Heritage Alerts May 2011
Khimsar Fort in
Rajasthan is more than
just a heritage
destination; it exudes
the charm and warmth of
true Marwari hospitality
as enjoyed by its
rulers.Navneet
Mendiratta tells us more
about the place
Treat the guest as your
God and you’d never go
wrong...” So said the
king to his staff when
he decided to turn his
“property” into a hotel.
The property was no less
than a fort in a thikana
called Kheewsar (now
called Khimsar) and
located some 40 kms from
Jodhpur in Rajasthan.
And the hotel was as big
as nine rooms. Needless
to say his loyal praja
followed their hukam’s
word and the feedback
book of the now over 60
rooms fort is full of
praises for the service
here. “Exemplary”, says
one. The others compete
with each other for some
really happy
superlatives.
There was much pride in
Hari Singh’s voice as he
recalled the words of
his Thakur. But, then,
this is how the people
of this little kingdom
feel for the royal
family. Their
generations have been
attached to the family
in some form or the
other and never in their
wildest dreams did they
ever consider moving
away. Not till lately,
when the younger
generation got ambitious
and chose to migrate to
other cities in search
of more challenging
prospects of employment.
However, it is not the
employment opportunities
that were on my mind as
I sat at the rooftop
restaurant of Khimsar
Fort. Thought I’d much
rather enjoy the famed
Marwari hospitality, the
golden sun and the era
gone by.
Laidback holiday
destination
Never wonder what to do
if you wish to enjoy
your offbeat
destination. Instead,
let it choose what to do
with you — this is what
a mad-nomad friend had
said to me years ago,
much before the travel
bug bit me. The mantra
has worked well with me
for years now and as I
sat figuring how to plan
my day, I was suddenly
reminded of my friend.
Khimsar is one such
destination. Planned in
a way that the guests
get to spend as much
time with themselves,
the focus is on what a
guest would like to do.
Now, this throws open a
lot of choices and I
wasn’t wasting any time
weighing mine.
I didn’t have to hunt
for someone to take me
on a guided tour. Dilip
Rao, manager of the
fort, happily
volunteered to show me
around. The property has
just about everything
that one would need to
hold on to the place. To
begin with, there is a
swimming pool, a
fetching spa, a gym
fitted with the latest
equipment, a cozy home
theatre, indoor and
outdoor games options,
shopping stops and
lovely restaurants to
feed you the wonderful
food. I was quite
impressed by the
affordability of the
services at the spa
(Mirage, as it is
called). And I would
have certainly given in
to the temptation had
Rao not suggested me to
take a safari into the
village and watch sunset
at the dunes. The dunes?
I wondered, now here was
my surprise.
On a wild buck chase
My driver was very
discreet, politely
answering my queries but
never speaking out of
turn. This was very
unlike the guides
showing me around the
wildlife at any other
destination. He reminded
me of a tiger who knew
his territory well. And
here were no
disappointments as the
promised wildlife
sighting was only
blackbucks and Nilgai,
both of which I saw in
plenty. Now, whether
this was because he’s
been chauffeuring the
royal family in the days
when it was legal to
hunt, I had no ways of
knowing. As he steered
the four-wheel drive
through the dry desert
terrain, I was impressed
by the smattering of
green every few miles.
“That’s the desi jeera
(cumin seeds) crop,” he
told me, warming up to
the topic of agriculture
in the region. “We also
grow mustard here and
some wheat. The water of
the land is sweet and
the gods have been
generous with rainfall
in the previous season.
We should be lucky to
get a good harvest,” he
said. To my left, a
colourful Rajasthani
scarecrow in a field
caught my eye. “Would
you like to visit a
dhaani, sa?” he asked
me. I nodded
immediately.
Dhaani is a cluster of
hutments that makes for
a single unit of
dwelling. Hukmi, a young
girl of 12 years, was
grinding some fresh
grain when we stopped
by. She happily led me
on a guided tour,
showing me their guest
room, the kitchen, the
store-room and the
bedroom. Each of the
units was equipped with
the very basic of
amenities and neatly
coated in mud. The walls
were devoid of colour
and motifs with mirror
work filled in for
decoration. In a corner,
I noticed a much smaller
“model dhaani”. It
looked like child’s
play. On enquiring,
Hukmi shyly smiled.
The sun was beginning to
come down, my driver now
seemed a bit restless.
“Shall we head for the
dunes?” We soon moved
on.
Sands of time
This had to be the most
beautiful patch of
dunes, after Jaisalmer’s
Sam, I thought to
myself. I could be wrong
in making comparisons,
but I certainly could
not hold my thoughts
back. I could see the
sun softening its glow,
playing with the colours
red and orange. I
climbed up the camel
cart that was waiting to
take me up the dunes.
“I’d be waiting here,
sa. You please take your
time,” said my escort as
the restless camel began
to pull me away from the
parked vehicle. This is
one place that makes you
realise that the
traditional transport
still scored over the
modern machine, that
there are still places
where technology cannot
hold its own. At a
distance, I could see a
small shack, where I
figured I’d be served my
evening tea. Tired, I
looked forward to a hot
cuppa.
Atop the dunes, one of
the most amazing sights
awaited me. Hidden
behind this curtain of
sand was a small
“village” with a mirage
of a water body. This
was the Khimsar Sand
Dunes Village, a cluster
of some 16 cottages
spread over an area of
about 60 acres. Rustic
in appearance, these
huts have been
deliberately designed to
be eco-friendly. “These
dunes are called Alka
and there are seven of
these,” another
attendant told me as he
served me tea. The sun
gently bid its golden
goodbye. Next to me, a
foreigner couple held
hands sighing at the
beautiful end to an
active day. I couldn’t
help but agree more.
Back at the fort, it was
an evening of more magic
what with folk singers
regaling the guests with
the raw desert strains
near the old ruins which
have now been converted
into a dining space.
Somewhere along, a
magician surprised his
audience with his “haath
ki safaai” and a
puppeteer shared his
craft notes. It really
is difficult to pull
reason out of magic or
should that be vice
versa?
Heritage weds
modernity
It was only natural that
we discussed the tales
from the past when I met
up with Bhanwar
Dhananjai Singh over
high tea the following
day. A really young
prince (he is all of 25
years), he looked every
bit involved with the
property. “With my
father, Kunwar Gajendra
Singh, being busy with
his political assignment
(he’s the elected
representative from
Nagaur district), the
responsibility of the
fort has fallen on me.
All of which I am
enjoying immensely,” he
shared.
But first some family
history: Founded in the
early 16th century, the
Karamsot dynasty has a
long lineage of capable
rulers who fought hard
battles but “lived with
grace and dignity”. Rao
Karamsiji was the eighth
son of Rao Jodhaji who
was the founder of
Jodhpur. He established
his kingdom between his
brothers — the Maharajas
of Jodhpur and Bikaner.
The construction of the
fort commenced in 1523
AD in the fairytale land
of majestic forts and
palaces. Thus began the
dynasty of the Karamsot
Rathores.
And this viraasat is
something Bhanwar
Dhananjai Singh is keen
to preserve. “Dunes hold
a special place in my
heart. I am looking at
converting some of the
area into a boutique
experience that is very
basic and yet luxurious
at the same time. Here
you are really close to
nature minus the
technical trappings like
a TV or a mobile and yet
something that does not
compromise on
hospitality. I plan to
host a world music fest
combined with vintage
car rally this year. God
willing, I should be
able to convert it into
an annual affair,” he
shared.
For a very brief while,
his mother, Preeti
Kumari, joined us. She
was on her way to the
dunes with some guests.
“These are the people I
grew up with. I am
meeting them after
years. Happy memories
are all worth this time
spent together,” she
said. I nodded in
agreement. Soon, it was
time for me to make a
move. I wish my host
luck as I bid adieu.
Yores from the past
I walked back the
pathways that led to the
turrets, ruins, stables,
guns and cannons. I
stopped by an ancient
Shiva temple and sought
blessings. It is said
this temple was
established after Rao
Karamsi dreamt of the
Lord. Further up are the
figurines of ninth
century Jain gods and
goddesses carved in
sandstone and defaced by
the Mughal ruler
Aurangzeb.
The ruins, as I referred
to them, make for Fateh
Mahal — named after
Fateh Pir Baba, a great
sufi saint who blessed
the family. It is said
that after his death,
the saint was buried
adjoining the fort
walls. Fateh Mahal was
under construction as a
personal residence next
to his tomb. The ruling
chief died during the
phase. Superstition had
it that the saint’s
spirit was not in peace.
Hence, the building was
left incomplete. Today
these ruins provide an
exquisite experience — a
glimpse of the bygone
era.
Another story that
caught my fancy was
pertaining to one of the
ancestors of the ruling
family. The Thakur, it
is said, had a unique
way of delivering
justice. The accused
would be taken to the
jails where the Thakur
would beat him black and
blue and later, when the
accused showed genuine
signs of remorse, he’d
be fed with ghee and
nursed back to health.
So much for royal
eccentricities.
Getting there
By Air The
nearest airport from
Khimsar is Jodhpur,
around 92 km away. Most
domestic carriers
connect Jodhpur with
Delhi, Jaipur and Mumbai
through regular flights.
The airport is located
around 6 km off the city
centre.
By Rail The
nearest railhead is
Jodhpur on the Western
Railway broad-gauge
network. Jodhpur is
linked to various
centres in the region by
express and passenger
trains. New Delhi, Agra,
Jaisalmer, Jaipur,
Udaipur and Ahmedabad
are some of the
important cities that
are linked with Jodhpur
through rail.
By Road Khimsar
is situated around 92 km
from the
Jodhpur-Nagaur-Bikaner
Highway. State transport
corporation buses and
private buses connect
Khimsar with other
centres in the region.
Local Transport Buses,
taxis and jeeps are
available on hire to
enable tourists to visit
the places around
Khimsar.
The Pioneer, 1st May 2011
Several monuments
built by the Mughals are
dedicated to women.
Taj Mahal, the most
famous of them all, was
built by Shah Jahan for
his queen Mumtaz in
Agra. Azam Shah, son of
Aurangzeb, built Bibi ka
Maqbara in Aurangabad as
a tribute to his mother,
Dilras Bano Begum. Baz
Bahadur built a pavilion
for his Hindu queen
Roopmati in Mandu. And
Ghiyasuddin Khilji built
the Jahaz Mahal, also in
Mandu, for his countless
paramours.
The character of
Ghiyasuddin Khilji has
always intrigued me. The
eldest son and right
hand man of Mahmud
Khilji, he did not lack
courage. But having
spent most of his time
in battlefields, he
refused to touch the
sword after he was
crowned king. Instead,
he authorised his eldest
son Nasir-uddin, the
heir-apparent, to reign
on his behalf.
Ghiyasuddin was ardently
religious and never
missed his prayers. He
even prayed at midnight
and ordered his
attendents to throw him
out of bed if he did not
wake up!
He also had great affection for animals and birds. One day, he discovered a mouse in his bedroom. But, instead of ordering it to be killed, he told the attendents to feed it regularly. He treated the pigeons and parrots who strayed into the palace the same way.
Unlike other kings,
Ghiyasuddin never
touched wine or any
other intoxicant. There
are many amusing stories
in the Wakiat-I-Mushtaki
about it. Once when
Ghiyasuddin fell ill,
the royal physician made
up a special medicine
for him. But Ghiyasuddin
refused to touch it
without knowing what the
ingredients were. So the
physician read out the
entire list comprising
300 components which
included poppy seeds. A
shocked Ghiyasuddin
ordered the medicine to
be thrown away
immediately.
“But the ingredients
cost me almost a lakh of
rupees” cried the royal
physician.“That cannot
be helped” said
Ghiyasuddin, “I cannot
forsake my principle for
the sake of money.”
“Then please allow me to
give it to other
patients who cannot
afford it,” pleaded the
physician. “Never!”
cried Ghiyasuddin, “What
the king cannot have
will not be given to
another living soul!”
The biggest passion in
Ghiyasuddin’s life,
however, were women. All
biographers agree that
he was practically
obsessed with the fair
sex. He had countless
beautiful women in his
harem for whom he built
the Jahaz Mahal and the
Hindola Mahal. Thousands
among them were “in his
service”. This is how
historian Firishta
describes it: “Among
them (women) were school
teachers, musicians,
dancers, embroiderers,
women to read prayers
and women of all trades
and professions. 500
young turkish girls in
uniform, armed with bows
and arrows which they
could use, stood on his
right. On his left stood
500 Abyssinian girls
with fire arms.”
Jahangir also writes in
his Memoirs: “He
(Ghiyasuddin) had a
whole city of women
comprising soldiers,
magistrates, qazis,
kotwals and whatever
else is necessary for
the administration of a
town. He taught the
women all kinds of arts
and crafts including
hunting and took some of
them along when he went
to hunt deer.”
Ghiyasuddin reigned for
31 years. His death is
one of the most brutal
and pathetic episodes in
the history of Mandu.
Although Nasiruddin
enjoyed all the powers
of a king, he bitterly
resented the presence of
his father, now getting
on in years. Crazy to
sit on his father’s
throne, he tried to
poison him twice. But
his attempt failed
because Ghiyasuddin
always carried a zahar
muhra (poison antidote).
Moreover, Nasir’s hatred
was so obvious that
Ghiyasuddin realised
what he was after and
threw away the poisoned
sherbet on both
occasions. Finally,
Nasir-ud-din decided to
take destiny into his
own hands and carried
the cup of poison
himself and ordered him
to drink it.
Ghiyasuddin looked at
his son and read the
greed and ambition in
his eyes. He took the
cup from him and took
off the zahar muhra from
his arm and threw it on
the floor. He knelt down
for the last time and
breathed his last prayer
to God: “Oh Lord
Almighty! My time has
arrived and I have
passed my years in
prosperity and happiness
rarely attained by any
king. Now, since this is
my last prayer, I beg on
my knees that thou shalt
not blame my son Nasir
as my murderer; that
thou shalt take my death
as something destined by
thee.”
Then he drank the
poisoned cup of sherbet
at a gulp and delivered
his soul to his creator.
This episode occurs in
the Memoirs of Jahangir
who keenly felt the
pathos of the situation.
He also writes about how
Sher Afghan felt about
it: “When Sher Afghan
came to the tomb of
Nasir-ud-din during his
reign, he ordered the
tomb to be beaten up
with sticks because of
what Nasir did to his
father.” Jahangir, who
loved his own father
dearly, adds: “When I
went to Nasir’s tomb, I
too gave it several
kicks.”
Nasir-ud-din is said to
have had a miserable
time attending to
domestic feuds galore
and finally died of a
painful disease.
Jahaz Mahal,
Ghiyasuddin’s
magnificent creation,
remains as beautiful as
ever, attracting
tourists throughout the
year.
Deccan Herald, 1st May 2011
A lock of salt-and-pepper hair said to have been clipped from the flowing beard of Rabindranath Tagore after his death in 1941 is on exhibition here, near the town of Totnes, to observe the 150th birth anniversary of the first non-white and the only Indian Nobel laureate for literature.
"To the best of my knowledge, this is the first time this is being exhibited," said Andy Christian, curator of Dartington Hall Trust, whose creation as a venture in rural regeneration was inspired by Tagore.
The hair, dug out of the archives and not as white as photographs of the poet suggest, is inside a small, transparent plastic packet, with "Sir Rabindranath" (he relinquished his title after the Jallianwala massacre in 1919) hand-written in ink on a white slip of paper.
Last year, Dartington bosses had auctioned 12 of Tagore's paintings and had decided to hold the clipped hair for this year.
According to Christian, the 1913 Nobel winner's son, Rathindranath, sent the hair to Tagore's close friend Leonard Elmhirst, who, with his American heiress wife, Dorothy, acquired Dartington Hall.
Prior to sending a portion of Tagore's beard to Elmhirst, Rathindranath had cabled the latter informing him of his father's death; and this is also a part of the exhibition. The telegram apparently took a few days to arrive, for this was only received on August 9, 1941. It said: ELMHIRST DARTINGTON HALL TOTNES FATHER PASSED AWAY THURSDAY NOON. RATHI. Tagore had died on July 30.
Elmhirst was from Barnsley in north-east England. He was smitten by Tagore when he met him while studying at Cornell University in the United States as an agricultural economist. Between 1921 and 1924 he worked in Santiniketan as the poet's private secretary as well as to establish a rural farm school at neighbouring Sriniketan. He also travelled with Tagore on goodwill missions to China and South America.
Tagore, who had invited Elmhirst to join him in India, was clearly pleased that he accepted. He telegrammed from Santiniketan on September 10, 1921: ELMHIRST BARNSLEY DELIGHTED COME INVITATION HOLDS RABINDRA-NATH TAGORE.
In a letter to the Dartington Hall Trust in 1976 when she was prime minister, Indira Gandhi (a Santiniketan alumnus) wrote: "There was a beautiful friendship between Tagore and Leonard Elmhirst. Tagore's Viswa Bharati owes much to Elmhirst's understanding and generosity." Elmhirst addressed Tagore as Gurudev, who conferred him the title of 'Desika'.
The glimpse of a
piece of Tagore's beard
has aroused curiosity in
a section of British
media. The exhibition
runs until 28 of June.
Times of India, 2nd May 2011
News of financial approval for the Delhi Metro’s phase 3 by the Delhi government has prompted the Delhi Urban Arts Commission (DUAC) to register its objection with the DMRC for the latter not following the statutory procedure. In April, the Delhi cabinet had given its nod to the Metro’s proposal for phase 3.
While the state government has already earmarked R1,071crore for phase 3, the Centre has made provision for R580 crore in Budget 2011-12.
DUAC is a regulatory body for maintaining urban aesthetics, in view of the many heritage monuments in the city. As per established procedure, the financial sanction for a project is accorded only after it has received all mandatory clearances, including DUAC nod.
Sources said the DUAC was planning a public workshop on Metro phase III, considering that the alignment has both the underground segment (running through the heritage corridor) and elevated stretches (that could have a direct bearing on urban aesthetics).
One of the lines of phase 3, joining Central Secretariat to Kashmiri Gate via Mandi House, ITO, Delhi Gate and Red Fort, passes through a heritage corridor with over 24 monuments.
There are 67 stations proposed under the third phase and around 41 km of the line would be underground, while the remaining 67 km is planned as elevated. “But it (the public workshop) can’t be held till the DMRC gives documents to us,” the sources added.
The DUAC’s annual report for the year 2009-10, presented in Parliament, had also pointed out violations. In its chapter on ‘Transport Proposals’, the DUAC is critical of sanctions for Metro proposals, brought to it after more than half the construction was over.
The report said, “It is unfortunate that the aforesaid DMRC proposals (constructed without the statutory clearances) were accorded financial sanction. Such practice needs to be checked to discourage project proponents from violating the established statutory provisions laid down for approval of projects.”
The report further pointed out, “It has been observed that the DMRC has been constantly violating the DUAC Act, which, as per the law of the land, is a mandatory requirement for all agencies, including Delhi Metro.”
KT Ravindran, DUAC chairperson, agreed that the commission wrote to the Delhi Metro last week, following media reports. “The law says that before financial clearance is given to any project, all statutory clearances are required,” Ravindran said.
DMRC confirmed the
receipt of the letter.
Its spokesperson said,
“We don’t need their
(DUAC’s) approval for
it.”
Hindustan Times, 2nd May 2011
The book, unmistakably a labour of love for the author, is a detailed study of the biodiversity of two national parks, Nagarahole and Bandipur, in Karnataka. The floral and faunal distribution, ecological setting, and the similarities and variations between the two are well documented and highlighted through tables, photographs, and satellite imagery. All of this covers 150 pages. But a chunk of the book — the first 92 pages — is, sadly, a hackneyed narration of the global climate change crisis interspersed with activist rhetoric like “Greening the Earth to Prevent Red”.
Going by the way climate change and biodiversity conservation have been treated, the title is somewhat misleading. Although the author, Basappanavar, asserts that the two are intertwined — which, in fact, they are — there is little attempt to examine how climate change would affect, or has already affected, the country's biodiversity in general and the two study areas in particular. More importantly, how conservation of biodiversity will help mitigate the adverse effects of climate change has not been gone into in any scientific detail. Thus, the two parts of the book stand disjointedly, and this deficiency perhaps may be addressed in a revised edition. Enough published material is available — on the impact of climate change on India's forests over the last hundred years, on what may happen to them as a result of rising temperatures, and on global initiatives like REDD (Reduction in Deforestation and Degradation) and India's REDD+ (REDD PLUS) proposal — for the author to draw from.
WEALTH OF
INFORMATION
These shortcomings and
sweeping statements
aside, the book provides
a wealth of information
on Nagarahole and
Bandipur. The two parks
forming a contiguous
geographical area in the
southern part of the
Western Ghats are an
interesting study at
once in similarity and
in contrast. The average
annual rainfall of
Nagarahole is 1,389 mm,
whereas Bandipur
receives 400 mm less.
Mean annual temperatures
are, however, the same
(22.67ºC). These two
factors may well explain
the differing relative
extents of forest
ecotypes in the two
parks.
The higher rainfall of Nagarahole accounts for its higher percentage of Moist Deciduous Forest (44 per cent) compared to only 10.66 per cent in Bandipur. In consequence, the Dry Deciduous forest area is much more (67.05 per cent) in Bandipur than in Nagarahole (41 per cent). The higher rainfall, as the author says, also accounts for the floristic richness of Nagarahole, which, in turn, may explain its higher densities of large herbivores and their predators. This establishes the “eco-biological” relationship of rainfall regime governing total bio-volume and the herbaceous biomass, which, in turn, determines herbivorous prey base and predator populations.
OPTIMAL HABITATS
An interesting
conclusion Basappanavar
draws is that the two
parks are in a near
“bio-equilibrium” state
and may well be
described as “optimal
habitats” for large
herbivores. That this is
so despite heavy human
pressures renders it all
the more important to
keep them in that state.
This, indeed, is a
challenge to the
authorities manning the
two parks. It emerges
that the utilisation of
the “carrying capacity”
is already at its
maximum in both parks.
Hence practices like
grazing by cattle from
outside and diversion of
land for non-forest
purposes have to be
curbed severely.
Promotion of tourism (in today's parlance “eco-tourism”) has to be consistent with these imperatives. As the author observes, “Eco-tourism in India has become almost synonymous with overcrowding, polluting, littering…” Overemphasis on eco-tourism in these two parks — in any nature reserve, for that matter — is bound to be counterproductive. Also, issues related to the settling of the so-called “forest dwellers” permanently in areas rich in wildlife should be subjected to a critical appraisal.
Basappanavar may well
include in his study the
Nilgiris Biosphere
Reserve, which is
contiguous to what has
been covered, so that
one could have a grand
picture of the
fascinating forest
ecosystems of the
southern part of the
Western Ghats. With his
knowledge and vast
experience, he should be
able to do it. India's
forests and national
parks deserve a lot of
scientific nurturing for
all the goods, services,
and aesthetic pleasure
they provide for its
people and foreign
visitors alike.
The Hindu, 3rd May 2011
A sound-and-light
show on the history of
the princely state of
Mysore will premiere in
the City of Palaces
somewhere in the third
week of May, the
organisers said.
The programme will debut
in Kannada, and later in
Hindi and English
languages. The ‘son et
lumiere’ show, one of
the ambitious projects
of the Mysore Palace
Board, will depict the
rich history of Mysore —
the life and times of
Yaduraya, his
successors, and the
reign of Jayachamaraja
Wadiyar, the last ruler
of the Wadiyar dynasty.
The programme did have
its share of hiccups and
controversies, leading
to its delay. With the
hurdles now removed,
Srikantadatta
Narasimharaja Wadiyar,
the scion of the Mysore
royal family, has
approved the script.
The 50-minute capsule
will add to the beauty
of the majestic Amba
Vilas Palace built in
the Indo-Saracenic
style, P V Avaradi,
Deputy Director of the
Palace Board, told
Deccan Herald.
Several noted
personalities like
Kannada actors Jayanthi,
the late Vishnuvardhan,
C H Ambareesh and Master
Hiranaiah have rendered
their voices to the show
that will be organised
in front of the palace
two days a week from 7
pm to 8 pm, he said.
The show has been
scripted in such a way
that no artistes are
involved in it. People
will only listen to the
commentary on the
history of Mysore, and
witness lighting skills
on the imposing palace,
Avaradi said.
The entry fee is likely
to be Rs 50 per head.
The show will not be
held on Saturdays and
Sundays because of the
illumination of the
palace.
Avaradi said
Krishnakumar, the brain
behind the show, will
arrive in the city this
week to give it the
final touches. The
deputy commissioner,
also the
member-secretary of the
Palace Board, has given
the green signal for the
launch of the show which
is expected to kick off
on May 15, according to
Avaradi.
The Hindi and the
English versions of the
show will be launched
after June. The whole
idea behind the show is
to explain to tourists
the rich history of the
Wadiyar dynasty that
ruled the princely State
of Mysore for four
centuries and also made
remarkable contributions
for the overall
development of the
erstwhile Mysore State
in general, and Mysore
City in particular,
Avaradi said.
Deccan Herald, 3rd May 2011
The Bisale forest
and Manjarabad Fort in
Sakleshpur taluk are two
must-visit spots on
every traveller’s
itinerary. But, what is
unfortunate is that the
walls of the fort, and
the watch tower at
Bisale are marred by
ugly graffiti. Also,
plastic covers and empty
bottles are strewn all
over the place, ruining
the natural beauty of
the region, reports
Shyam Sundar Vattam
Rare flora and fauna,
rivulets and the
breathtaking view of
Brahmagiri, Pushpagiri
and Kumara Parvatha
peaks...We are talking
about the beautiful
Bisale forest and
Manjarabad Fort, close
to Sakleshpur and
nestled in the
biodiversity hub, the
Western Ghats.
Entering the Bisale
forest and standing at
the highest point here,
you can see green
mountains touching the
sky. Watching the clouds
kiss the peak of the
Brahmagiri Parvatha is a
visual treat. The
Department of Forests
has constructed a watch
tower for visitors to
feast on the serene
beauty of the region.
This spot is situated
just by the side of the
State Highway (from
Sakleshpur to
Subrahmanya. The famous
Kukke Subrahmanya is
hardly 24 km from this
place). During the rainy
season, the tiny streams
and rivulets add to the
drama of the place.
This spot is just 13 km
from Vanagooru village
and it takes at least 45
minutes to one hour to
reach it because of a
bad connecting road.
There are countless
number of potholes
because of which no
private bus operates on
this road. The KSRTC
operates five buses from
Subrahmanya to various
destinations daily.
Locals depend on private
jeeps and KSRTC buses
for their daily commute.
A project for the
improvement of this road
was shelved following a
change in the government
some years back. The bad
road is one of the
reasons why tourists do
not want to take the
risk of visiting the
Bisale point. If the
road is developed, more
people will definitely
visit this spot, points
out Goddu Umesh, a
resident of Vanagooru
who is part of a forum
engaged in the ‘Save the
Western Ghats’
agitation.
Writing on the
wall...
Typical of all tourist
spots in the country,
the permanent structure
at the highest point is
full of graffiti.
Tourists who visit this
spot write their names,
mobile numbers and
messages on the walls,
stone chairs and
pillars, thus making the
whole area look ugly.
Besides, plastic covers
and empty bottles are
strewn all over the
place and the spot, it
seems, is not cleaned
regularly. Posting of
security personnel and a
strict ban on plastic
items inside the place
will further enhance the
beauty of the spot.
Manjarabad Fort
Situated just five km
from the town,
Manjarabad Fort is
definitely worth a
visit. It is 3,240 ft
above sea level. Trek up
to the summit of the
fort and you can see tea
plantations and vast
paddy fields stretching
up to 40 km in the
distance. One has to
trek about a half km
from Donigal to reach
the fort.
There are 253 steps to
reach the top. The fort
is more than 200 years
old and is a protected
monument. The
Archeological Survey of
India is responsible for
the maintenance of this
fort.
It is constructed in the
shape of a star. In the
middle of the fort,
there is a pond with
steps on all the four
sides. Tipu Sultan, the
Tiger of Mysore, built
this fort more than two
centuries ago. It has
withstood the vagaries
of nature for all these
years. The fort is open
for visitors between 8
am and 6 pm.
But the graffiti on the
walls of this historic
fort tells a sorry
story. Not a wall in the
fort has been spared the
ugliness of graffiti.
The small rooms inside
the forest have been
converted into toilets
by miscreants. The
lights installed near
the steps have been
damaged. There is dirt
and filth everywhere.
One hopes the ASI takes
steps to clean up the
fort, and restore it to
its original glory.
A pond in the middle of
the fort may have been
constructed for the
benefit of soldiers. Now
the pond is choking with
weeds. An excavation by
the ASI may help in
ascertaining the source
of water.
The need of the hour is
to conserve this fort
for the coming
generations. It would be
of interest to find out
how Tipu selected this
spot because it is
situated in the midst of
forests and hidden from
the outside world.
‘No projects please’
Local people have urged
the government not to
allow any hydel project
in the taluk as it would
cause irreparable damage
to the environment.
Already, enough damage
has been done to the
flora and fauna in the
region and it is high
time that the remaining
forest be conserved.
Sakleshpur has something
to offer for all kinds
of visitors,
predominantly nature
lovers.
Evergreen forests for
trekkers, rivulets and
small streams for
rafting, temples and
heritage structures for
research buffs. All
these are tucked away in
this small taluk in
Hassan district.
Sakleshpur is situated
on the
Bangalore-Mangalore
National Highway.
Traditionally a
coffee-growing area, it
has tea and spice
plantations all along
the highway. Assured
rainfall every year has
made this area resemble
a green carpet. In spite
of the large-scale
destruction of forests
in the name of power
generation, Sakleshpur
taluk still has
something in its kitty
to offer for nature
lovers.
A trip to this taluk is
incomplete without
visiting Bisale forest,
Manjarabad Fort,
Mookanamane Abbi and
umpteen number of small
natural falls.
Deccan Herald, 3rd May 2011
I was confused as I
looked at the museum
building in front of the
Gol Gumbaz, which is
similar to the Gol
Gumbaz. As soon as I
entered the mausoleum a
deafening sound greeted
me. Visitors were
clapping, whistling,
shouting, singing and
making strange sounds
just to be noticed. The
dome has wonderful
acoustics that reflects
even the tiniest sound
several times back and
forth. Unfortunately
there is no bar on
visitors making all
sorts of sounds that
takes away the pleasure
of being in one of the
largest domed buildings
in the world built in
the year 1659 AD by the
famous architect, Yaqut
of Dabul. Most visitors
forget that it is a
mausoleum built to inter
the body of Adil Shah
dynasty ruler Muhammad
Adil Shah and a few
members of the royal
family.
The structure consists
of a massive square
chamber measuring nearly
50 meters on each side
and covered by a huge
dome 38 meters in
diameter making it among
one of the largest dome
structures in world. It
covers one of the
biggest single chamber
spaces in the world over
an area of 1,703 square
meters.
The acoustics of the
enclosed place make it a
whispering gallery where
even the smallest sound
is heard across the
other side of the
Gumbaz. However, if you
want to experience the
echo effect, it would be
a rare day when there
are very few visitors.
Each tower consists of
seven storeys and the
upper floor of each
opens on to a round
gallery, which surrounds
the dome.
The view from each of
these galleries is
interesting. In the
centre of the chamber is
a square raised podium
approached by steps in
the centre of each side.
In the centre of the
podium are the tombs of
Muhammad Adil Shah II,
his two queens, son,
daughter and
court-dancer Rambha. The
actual graves lie in the
cellar beneath the
podium. Bijapur is about
580 km from Bangalore
and is well connected by
road and rail. One can
walk or hire a
taxi/auto-rickshaw to
reach the site of the
Gol Gumbaz.
Nurturing classical
dance forms
Nrityagrama is a unique
place where classical
dance is nurtured. The
centre is located at
Hesaraghatta, about 35
km from Bangalore, and
is the brainchild of
legendary classical
dancer Protima Gauri who
famously said, “Either
you dance or die.”
The sprawling campus of
10 acres has a beautiful
landscape and is based
on the traditional
Gurukul model of
teaching.
At Nrityagrama, students
are expected to grow
vegetables, fruits ,
cook, and serve their
gurus.
Vasantahabba is an
annual dance festival
celebrated here during
February. People from
across the globe attend
the celebration along
with legendary artists.
More than 40,000 people
gather to witness the
Vasantahabba.
This township of dance
is open to the public
from Tuesday to Sunday
(from 10 am to 2 pm) and
is closed on Mondays and
government holidays.
There are plenty of BMTC
buses from Bangalore to
Hesaraghatta.
From Hesaraghatta, you
can hop into an auto and
reach Nrityagrama. There
is no accommodation for
visitors but visitors
can avail the services
of nearby hotels.
Nrityagrama is an
interesting weekend
getaway for those in
Bangalore.
Deccan Herald, 3rd May 2011
Short-circuit may
be the reason
Station master’s
residence, office,
machinery and crucial
records burnt
Probe begins; report
within 10 days
The 108-year-old
Kandaghat railway
station, which is part
of the Kalka-Shimla
heritage railway track,
was burnt in a
devastating fire which
broke out past midnight
around 1.15 am.
Though the exact cause of the fire was not known, officials said a short-circuit was likely to be the reason as the entire station was burnt.
Kandaghat SDM Raman Sharma, who was among the first officials to reach there, said fire tenders were requisitioned from Solan and fire was doused around 5:30 am this morning.
With the Railways facing a shortage of staff, night duty had been discontinued for the past few days. So the fire could not be reported in time. The station master lost cash, valuables and furniture worth Rs 10 lakh as his son had recently got married.
Locals revealed that the son of the station master, who was sleeping in the official residence located on the campus, was the first to sense that some fire had broken out as he saw smoke rising. He then informed the officials and fire tenders were summoned from Solan.
The tenders, however, took one-and-a-half hour to reach the spot, thus leaving enough time for the fire to spread. As the station did not have adequate water to douse the fire, it soon spread and engulfed the entire station, including the canteen, station master’s residence, the office, machinery as well as crucial records.
Two cylinders present in the canteen also blasted due to the fire.
Senior officials of the Railways, including DRM Pradeep Kumar from Ambala and senior officials from Shimla, arrived here early this morning to take stock of the situation.
The DRM told mediapersons that a committee comprising the assistant operations manager, assistant engineer, assistant electrical engineer and assistant commissioner, security, had started enquiring into the incident and they would submit a report within 10 days.
With inadequate water, precious time was lost as tenders had to be refilled from Solan and this delayed the fire-fighting operations.
The railway traffic was, however, running as usual as there was no loss to the track, said officials. The communication system was, however, disrupted after the incident, but it was restored by the afternoon.
The fire has exposed the lack of inept handling of fire incidences as it was only after the station master’s son felt suffocated that he ventured out to discover its cause. No employee was present on duty who could have detected the fire in the initial stage.
Though occurrence of
fires was a common
feature on this track,
the Railways appears to
be ill-equipped to
handle such situations
thus leading to losses.
The Tribune, 4th May 2011
Despite being home to several important historical buildings, it seems Delhi does not take pride in its heritage monuments. Whether it is the widespread instance of grafitti on age-old structures or cases in which heritage buildings have been encroached upon, the city is not exactly friendly towards its heritage. And now there’s proof of this.
According to data released by the government on Tuesday, there are more than 1,000 unprotected monuments in Delhi. These are apart from 174 heritage monuments and structures under the protection of the Archaeological Survey of India. According to the National Mission on Monuments and Antiquities — established to prepare a national database on monuments from secondary sources — Delhi has as many as 1,180 unprotected monuments.
There are approximately 3,650 monuments and remains of archaeological sites under the protection of Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) across the country, a number far lower than the actual wealth of tangible heritage.
The National Mission on Monuments and Antiquities (NMMA) was launched in March 2007 to document this heritage.
Around a decade ago, conservation NGO, Indian National Trust for Arts and Cultural Heritage had come up with a listing of 1,200-odd heritage buildings, monuments, structures and remains across the Capital. These included 174 under ASI.
It's the first time that the government has officially acknowledged that there are 1,000 unprotected monuments in the national capital.
"It is a good thing,” said AGK Menon, Indian National Trust for Arts and Cultural Heritage (INTACH), Delhi chapter head. “They (the government) are beginning to recognise the importance of understanding the dimensions of heritage in the country," Menon added.
"The Shahjahanabad Redevelopment Corporation (SRDC) has been identified as the documentation resource centre (DRC) for NMMA in Delhi,” said a senior Delhi government official.
“It will carry out various outreach programmes such as heritage walks, photo exhibitions and multimedia publicity programmes," the official added. Rajasthan, with 5,220 unprotected sites tops the list, followed by Uttar Pradesh with 3,653 sites and West Bengal with 3,627 sites.
The total number of
unprotected monuments
across the country, so
far, is 33,826.
Hindustan Times, 4th May 2011
New structure to
be built as per original
design: Officials
With the exact cause of
the fire which damaged
the Kandaghat railway
station on Monday night
yet to be confirmed, a
four-member team of
officials has started an
inquiry into the
incident.
The restoration work was, however, begun to put in place a temporary structure which would house a rest room and a ticketing system for passengers. Since the section yielded a revenue of almost Rs 1.5 lakh per month, the railway authorities had begun the work on a priority.
A visit to the site revealed that officials of the engineering wing comprising assistant engineer and works inspector were preparing drawings of the new structure after selecting a new site.
As an immediate measure, a tent and some chairs were arranged at the site to facilitate the passengers. Since this was the peak tourist season, the number of passengers had grown by almost 20 to 25 per cent.
The officials revealed that since the buildings which were razed in the fire were constructed during the British era, their restoration would be done on the same lines using wood and bricks.
They added that since the original drawings were available with them, they would reconstruct the new structure as per its original design. A final plan would be drawn up once the inquiry was complete.
Interestingly, doors and windows of the railway station would be painted dark blue like the remaining part of the station, while the building would be given crèam colour as it was an age-old tradition to match the colours of the trains with the buildings, revealed an official.
The ancient communication and track-control system, called the Neals Token Instrument System, which had been destroyed in the fire, had been replaced with a similar system.
Workers were seen removing the gutted portions of the canteen and main office so that the restoration work could begin. The officials said they were awaiting instructions from the DRM, Ambala, and proceeding as per the directions.
The rail traffic was plying as usual and the authorities had to reschedule a few trains yesterday morning. It was, however, restored by yesterday afternoon and trains were plying as per their usual schedule today.
In 1903, the rail
line was opened to
traffic by Indian
Viceroy Lord Curzon and
only Europeans were
allowed to avail the
facility.
The Tribune, 5th May 2011
Union Environment and
Forests Minister Jairam
Ramesh has urged
Minister of Defence AK
Antony to ensure that
the Defence Research and
Development Organisation
(DRDO) abides by the
clearance conditions
which were imposed by
the MoEF.
“I request for your
personal intervention to
ensure that DRDO
complies with the
conditions stipulated
when given approval for
use of the Wheeler
Island in 1993 and for
taking extra measures
suggested by the State
Forest Department in
protecting and
conserving the Wheeler
Island ecosystem as
well,” said Ramesh in a
recent letter to Antony
Operation Kachhapa
applauds the recent
initiative of Ramesh in
writing to the Union
Defence Minister to
abide by the clearance
conditions. These
conditions were imposed
by the MoEF while
allowing the use of the
Wheeler Island for
missile testing in 1993.
The MoEF had barred
testing of missiles from
Wheeler Island during
the breeding and nesting
season of sea turtles
said Coordinator,
Operation Kachhapa,
Biswajit Mohanty.
The turtle mass nesting
islands at Nasi are
perilously close to
Wheeler Island, which is
used by DRDO for testing
of missiles. However,
every year, bright
illumination and firing
of missiles during the
turtle breeding and
nesting season affects
the turtles. This year,
more than 2.5 lakh
turtles nested here.
In spite of consistent
requests by the State
Government to stop such
activities during the
nesting season from
November to March, the
DRDO continues with such
activities. Sea turtles
are extremely sensitive
to illumination and
bright lights.
Similarly, the
vibrations caused by
missile firing could
possible impact the
fragile egg shells of
lakhs of eggs, which are
buried in the sand in
the nesting beach.
The Pioneer, 5th May 2011
An expert committee will now determine the habitats
Stung by the criticism of forest rights activists, wildlife activists and scientists regarding its initial draft guidelines for determining critical wildlife habitats issued in February, the Environment Ministry has now come out with a revised version.
The Ministry was forced to withdraw the earlier guidelines on March 4 after protests that they would facilitate the forced relocation of forest dwellers and tribal communities from wildlife parks and sanctuaries.
Critical wildlife habitats (CWH) are defined under the Forest Rights Act, 2006, as the “areas of national parks and sanctuaries where it has been specifically and clearly established, case by case, on the basis of scientific and objective criteria, that such areas are required to be kept as inviolate for the purposes of wildlife conservation…”
In its preamble to the guidelines, the Ministry emphasised that it “is in no way intended to cause or force resettlement or relocation of Scheduled Tribes and Other Forest Dwellers from National Parks and Wildlife Sanctuaries,” in a bid to ease the concerns of activists.
The new guidelines envisage a bigger role for the gram sabha, whose free informed consent must be given before any relocation is carried out. It also seems to ensure that forest rights are settled under the FRA before a CWH can be declared in an area.
An expert committee – which includes members of the gram sabha, an ecologist, a tribal welfare NGO and a social scientist apart from the Forest Department's officers – will now take the main responsibility for determining the habitats. Under the earlier guidelines, the process was to be initiated by the park manager, with a token committee only involved in consultations with forest rights holders.
The new guidelines also provide for a National Steering Committee to take a final call on the notification of such habitats.
The Ministry has
invited comments and
suggestions from the
public over the next 30
days before it finalises
the guidelines.
The Hindu, 6th May 2011
After a long wait, the
area around 16th century
Nila Gumbad monument in
Nizamuddin will finally
bear a new look.
Northern Railways
approved the proposed
road layout planned by
the Archaeological
Survey of India (ASI)
and the Aga Khan Trust
for Culture (AKTC).
Officials said the
landscape and
conservation plans aimed
at re-intergrating Nila
Gumbad with the world
heritage site Humayun’s
Tomb can finally
commence. Heritage
conservationists said
Nila Gumbad is the
earliest Mughal-era
structure in Delhi and
originally stood in the
riverbed and was
accessible only through
the Humayun’s Tomb
complex.
ASI had relocated 400 squatters from this area in 2002 and since 2007, AKTC and ASI have been requesting for permission to shift a road segregating the site from Humayun’s tomb.
AKTC project manager Ratish Nanda said: “We are delighted that urgently needed conservation works can now be coupled with restoring portions of the original garde setting.’’
The railways own some land behind the Nila Gumbad monument and ASI for years had been asking permission to use 1 acre of it to realign a road — which divides Nila Gumbad from the Humayun’s Tomb complex — so that the two structures can be connected.
Related Posts
1. ASI-Intach row hits
Lodhi Garden structures’
facelift
2. Delhi: Railways
prunes plan for
commercial space in CP
3. Rain or shine, Bharat
Insurance building
weathers it all
4. Govt notifies NDMC
heritage
5. CWG Games coming, but
heritage sites not ready
The Times of India, 6th May 2011
Restoration work
under way; expected to
be complete in two years
Passing through
Tughlaqabad on the
Mehrauli-Badarpur Road
in the Capital, it is
easy to miss the
Adilabad Fort, tucked
away on a hillock on the
south-eastern side of
the better known
Tughlaqabad Fort.
Built by Ghiyas-ud-din Tughlaq's son Muhammad bin Tughlaq in the 14 {+t} {+h} Century, the Adilabad Fort forms the missing piece in the Tughlaqabad Fort-Ghiyas-ud-din tomb jigsaw. The fort has been restored from a state of complete ruin by the Archaeological Survey of India over the past two years.
“Work began on the fort about two years ago as part of the preparations for the Commonwealth Games,” says ASI conservation assistant Bhadur Chand who oversees work at the fort.
The restoration work involved gluing together big chunks that had fallen off the outer fortification wall and raising portions of the bastions inside. The inside boundary of the fort is lined with arches. Traditional materials like lime, surki, sand (Badarpur), urad daal and jaggery were used for reconstruction.
“Almost all of the palace area inside the fortification wall had collapsed,” says Bahadur Chand. “Many portions have been excavated and raised to a higher level.” Originally called Muhammadabad, the fort was later renamed Adilabad, with Adil meaning just. Architecturally Adilabad Fort is very similar to Tughlaqabad Fort, and has two gates overlooking the city on its south-east and south-western sides. The Tughlaqabad Fort, built by Ghiyas-ud-din, was connected with Ghiyas-ud-din's tomb through a causeway and with the Adilabad Fort through an embankment in its south-eastern corner. While the causeway has since given way to M. B. Road, the embankment land is now owned by the Delhi Development Authority.
One problem faced during the restoration work was lack of water in the area. “We checked the entire area around the fort, but there is almost no water available to be pulled up from the ground. We had to make do with a tanker of water from a nearby garden,” says Bahadur Chand.
According to Superintending Archaeologist (Delhi Circle) K. K. Muhammed, the ASI plans to restore as much of the original plan of the area as possible, including the causeways and water body. “If the DDA agrees to hand over the land, the ASI can plan integrated development,” he says. The next step is to illuminate the fort and Ghiyas-ud-din's Tomb, and eventually promote “eco-tourism” in the area.
Nearly Rs.2 crore has been spent on restoring Adilabad Fort in the past two years and complete restoration would require another Rs.3 crore, says Mr. Muhammed.
According to him, it
would take another two
years before restoration
work at Adilabad Fort is
complete. Once that is
done, ASI plans to
promote the area through
cultural activities,
much like what has been
done at Old Fort.
The Hindu, 7th May 2011
More than a museum
operation
Heritage is a word that
rolls easily off the
tongue these days. The
Railways have not lagged
behind, securing UNESCO
World Heritage status
for its mountain
systems, setting up
museums featuring old
locomotives and
carriages, coming up
with replications of the
royal saloons of
yesteryear in the shape
of the Palace on Wheels
tourist train. Even
reviving some steam
loco-sheds (for
instance, Rewari in
Haryana) to re-create
the magic of the
coal-fired “puffer
Billy”. Alas, it has
come up short in
preserving the aura of
historic systems still
in operational service.
Articulating that most
painfully is the
destruction of the
108-year-old Kandaghat
station on the
Kalka-Simla hill line in
a devastating fire a few
nights ago. True it was
an accident, but most
accidents are really the
result of negligence. A
feeling confirmed by
initial reports that an
electric short-circuit
provided the “spark” ~
short-circuits are often
the result of poorly
maintained wiring, and
it is not difficult to
imagine that scant
attention had been paid
to that aspect of the
old, mainly wooden
structure that reflected
traditional local
architectural norms.
Suspicions of negligence
are confirmed; in an
effort to overcome a
staff shortage there
were no personnel on
night duty ~ it was
quite some time before
the fire was noticed by
people living in the
station master’s
residence. The
fire-fighting
arrangements were
primitive, by the time
fire-tenders from Solan
reached Kandaghat the
building was a charred
ruin. Northern Railway
may pride itself that
operations were not
disrupted, alternative
arrangements for ticket
sales etc were quickly
made, but that does not
compensate for what was
lost ~ nothing ever
will.
It is so
apparent that “concerns”
with heritage are
superficial, top-heavy,
for the record-book
only. Having secured
UNESCO recognition for
the hill railway, was it
not imperative for the
authorities to be
extra-sensitive to the
threat from fire,
landslides and so on?
Efficient fire-fighting
systems ought to have
been in place ~ it is
myth that modern
facilities are taboo, or
militate against
“heritage”, they must be
installed with
sensitivity. Heritage
conservation is a
specialist business, it
does require expertise
to keep old systems
operationally efficient
without succumbing to a
“museum mindset.”
Clearly the Railways
have a lot to do. Not
just in “declared”
heritage sites but
elsewhere too, the
organisation does have a
glorious past. Even if
the less said about the
present the better.
The Statemsn, 8th May 2011
Jaipur's Jal Mahal
has been resurrected by
conservationists and
guarantees a high
definition digital
experience of the 16th
century. Next time you
are in town, drop
everything else as the
best of Jaipur's
heritage is finally
under one roof. Or
should we say on the
waters? Divya Kaushik
reports
A palace sits in the
middle of the lake,
cupolas lit by earthen
lamps, like a floating
ship of twinkling
lights. The water
shimmers, fuzzing out
the chimera of a
fire-spouting dragon
under water. Rajput
princesses make merry on
the windy pavilions,
while the Manganiyar
flautist sits on a
silent perch to make the
most soul-stirring music
against a setting sun.
Meanwhile, the ageing
maharaja, still
classical and purist in
his taste, watches a
Kalbelia dancer
silhouetted against the
cherry red sky and the
rugged hills, she
swirling with emotions,
he contemplating their
depths in the dark
waters around the
gazebo. Oarsmen dressed
in white Rajasthani
regalia and orange
turbans slosh up the
water to bring in the
musicians. The night is
young...
Circa 1600 could easily
be transposed on Circa
2011 as the Jal Mahal,
the pleasure palace of
the Jaipur royals
sitting on the Mansagar
lake, has been lovingly
restored. The waters
sparkle, the migratory
birds hum overhead and
greenery abounds as the
painted exteriors bring
the brilliance of the
Mughal architecture
alive. The huge
corridors echo with the
sounds of dholaks
and Manganiyar music
bands. Splendid terrace
gardens air out your
senses with the
fragrance of jasmine
that wafts up all the
way to the Amber and
Jaigarh forts, where the
maharanis walked around
for their evening
stroll. During special
occasions, people
assembled on the
promenade, particularly
when the royals hosted
duck-hunting parties,
lavish picnics,
glittering firework
displays and elaborate
music and dance
performances. Though
there are no documented
references that give a
clear picture and
details about this
palace built around 1734
by Jaipur’s visionary
founder, the great ruler
Maharaja Sawai Jai Singh
II (1688–1743),
miniature paintings and
some other historical
sources clearly indicate
that Jal Mahal was
constructed for a
ceremonial outing and
was never intended as a
living palace.
Almost a missionary
zeal
Had Jai Singh II been
alive today, he would
have fallen in love with
his creation all over
again. Thanks to five
years of lengthy
research, amazing
planning involving the
best brains from across
the globe, the
conservation initiative
by Rajasthan Tourism and
the Jal Mahal Resorts
development team has
borne fruit. Says
project director Rajeev
Lunkad, “We had to start
from scratch as both the
lake and the palace had
fallen into disuse. But
the picturesque location
was a great advantage
and could easily be
converted into a hub of
the tourist city, where
walkers could breathe,
where visitors could
just sit and relax,
where artists could soak
in the culture and get
their muse. So, we
planned to work on each
and every element of the
palace. All materials
used on the monument are
traditional: The plaster
is a natural mix of
lime, sand and surkhi.
A team of skilled
craftsmen was assembled
to recreate the
splendour of an 18th
century Rajasthani court
with its distinctive
chhatri towers and
pavilions, combining
intricately-carved white
marble or sandstone
walls with adornments
like murals, decorative
brass and mirror work.
The results speak for
themselves. The Jal
Mahal is once again one
of the best monuments in
Jaipur. Besides, it is
also a confluence of
various arts and crafts
of India.”
More than 50 artists
from in and around
Jaipur were brought
together to recreate the
frescoes, blue pottery
work, jaalis and
other important
components of the
palace. The research and
conceptualisation were
done by architect
Vibhuti Sachdev and art
historian Mitchell AK
Crites, who has devoted
the last 30 years in
discovering, saving and
revitalising traditional
forms of craftsmanship
such as Islamic
calligraphy, mosque
design and decoration.
Coming Back to life
Nothing can be more
pleasant than watching
the sunrise from the
shores of the Mansagar
lake. The early morning
rays startle the birds
and they take flight,
setting off diamond-like
ripples in the water.
The bells chime at the
Kanak Vrindavan temple
behind the Jal Mahal,
giving a ritualistic
start to a new day. And
the trees sway gently,
like a performer sensing
the audience.
There is a lot of human
effort behind this
divine experience. Some
native trees have been
re-planted on the shores
of the lake. “We hope to
create a green canopy,
planting more than
100,000 trees, including
Rajasthan’s state tree,
the Rohida, and trees
rescued from
road-building sites
across India,” informs
Lunkad.
“Two million tonnes of
toxic silt were dredged
from the bottom of the
lake, increasing its
depth by over a metre.
An eco-friendly water
treatment system was
developed that
dramatically improved
the quality of the lake.
We re-introduced local
vegetation and fish. As
a result, the wetlands
have been regenerated,
attracting birds like
grey heron, sandpipers
and black-winged stilts.
It is now completely a
man-made lake and every
effort is being made to
make it crystal clear.
Patrol boats maintain
the cleanliness,” he
adds. You wouldn’t
realise that men are at
work because these boats
look like barges. And
since there were no
trained boatmakers in
Jaipur, carvers came in
from Mathura to create
huge wooden boats with
the faces of elephants,
tigers and swans. “If
you study miniature
paintings closely, you
will notice that animals
were used liberally.
Even royal palanquins
are inspired by animal
figures,” says Lunkad.
The Jal Mahal project
includes the creation of
Jal Tarang, a green
leisure destination for
visitors and locals that
will include
environmental-friendly
accommodation,
independent galleries,
art boutiques and
lakeside dining along a
tree-lined promenade,
all in keeping with
Jaipur’s heritage.
The grand palace
As one approaches the
east-facing entrance of
the palace, past the
series of intricate
trellis, neo-Mughal
pavements and painted
arches and domes, you
will be momentarily
struck by the clang of
the metal landing strip
as you alight from the
boat. But the dhaatu
or metal has a lot to do
with vaastu,
which is the basis of
the structure.
The flooring has been
done in white marble,
cascading smoothly from
the pillars, seasoned to
withstand all weather
conditions. Though the
pavilions and the
corridors originally did
not have any frescoes or
paintings, they have
been liberally daubed
with coloured murals
depicting the royal
celebrations in Jaipur
or the raas leela,
Krishna being somewhat
of a patron God of the
royal house of Amber.
Art is not just about
display. It is also
about participation by
local artists and
craftsmen. Inspired by
the miniature tradition,
these paintings will be
displayed in five themes
in different galleries.
The Monsoon Unfolding
series features a
specially commissioned
34-ft mural of the Jal
Mahal and its
surrounding landscape at
the onset of monsoon.
Paintings with water as
a recurring motif will
be put up at pleasure
pavilions, an allusion
to energy flow with
nature. Baramasa
paintings depict
seasonal festivities,
while those celebrating
the arboreal splendour
of the royal gardens
have been put up near
the stairway to the
terrace.
The Ittra Mahal (The
scented chamber) is an
exquisitely decorated
room where visitors
sample the traditional
perfumes of courtly
Rajasthan. “Music will
be an additional feature
at the palace. None of
the monuments in Jaipur
has that,” says Lunkad.
And with romantic
passages and nooks, you
know this one is all
about the indulgence of
passion.
A visitor’s delight
The terrace garden has
been cleared of unwieldy
clumps of bushes and is
now a landscaped delight
with four pergolas at
the corners and a raised
central stage for
performing arts, in the
manner of courtly social
evenings. Keeping with
the tradition of Mughal
gardens, the fountains
and lights have been
arranged in a layered
formation. With the
floor done in opaque and
transparent marble, the
terrace blooms on a full
moon night as the milky
beams light up the
contours of the lotus
motif. It flickers like
a glow worm at night and
blazes a pure white in
the summer sun. Never
doubt that stones want
to live, indeed want to
become something.
It was here that queens
basked in the sun during
winter, overlooking
panoramic vistas, and
listened to music during
summer. If you want
Jaipur in miniature,
just step into Jal
Mahal. For, it combines
all Rajput styles used
in separate structures
across the city. The
Gulabi Tibari will
feature festive pink and
white decorative stucco
inspired by the
Sarvatobhadra Pavilion
in Jaipur City Palace.
The Badal Mahal, with
its dark clouds swirling
across the ceiling,
raindrops patterning the
walls and lily pools
blossoming in the
panels, will bring the
colours of monsoon to
life. The Chini Burj
will feature the rare
technique of blue glazed
finish. The Pitli Burj
will use the complex
techniques of Jaipuri
brass work such as
embossing, cutting,
enamelling, and
filigree, dedicated as
it is to the Sun God.
The Aina Burj will draw
its inspiration from the
glittering mirror-work
in Amber, while the
Shobha Burj will reflect
the opulent jewelled
interior of the Shobha
Niwas in Jaipur City
Palace.
What began as a natural
reservoir where
rainwater accumulated to
stave off famine, turned
into a black-and-white
sepia photograph in
between, has today
become a burst of colour
and art. Indeed, age
hasn’t withered her, nor
custom staled her
infinite variety.
The Pioneer, 8th May 2011
When Tagore entered the world of painting seriously in 1923, there seemed to be a harsh edge to nearly everything he painted
"The phantoms of
faces,
Come unbidden into my
vacant hours."
"Fondly indulgent
is my
Mistress of the
Line to the errant in
the poet."
— Rabindranath Tagore
It was at the insistence of Jawaharlal Nehru that, in 1961 — the year in which the centenary of Rabindranath Tagore’s birth was being celebrated — Satyajit Ray was asked to make a film on the poet. I remember seeing the film. Interestingly, however, nearly all of it I have forgotten, except the very last part. In that, as if winding up Tagore’s rich and crowded life, the great filmmaker dwelt on the rising, swirling disquiet in the poet’s mind in his last years — he died, one recalls, in 1941 — about what was happening all around him: the world was at war again; carnage on a scale undreamt of before was being witnessed; it was as if humanity had completely lost its hold upon sanity. He cited Tagore’s own words, quoted excerpts from his letters, showed him pacing up and down agitatedly in the balcony of his Jorasanko home. And then, suddenly, he moved on to flashing upon the screen the poet’s own paintings and drawings; no commentary, just soft melancholic music in the background, and one disturbing, haunting image piling upon another in leisured succession. Clearly, the selection of works was arbitrary, being Satyajit Ray’s own, but the images printed themselves upon the viewer’s mind: birds with long, predatory beaks, anguished faces tortured by thought, eyes smouldering ember-like with pain, dark presences.
In nearly every other mind, Rabindranath remains a writer — more than 1000 poems; nearly two dozen plays and playlets; eight novels; eight or more volumes of short stories; and a mass of prose on diverse topics — even though he was no stranger to painting. And yet in many eyes, it is his paintings and drawings, more than his great literary output that broke completely fresh ground in the Indian context. There are casual references in his writings to his childhood interest in painting but then he did not pursue it with any seriousness. And it was not till as late as the early twenties of the last century, when he was more than 60 years old, that he returned to this art.
What touched it all off is a matter of speculation. In some part, one knows, it grew out of his doodles, his erasures, in fact. Pages of his manuscripts have survived, especially of his Purabi, which he was working on then, in which one sees him correcting or revising some lines or words in black ink and then, at some point of time, beginning to join those erasures and shaping them into strange, mysterious forms: crouching figures, fantastic animals, agitated limbs.
"When the scratches in my manuscript cried, like sinners for salvation", he wrote once in an introduction to an exhibition of his paintings, "and assailed my eyes with the ugliness of their irrelevance, I often took time in rescuing them into a merciful finality of rhythm...." This is beautifully said: a poet’s honest and evocative words.
The question only is what it was that lay embedded in the lower strata of his mind that surfaced and took these mysterious, often disturbing, shapes. Without any doubt, Rabindranath was a citizen of the world — meaningfully, the institution he founded at Santiniketan was named Visvabharati — and as one he seems to have soaked in elements of other cultures. The enormous status he gained from the Nobel Prize that was conferred upon him in 1913 opened the world to him in many ways. He travelled extensively and in the process saw art everywhere. At the Chicago Art Institute, he encountered an astonishing number of works of modern painters, from the Impressionists to those by the German Expressionists like Kirchner and Pechstein.
In 1920, he attended lectures by distinguished scholar and art historian, Stella Kramrisch, whom he later invited to come to teach at Santiniketan and from whom he heard all about the art of Europe from the Gothic to Dada. In 1921, he went on what can only be called a triumphant tour of Germany, meeting artists, visiting museums. At the British Museum, he saw the art of the primitives of Ireland and Indonesia and North America. Everything left an impression upon him, and when he visited Japan, it is from there that he wrote to Abanindranath, admonishing him not to keep "squatting in the south verandah of his home", but to soak in the art of that ancient land "so that our own art may revive and flourish".
There is a reaching out in all this, and the desire to transcend boundaries. But was it only acquaintance with the art of other cultures that started it all, one wonders, or was there some dark bedrock inside himself that he was beginning to explore?
There are no easy answers. But it is clear that when he entered the world of painting seriously in 1923, everything started pouring forth in a furious rush as it were: those brilliantly rendered, haunting phantoms of the imagination, faces riven by fear and anxiety, Sphinx-like visages of women ravished by injustice, cheerless landscapes. There seemed to be a harsh edge to nearly everything he painted. It was, as Prithwish Neogy wrote, like the ‘eruption of a volcano’, the lava of thought sliding down and taking everything over.
The first exhibition of Rabindranath’s paintings and drawings was held in 1930: ironically however, not anywhere in India but in Paris. The show then travelled all over the world, from Berlin and Dresden to Copenhagen and Boston, opening to reviews that often bordered on the ecstatic.
To an audience in Moscow, Rabindranath said, "My most intimate gifts to you are my pictures ...." Stella Kramrisch wrote about his work with calm maturity. "That Rabindranath Tagore is a great poet", she said, "may stand in the way of acknowledging him as a great artist. But few, since time immemorial, were the masters, who gave dynamic form to their most personal vision. If this vision has for its background the depth of the poet’s mind, it is not difficult to know what place his work occupies in the world of art".
By now, a great deal has been written about Rabindranath’s paintings, both in India and abroad. Some of the most perceptive words came, however, from Rani Chanda, a close associate, who often saw the poet at work on his paintings. The impetuosity, the speed at which he sometimes worked, the fearful intensity with which he used to look out of his window at trees in which he discovered fanciful shapes and faces, the manner in which he often ‘talked to his pictures", especially to the portraits of his melancholy women, offering them colours as if to cheer them up, all tell of something that was constantly happening in his mind.
One almost senses that there were two different Tagores, the one of painting quite different from that of poetry. At any rate, there were two very different contrasting images of him: the one painted by his friend and admirer, William Rothenstein, which showed him as a saint and a poet-prophet, and the other that he painted of himself in 1935: a dark, brooding face against a backdrop of chrome yellow, ‘resembling the evening sky’, sombre with a sad gaze as if reflecting a disturbed mind.
But then, as Tagore
himself said in the
context of his art:
"There are two kinds of
reality in the world.
One of them is true and
the other truer. I seek
to occupy myself with
the truer."
The Tribune, 8th May 2011
River Prachi and
its valley can stake
claim to fame alongside
the best of historical
splendours of the State,
writes Lipipuspa Nayak
Prachi, the mythical
Saraswati river, flows
down the tapering
Eastern Ghats almost as
a frail drain. The tiny
stream, however, has
hogged headlines in
recent times, with its
antiquity and relevance
being weighed anew
against a nondescript
village — Kendubilwa —
on one of its banks.
Kendubilwa is the sylvan
hamlet where poet
Jayadeva of Odisha was
born and had composed
his celebrated 15th
century classic,
Gitagovinda.
Another lesser known
tale of the river is the
historical splendour of
its valley — a whole
wealth of architectural
and aesthetic heritage
along the course of this
river. River Prachi and
its valley can stake
claim to fame alongside
other historical
splendours of Odisha:
The rock-cut caves and
stone edicts of Kalinga
by the first century
Oriya King Kharavela, as
remnants of
Utkala-Kalinga
civilisation. The
Utkala-Kalinga-Kangada-Koshala
civilisation, apart from
its kings and wars, had
always been evaluated by
its economy, which
included a flourishing
maritime trade. If
historical facts are to
be believed, about 2,500
years ago, Prachi fed a
much civilised way of
life along its banks.
The immediate object of
interest for an
outsider, however, is a
chain of exquisite
temples hemming the
banks of this river at a
distance of about two
miles each. The temples
have been built at the
shrines of the mythical
‘Ashtashambhus’ — the
eight ‘self-manifested’
pantheon of deities of
the Prachi valley —
situated in innocuous
villages along both
sides of the river. In
modern-day topography,
this can be located
along the
Kolkata-Chennai National
Highway No 5, on which
you take a left turn
about 15 km from
Cuttack, the ex-capital
town of Odisha. The
temples carry scriptural
sanction; they are
mentioned in the Padma
Purana. The deities are
named Laksheswara,
Dakshineswara,
Kapileswara, Amareswara,
Gokarneswara,
Shobhaneswara, Rameswara
and Angeswara. Later
additions are
Siddheswara, Natyeswara,
Mukteswara and
Bhimeswara. It’s at the
Natyeswara temple that
Prachi merges with river
Chandrabhaga in the sun
city of Konark.
The archaeological
splendour of Prachi
valley manifests itself
in these temples, some
of which are built as
late as 300 years ago
(like Laksheswara and
Dakshineswara in
Bagalpur village).
Others, such as
Akhandeswara (in
Prataparudrapur) and
Shobhaneswara (in
Nuagaon village), seem
quite ancient, though in
the absence of
systematic research,
they are best left to
guess. These temples,
going by their
architectural and
sculptural nuances, are
credited to the
patronage of the Keshari
dynasty; they share
platform with the famous
Lingaraj temple in
Bhubaneswar, the capital
city of Odisha, built by
the Kesharis.
The Madhab temple is
built by Anangabhima
Deb-II, the patron of
the temple of Lord
Jagannath at Puri. It
houses Lord Vishnu in
its sanctum sanctorum,
in an obvious contrast
with other temples where
Lord Shiva is the
presiding deity. A rare
idol of Durgamadhab is
worshipped here, and in
line with the worship
practices of the
Jagannath temple, the
deity is offered cooked
food as prasad. In fact,
in many ways than one,
the temple humbly emits
the ambience of its
famed ‘cousin’ in Puri.
In architecture, too,
the Madhab temple
approximates its massive
cousin.
The other famous temples
of Prachi valley are
Siddheswara (in Kuranga
village), Gokarneswara
(in Kantapada),
Angeswara (in Pitapada)
and Amareswara (in
Amareswara). The Barahi
temple in Chauraasi
village, between
Angeswara and
Amareswara, excels with
its exquisite sculptural
and aesthetic
singularity. Not among
the Ashtashambhus and
with shades of a highly
evolved temple
architectural
aesthetics, it has a
quiet folklore: It is a
labour of love of the
sculptors of the Konark
temple who, on their way
back home, stopped here
to erect this edifice.
Myriad festivals are
celebrated on grand
scales at these shrines.
Shivaratri is the
loudest festival,
followed by Bhouma
Ekadashi (the 11th day
of the waxing lunar
phase in the Hindu month
of Magha). This latter
festival propitiates
lord Durgamadhab at
Madhab temple. Akshaya
Tritiya, the festival of
harvest rituals, is the
next eminent festivity,
in honour of Lord
Dakshineswara.
The Archaeological
Survey of India has
taken over the
preservation of some of
these invaluable
monuments, besides the
excavation of this
ancient river valley.
The river ostensibly
betrays its present
condition of narrow
trails and dry patches.
Rich folklore of the
region blends
temporality with
timelessness. So, the
villagers, still
unsullied in their
earthiness, show you the
place where Pandavas
lived during their
exile. Or, the
footprints of Lord Rama
in Dakshineswara! But,
then, the stories must
travel wider.
The Pioneer, 8th May 2011
Thanjavur. The very name brings to mind the image of a city of temples, art, music, dance, sculptures and paintings.
With a history dating
back to nearly 2,000
years, this ancient city
is situated in one of
the most fertile areas
in South India, the
delta of River Cauvery.
Thanjavur has had a
chequered past, being
ruled by the Cholas, the
Nayaks and the Maratha
rulers, before coming
under the British rule.
Legend has it that
Thanjavur, also known as
Thanjapuri, is named
after a demon Tanjan,
who was a menace and was
therefore annihilated by
Goddess Anandavalli
Amman and Lord
Neelamegaperumal. The
dying wish of the demon
was that the city should
bear his name, which was
granted.
Like all ancient cities
of historical
significance, Thanjavur
and its surrounding
areas are home to many
temples and monuments.
The best example, which
perhaps, symbolises the
zenith of artistic
endeavour is the
Brihadeeswara Temple
built by the Chola king
Rajaraja. Also known as
the Big Temple or the
Periya Kovil in Tamil,
this poetry in stone
compels one to search
for superlatives to
describe its
awe-inspiring
magnificence.
Enclosed within the
walls of a fort, the
temple is dedicated to
Lord Shiva
(Brihadeeswara). The
entrance is through a
massive tower or
gopuram. The first thing
to strike the eye is the
colossal, monolith stone
Nandi (sacred bull),
housed in its own
enclosure and facing the
main deity. Right in the
centre of this vast
expanse of land is the
shrine of
Brihadeeshwara.
Typical of Chola
architecture, the main
sanctum is enclosed
within three outer
structures, the ardha
mandapam, the mukha
mandapam and the maha
mandapam, each adorned
with exquisite stucco
sculptures and carved
pillars. The various
manifestations of Lord
Shiva, all the 108
Bharatanatyam dance
postures, find
expression here.
Proceeding through the
darkened halls, one’s
sense of breathless
expectations are not
belied as the gigantic
lingam of Lord
Brihadeeswara comes into
view in the soft glow of
the oil lamps. Such a
contrast to the puny
man!
The exterior of the
temple carries
inscriptions detailing
the conquests and
donations of the king.
But the crowning glory
of this temple is the
stupendous gopuram or
vimanam. Towering to a
height of 200 feet, this
glorious structure is an
amazing example of not
only artistic perfection
but of engineering skill
also. Surmounted by an
octagonal dome resting
on a single granite
block weighing 81 tons,
it is believed that this
block was hoisted up an
inclined plane,
especially built for
this purpose, from a
spot six km away.
The gopuram is
embellished with a metal
kalasham, nearly four
metres in height.
Innumerable stucco
carvings adorn the
gopuram, making it a
rivetting sight.
Abutting the southern
face of the tower and
reached by a flight of
21 steps is the tiny
alcove shrine of Lord
Dakshinamurthi.
The entire outermost
passage (prakaram) on
all the three sides of
the complex houses 108
Shivalingams with
beautiful mural
paintings depicting
incidents from the lives
of the shaivaite saints.
To the right of the
Nandi is the temple of
Goddess Brihannayaki,
the consort of Lord
Shiva. Situated within
the same precincts are
temples to Lord
Ganapati, Lord
Chandikeshwara and Lord
Subrahmanya. Coming out
of this UNESCO World
Heritage Site, one’s
mind goes back to an age
where artistic
sensibilities created
edifices that have stood
the test of time.
Deccan Herald, 8th May 2011
Barely noticeable amidst the welter of ugly shop fronts and the squalor of chaotic traffic, the facade of Seth Chhunna Mal’s haveli at Katra Neel in the 350-year-old vintage selling street of Chandni Chawk, looks on benignly as a mute spectator of history since the time of Mughal emperor Aurangzeb.
According to The Punjab
Gazette of July 26,
1865, Seth Chhunna Mal
was the raees-e-azam
(richest man) of
Shahjahanabad, the
walled city of Delhi.
His forefathers had
migrated from Lahore and
Rawalpindi somewhere at
the end of the 16th
Century. At one time in
the not too distant
past, all roads in
Chandni Chowk led to
Seth Chhunna Mal ki
haveli. It was in this
haveli that the first
motor car was brought in
Shahjahanabad. The
credit for installing
the first telephone too
goes to Seth Chhunna
Mal.
Now, finding your way
through the colourful
confusion of Chandni
Chowk — rickshaws, three
wheelers, scooters, cars
battling for space in
the narrow lanes,
hawkers on the
sidewalks, people
jostling along the
pavements, vendors
shouting themselves
hoarse — is a little
more difficult. A flight
to stairs sandwiched
between the textile
shops and some halwais
(sweets mart) lead via
the tiled sidewalls and
a brass banister to the
main courtyard.
The main entrance
doorway with white deft
English tiles along with
shining handrails and
Victorian iron grill is
in itself a preview of
the excellent treat of
heritage and nostalgia,
that one is going to see
later in the haveli. To
the right and the left
are grand as well as
graceful drawing rooms
with gilt framed mirrors
and painted plaster work
so typical of the bygone
Mughal era.
Seth Chhunna Mal
purchased this haveli
built earlier by a
Maratha chieftain Rai
Brij Bahar. It has 128
rooms, most of them in
their original form.
This Khatri family of
businessmen flourished
in the cloth trade
specialising in shawls
and costly brocades for
the Mughal court.
With their headquarters
in Delhi, they had
offices in Farrukhabad
and Calcutta where the
actual trade was
conducted on board ship,
directly with the
captain. According to
Anil Parshad, the
occupant of the main
portion of the haveli,
once there also used to
be a tunnel between the
haveli and the
apartments of the
emperor in Red Fort.
Later, this underground
tunnel was filled for
water percolated into
it.
Mirza Fakhru, the son
and the heir apparent of
the last Mughal emperor,
Bahadur Shah Zafar, was
indebted to Seth Chhunna
Mal, for he borrowed
more than he could pay
back, therefore
releasing all his assets
to Seth Chhunna Mal who
became very rich after
that.
It was from here that
the additional business
of lending money began.
Seth Chhunna Mal’s best
time was in 1857, during
the time of Sepoy Mutiny
when the British had
been expelled from the
city.
But, Seth Chhunna Mal
remained loyal to the
English at a time when
the slightest lurking
partiality for the
British meant death. As
history revealed, the
revolt failed and the
British were
hand-in-glove with him
afterwards, for they
were on the look out for
new native allies.
The typical haveli plan
of Seth Chhunna Mal’s
mansion is eminently
sensible for Indian
conditions, affording
privacy from the street
and plenty of light and
air to the living
quarters. Traditional
Indian families did not
allow the European
practice of separate
drawing and dining
rooms, but there is a
magnificent baithak
(sitting-room) for the
guests and formal
visitors to the left of
the front staircase.
An inscribed marble
tablet in Urdu states
that this hall was
renovated in 1868.
Magnificently carved,
gilt framed mirrors
reflect pendant glass
lamps hanging from a
cloth-covered ceiling.
Besides, an exquisite
Adam style frieze with
border, Greek vases and
garlands painted in deep
red and blue and touched
with pure gold leaf,
adorn the ceiling line.
Paintings of ancestors
enjoy the pride of place
between the mirrors.
Carved marble topped
consoles are ranged
along the walls and
Persian carpets provide
comfort underfoot.
To the left of the main
staircase, across the
open courtyard, and
facing the street is the
large bedroom of Anil
Parshad. Bohemian glass
chandeliers are
suspended from a painted
plaster work ceiling and
great marble topped
carved tables were
purchased from the house
of Colonel Skinner of
Skinner’s Horse Regiment
in Kashmiri Gate. His
haveli was a rendezvous
of all the rich and
famous in Delhi. Even
Mirza Ghalib refers to
it in one of his
letters. In 1864, Seth
Chhunna Mal was also
made the Honorary
Magistrate of Delhi, a
great honour. He was
also awarded a Khillat,
a testimonial, and
elevated to the status
of Rai Bahadur.
Since the members of the
family were strict
Vaishnava vegetarians,
the munim’s (clerk’s)
record of 1858
represents eggs as safed
aaloo and chicken as
chalti phirti tarkari
(mobile vegetable)!
Seth Chhunna Mal had
given enough evidence of
his loyal activism and
public charity to merit
these honours. He was
also one of the founder
members of the
Anglo-Sanskrit School.
His contributions to
famine relief and public
work were exceptionally
generous, as his income
could sustain such
benevolence. In Delhi in
1869, he became the
richest man as his
yearly income crossed
one lakh rupees!
After Seth Chhunna Mal
died in 1870, his
nephews and sons kept up
the commercial and
social status of the
family. Now, there are
two branches of the
family — the Parshads
and the Mohans and there
are 70 signing members
in the family. The
family closed its
traditional business
before 1936, according
to Vinod Parshad.
“Our name was big in the
real estate and money
lending business, but
with banks coming in, we
lost our business,”
reveals Anil Parshad.
“Besides, the rent from
the shops below the
haveli has not been
revised for years. It is
as low as 12 rupees per
month, per shop. There
are about 100 shops in
all,” he adds.
The connoisseurs of art
and architecture rate
this dusky mansion very
highly. But, of late,
slowly and gradually,
the haveli is losing its
glamour. Regretfully,
the later additions of
the ugly iron bridges,
staircases and
protective grids over
courtyards, sheet iron
windows and many other
haphazard additions mar
the elegance of the
otherwise graceful
structure.
“If the government will
not help us with its
restoration, we’ll turn
it into a hotel. But,
let me tell you, we love
this place,” adds Anil.
Deccan Herald, 8th May 2011
This is a compilation of some already published writings on Indian Numismatics by A.K. Bhattacharyya, who had been the Director of Indian Museum in Kolkata, for almost a decade from 1965. During this period, he had the distinction of bringing a large collection of Indian coins to that Museum from the old Mint where they had been kept in safe custody during the World Wars. Prior to that, he had an opportunity to examine the collection of early Indian coins in the Musee Guimet in Paris in the late 1950s.
Disparate
Numismatics apart,
Bhattacharyya has,
during his long career
spanning half-a-century
and more, written
prolifically on such
diverse subjects as art
and iconography (of the
Buddhists, Jains,
Vaishnavas, Shaivas and
other religious groups),
epigraphy, painting, and
textiles.
The bunch of 10 essays under review is somewhat disparate, both chronologically and thematically. The chronological spectrum stretches from the earliest coins of India to those of the Mughals. While some chapters are devoted to mere descriptions of individual coins (for example, in chapter III, we read about typological descriptions of stray coins of Kaushambi, Chandragupta II, Shahjahan, and Muhammad Shah and coins of the ‘Turko-Afghans'), some throw interesting light on the cultural aspects of coins (Ch. VII on “Art in Islamic Numismatics of India” and Ch. VIII on “Poems as coin legends in India”).
Some others are
useful compendia of
important museum
collections such as
those in the Indian
Museum, Kolkata, (Ch.IV)
and Musee Guimet
(Appendix) — these two
represent a major
exercise in
documentation and as
such merit a distinctive
place in the
historiography of Indian
numismatics.
The titles of other
chapters are indicative
of the contents, nature,
scope and orientation of
those contributions:
“Indian coins — A
Succinct Survey”;
“Bilingual Coins of
Mahmud of Ghazni — A
re-study”; ‘Hindu
Elements in Early Muslim
Coinage in India”;
“Coins and their Issuers
in Muslim Numismatics of
India”; and “A Study of
the History of the
Yadavas and their
Coins”. Of these, the
one on coins and their
issuers in Muslim
numismatics of India is
particularly noticeable
for its accent on
demonstrating the role
of coins as markers of
sovereignty of the
concerned issuers.
Coins of Sultans
Starting with “sporadic
issues of Mahmud of
Ghazni”,” this chapter
discusses coins issued
by all the sultans up to
the Lodis and the
Sayyids and goes on to
include the issues of
the Mughals. It devotes
considerable space to
coins of the ‘Provincial
Sultanates' of Bengal,
Kashmir, Malabar,
Jaunpur, Gujarat, Malwa,
Golconda, Bijapur, and
so on, and concludes
with a brief note on Ek
pai Sikkah of the East
India Company issued
under Shah Alam's
suzerainty.
What is of major concern in this volume is the kind of vocabulary used to designate the different periods discussed and the various coin types. Much of that smacks strongly of communalised terminology. Witness these: “for purposes of numismatics, medieval Muslim period in India starts with Mahmud of Ghazni” (p.97); “Later Hindu Coinage” for the coinage of the period between c.500 and 1200 CE (p.3); “ Hindu elements in early Muslim Coinage in India” (title of chapter VI); “ Islamic/ Muslim numismatics of India” (pp.68 and 94) [emphasis added]
Apparently, the essays in this collection have been published over a very long period — the year of original publication is not given. Stylistic inconsistencies apart, they are disappointing in that they do not address the economics of numismatics. Surely, by the time these essays were written, D.D. Kosambi's understanding of coins being “stamps of society” was well established. Further, it was well understood that primarily these tiny metal pieces were supposed to serve as a medium of exchange. One looks in vain for any notice thereof.
The production side,
including editing,
leaves much to be
desired, and the price
is quite prohibitive,
perhaps because of the
use art paper for the
text too, not just the
plates.
The Hindu, 10th May 2011
Backed with more than 1,000-odd heritage monuments, including three World Heritage Sites, and an uninterrupted history of continuous habitation for more then 1,000 years, Delhi has staked claim for inclusion in the Unesco's tentative listing for the World Heritage City tag. Ahmedabad in Gujarat is a lso in the race for the title, which as and when earned by either of the city, would make it India's first World Heritage City.
With sites dating back to even Harappan era and around 1,200 heritage monuments and structures, including World Heritage Sites of Red Fort, Qutub Minar and Humayun's Tomb, Delhi has far better stake than any other city in the country to be a World Heritage City.
The Delhi Transport and Tourism Development Corporation (DTTDC), the nodal agency for carrying out related procedures, has submitted the tentative document to the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI).
'Tentative document' is a set of formal papers that help the stake holder's claim for qualification.
OP Mishra, DTTDC general manager, told HT: "The tentative document was submitted to the ASI in the last week of April and we are waiting to hear from them."
"We will evaluate the proposal for tentative listing. If required, make some additions/ alterations in consultation with the Delhi government and forward it to the Unesco when it is complete in all respects," said BR Mani, spokesperson, ASI.
But the wait for the title is not going to be easy for Delhi. First, it has competition from Ahmedabad and second, the procedure for the final notification is tough and lengthy.
ASI has already forwarded Ahmedabad's tentative document. In the same way, the ASI can send Delhi's nomination for the 'tentative list'.
But to inscribe the same in the final notification is a long drawn process.
Once any site is
included in the
'tentative list', a
detailed dossier needs
to be prepared. January
31 is the deadline every
year for sending this
dossier and the Unesco
generally takes 18
months before it
considers it in its
annual meeting in June.
Hindustan Times, 10th May 2011
As a part of Tagore's 150th birth anniversary celebrations, an exhibition by the West Bengal Archives Department throws light on the colonial surveillance of the poet.
Being in Kolkata at the time of Rabindranath Tagore's 150 {+t} {+h} birth centenary celebrations is interesting. Tagore is being revisited and re-imagined through different lens by a cross section of people: intellectuals, artistes, theatre professionals and admirers of the poet-philosopher whose birth anniversary was on May 7.
But one historically significant exhibition has uncovered relatively unknown aspects of Tagore: a Tagore being scrutinised by the British government's watchful Intelligence Branch based on their suspicion that Tagore was close to the “Communists” and that the institution he founded, Santiniketan, could be a “terrorist” organisation and “tainted with Communism”. Fascinating also is to find my home state, Hyderabad's, connection to Tagore's Santiniketan!
The Directorate of State Archives of West Bengal celebrated the Archives Week (April 6-12) with an exhibition; “The Evolution of State Archives (1910-2010) and Rabindranath Tagore in Government Records”. The exhibition was put together from sources such as the confidential files of the Intelligence Branch, which includes informers' reports, intercepted letters of the dwellers of Santiniketan and Sriniketan (the rural development centre near Santiniketan) and rare photographs. The Report on the Native Papers in Bengal, Report on the Political Situation and Labour Unrest in Bengal (IB, CID), District Gazetteers were also consulted.
Exhibition
The Hyderabad connection to Tagore's Santiniketan was remarkably new for me; the Nizam of Hyderabad was the largest donor of all to Santiniketan, having given Rs. 100,000. The letter from Tagore seeking support and revealing the donations given and more needed, is displayed: IB 285 / 1925.
The Intelligence
files reveal a British
administration highly
suspicious of Tagore's
anti-colonial network
and keeping close watch
on all the activities at
Santiniketan. The
“Extract from the report
of an IB officer dated
Chandernagore, February
11 1931” for instance,
reads: “There are two
Japanese teachers at
present there. One of
them is Mr. Takagaki
about whom I have
already reported. He is
the Ju-Jutsu teacher and
lives in Santi Niketan
with his wife Mrs.
Takagaki. The name of
the other Japanese
teacher is Mr. Konosan.
He teaches carpentry but
he also himself
manufactures and sells
furniture. He lives at
Surul (Sri Niketan) with
family (wife).” This has
a handwritten note:
“Inform SP he is
supposed to report
movements of foreigners.
Sd. F. James, dated
12.2.31”Another typed
letter (from a local
informer) addressed “To
the Chief Secretary,
Government of India”
reads: “Dear Sir,
Santiniketan
Visvabharati is an organ
of terrorist movement of
India greatly supporter
of Subhash Chandra Bose
Party (sic). All inmates
of this ashram are
pro-Japanese. They
create panic all over
the world to support
terrorist movement of
India”.
The Hindu, 15th May 2011
They were once majestic homes unique to Pune. But wadas are slowly fading out of the cityscape
Hemchandra Date takes a long, pensive look at a wooden door that has “Hari Bhavan Est 1858” written on it. He examines the fading blue paint, the rusted bolts, the creaking latch, and the small “chor darwaza” built within it. In the days of yore, at night, this little door would be kept unlocked, for any member who would be coming home late.
All Date can hope for is that these memories remain vivid in his mind long after Hari Bhavan ceases to exist. In a few weeks from now, the stone walls of the 150-year old house will be pounded to dust.
Hari Bhavan is a wada, one of many such houses that used to be a symbol of pride for their residents, mostly administrators and businessmen, during the reign of the Peshwas, who ruled from 1749 to 1818. Wadas have been unique to the history and culture of Pune. They are mostly made of wood, have red sloping brick tiles, narrow passages, ornate carvings on wall edges and are divided into courtyards. The men of the family would gather in the central courtyard to discuss business and politics, while the women and children would huddle inside the rooms.
Historian Mandar Lavate says,“Probably the best examples left now of wadas are the Mujumdar Wada in Kasba Peth, the Raste Wada in Rasta Peth and the Vishrambaug Wada behind Shaniwar Peth — all in the old city. The major wadas were named after the members who built them. Raste Wada, for instance, was named after Sardar Raste who built it. The 232-year-old Mujumdar Wada is nothing if not a fine example of the architecture of those times with its ornate wooden windows, exquisitely-carved furniture and antique chandeliers.”
Date’s grandfather, Gajanan Hari Date, a businessman, had built three wadas — Hari Bhavan, Date Wada, and Janki Bhavan — within the same compound in Narayan Peth. Located off the bustling Laxmi road, in the old city, Narayan Peth has been a central hub of activity for old-time businessmen. “Hari Bhavan was not where we just lived. We also did business here, for example, by renting out a small marriage hall within the wada,” says Date of his large six-room, two-storeyed house. It stands in contrast to a shining, new six-storeyed glass-and-cement building next to it. Soon, Hari Bhavan too will give way to a multi-storeyed apartment building, following the fate of Janaki Bhavan, on whose place also stands a similar edifice.
First, the main gate of the compound was broken down, then a road was laid by the Pune Municipal Corporation (PMC) between Hari Bhavan on one side and Janaki Bhavan and Date Wada on the other. “We will commission a builder to construct a multi-storeyed building in which each family within our large family will have a flat of its own, instead of wrangling over one large, single property. At least my grandfather’s land will still stay,” says Date.
There are many reasons why wadas, despite their historical value, are slowly fading out of the cityscape. Built as large single-storeyed structures close to the road, they have fallen prey to shrinking urban spaces, the breakdown of the joint family system, property disputes, and widening of roads. There is also the issue of safety. Having been constructed primarily with wood, the wadas weren’t well-ventilated. Hanging wires and non-concealed electrical circuits pose a fire hazard, especially in the congested, almost claustrophobic old city area of Pune, where most of them are located. This has led the PMC to embark on annual drives to determine the stability of these structures, and identify which of them need to be demolished.
Photographer Sandesh Bhandare, whose book Pune: Queen of the Deccan is about the city’s wadas, says “the rot had already set in when I was shooting the wadas way back in 1988”. “Wonderful specimens of the erstwhile Peshwa culture like the Natu Wada in Shaniwar Peth no longer exist, except in photographic books and journals,” he says.
Restoration architect Kiran Kalamdani says wadas are impractical today. “A courtyard of 20 feet by 20 feet would then be home to around 40 people. Today, even an average person requires a room which is at least 10 feet by 10 feet.” But some wadas have been lucky enough to have found favour with contemporary living. The 20,000-sq feet Vishrambaug Wada is now home to a post office and offices of the municipal corporation. It has been restored under the PMC’s Heritage Corridor Plan, retaining the original design, including red tiles, and sloping brick roofs, wooden and stone pillars, wooden staircases, high-and-narrow windows, and ornate carvings on the edges of the walls.
Kalamdani, who helped restore Vishrambaug Wada, says restoring wadas is an uphill and expensive, but not impossible, task. “About a century-and-a-half ago, the old city was the hub of all socio-economic, cultural and political activity. All businesses allied to wada-building like carving and brick-making were concentrated there. To rebuild them in the original style would mean replacing certain materials, like lime with cement for binding, old decayed wood with treated wooden panels and so on. It’s an expensive proposition but the results are pretty similar to the original designs.”
A hint of modernity
has transformed the Sai
Krupa Wada, owned by the
Tarawade family, in
Somwar Peth, into a
monument that has stood
the test of time. Built
in the early 1900s by
social worker and
freedom fighter Bandoba
Malharrao Tarawade, the
wada has been renovated
twice over the turn of
the century. The family
members have used stone
in place of wood so that
the the walls and the
floors last. Instead of
using lime as a binder,
they have used cement
and mortar. But the
design remains the same,
with small doors and
windows, and a small
courtyard, complete with
a secret passage for
servants to enter and
exit from. The
1,600-sq-ft wada has
three families living in
it. Chandrakant
Tarawade, a retired
government servant, who
stays there with his
brothers Sanjay and
Vijay and their
families, says, “ We
cannot make any changes
to the room sizes
without breaking down
the structure. That
would mean building a
new house altogether.
Over the years, builders
have approached us with
lucrative proposals but
we have not accepted
them. These houses
symbolise everyone being
together. Of course, you
can always get a private
life in high-rises. But
we are happy being
close-knit.” The
Tarawades are an
exception. As Date’s
24-year-old nephew,
Shashank, says
wistfully, pointing out
to an open space that
has now become a
multi-storeyed parking
lot near his old house,
“That area behind the
wada used to be an open
ground where we would
play. At least I got a
chance to live in the
old house and play in
the open. What will the
next generation have?”
Folk tales and memories
of a forgotten past,
perhaps.
Indian Express, 15th May 2011
Despite cancellation of the Government accommodation allotted to him at Safdarjung Lane in 1980, Maharaja Ranjit Singh Gaekwad of Baroda has continued to be in unauthorised possession of the centrally located property. The 7, Safdarjung Lane bungalow was allotted to him from the Lok Sabha pool when he became an MP in 1980 and was subsequently cancelled in 1989 after the dissolution of the 8th Lok Sabha.
The Maharaja at present resides at the palatial 700-acre Laxmi Vilas palace in Baroda and stays in Delhi for a few days in a year. Staff posted at the bungalow told The Pioneer that the Maharaja and his wife stay at the house for a few days in a year. The property remains otherwise unutilised throughout the year as neither his children nor any other visitors stay there.
When he was served an eviction notice in 2000, the Maharaja approached the Urban Development Minister stating that he had met the then Prime Minister VP Singh in January 1990, who had issued instructions that no proceeding should be initiated against the Gaekwads and that they should not be vacated from 7 Safdarjung Lane. He requested that they should not be evicted till an alternate land in a prime location of Delhi was given to him in lieu of Baroda House. The representation by the Maharaja did not mention anything about the letter dated 1951, wherein the issue of Baroda House and Nazarbagh Palace was settled.
The Maharaja then approached the Delhi High Court in 2002 seeking a stay on the eviction. He claimed that he was never given an alternate accommodation in exchange for Baroda House which was handed over by his family to the Centre. He has submitted that he was occupying the property in lieu of allotment of another plot in Delhi for his personal accommodation. In its order dated September 2002, the High Court granted a stay on the Maharaja’s eviction subject to his making a payment of license fee.
In addition, according to a document dated July 2007, the Directorate of Estates filed a counter affidavit stating Gaekwad was not eligible for allotment of the bungalow and that his request for allotment of alternate accommodation in lieu of Baroda House should be delinked from retention of the bungalow.
A letter dated January 2007 written by the Directorate of Estates to the L&DO also suggests that the unauthorised occupation of the bungalow cannot be linked with an alternate plot requested by the Gaekwads from the L&DO. The letter also states that the bungalow belongs to the Lok Sabha pool and there is a pressing need for it to be vacated.
In addition, there is an outstanding amount of Rs 8.13 lakh up to December 2006. The rent and hiring of the furniture cost around Rs 52,000 per month.
Disputing the Maharaja’s claim, the Centre has filed a detailed affidavit with supporting documents in May 2011 before Justice S Muralidhar. Documents detailing the history of Baroda House have been attached to substantiate the Centre’s claim.
According to the affidavit, the question of title and ownership of Baroda House and Sirmur plot was settled between the Maharaja of Baroda and the Union of India in terms of the Instrument of Merger executed between the two parties. There was a private party agreement for the exchange of the Baroda House for Nazarbagh Palace in Baroda.
Nazarbagh Palace was a property owned by the Centre, which was handed over to the Maharaja in exchange for Baroda House that was required by the Government for housing its offices in New Delhi. The exchange stood completed in 1951. Baroda House was subsequently purchased by Northern Railways and is at present being used as its headquarters. Even if one argues that the Centre retained the private property of the Maharaja, even then the petition was filed only in 2002, an inordinate and unexplained delay of almost five decades.
It is now up to the
Delhi High Court to
decide whether the claim
made by the Maharaja of
Baroda on the property
at India Gate is valid
or not and whether he
should be evicted from
the Safdarjung lane
bungalow.
The Pioneer, 15th May 2011
Jammu, gateway to the sprawling mountain regions of Kashmir and Ladakh, is currently being developed as a heritage city, reports Suraj Saraf
Five prestigious heritage projects are presently under execution in Jammu city to help boost tourism. Jammu constitutes the doorway to the Kashmir valley and Ladakh.
The first one is the Mubarak Mandi project. There is a huge complex of palaces of the old Dogra ruling dynasty spread over 120 kanals. The palaces are designed on Rajput, Mughal and European styles. The project involves an expenditure of Rs 200 crore.
The second one is the Raghunath Bazar heritage project named after high-profile Raghunath temples. The bazaar, business hub of the city, offers a captivating sight of numerous large and small composite statues.
The third project involves the ancient Bahu fort-cum-palace that is proposed to be linked with Mubarak Mandi through a ropeway spanning the Tawi.
The fourth project would result in the beautification of the ancient Shiva shrine, located charmingly in the wild environs above the right bank of the Tawi.
Under the fifth one, old historical records dating back to the early 18th century would be digitalised. According to J&K Tourism and Cultural Minister Nawan Rizgin Jora, the government has sanctioned Rs 5 crore to improve the archive repositories in Jammu, Srinagar and Ladakh.
The repository at Jammu, established in 1928, is one of the oldest archives in the subcontinent. Its records date back to the Mughal times. These have been classified into Persian, English and Urdu. The repository also has a library with 30,000 books and manuscripts.
A sum of Rs 3.5 crore has been sanctioned for the development of the Pir Kho cave Shiva shrine. The cave is an ancient one and connected both with Ramayana and Mahabharta.
Popularly known as Jamwant cave, it is linked with Jamwant, the boar chief of Lord Rama’s armies in his fight against Ravana. Later, Lord Rama is said to have ordered him to reside in this cave. Lord Krishna is said to have won over him in fight and married his daughter Jamawanti. Historically, Guru Gorakh Nath is said to have visited it. An exquisite statue of Gorakh Nath in white marble is installed in a temple at the well-known Shiva shrine of Sudh Mahadev, about 125 km north of Jammy city.
To develop Pir Kho as a tourism-cum-pilgrimage centre, crores of rupees are proposed to be spent on the construction of a reception centre, a landscape park, a gymnasium, an amphitheatre, bath ghats and footpaths, besides gateways. Bahu fort, lying on a hillock besides the Tawi and facing Mubarak Mandi, is an ancient sturdy structure.
"The fort and the town of Bahu stand east of Jammu city on the left bank of the Tawi. The fort still bears appearance of great strength and was famous in former times", say renowned archaeologist J. P. Bogel and Kutchison in their History of the Punjab Hill States.
It is said to have been renovated and re-structured by Maharaja Gulab Singh, who founded Jammu and Kashmir state in the mid-19th century. The fort is now being renovated as a heritage structure by restoration of the rampart walls, viewpoints, royal residence, water tank and construction of pathways and improvement of the light and sound system. The fort also has an old Kali goddess temple, which is visited by devotees, especially in large numbers, on each Tuesday and other auspicious occasions.
The fort
is known as Bahu fort
because it was
originally believed to
have been founded by
Bahu Lochan, whose
younger brother Jambu
Lochan founded the city
of Jammu. There is
reference to Jammu
inMahabharta as Jambu.
The Tribune, 15th May 2011
Have you ever noticed the liberal sprinkling of bright lemon yellow dotting the city’s streets and parks this time of the year? No points for guessing that it’s Amaltas. And for that matter, have bunches of Gulmohar colouring the summer sky in hues of crimson, red and even light orange caught your eye?
Mind you, Amaltas and Gulmohar are just two of the swathes of colour that can be witnessed around this time of the year. Contrary to general perception about summer being a dry and hot season, this is the season when nearly every area of the Capital witnesses a range of flowering trees in full bloom. Subhash Chandra, former director (horticulture) of New Delhi Municipal Council (NDMC), says, “Summer flowering of trees in Delhi is very special with Amaltas, Gulmohar, Jarul (Pride of India), Barna, Plumerias, Kanakchampa, Sita Ashok and Ashok competing with each other in adding colour and joy to an otherwise dull, hot summer.”
But have you
noticed?
Even if
you are not someone who
cares about the carbon
footprint, cycling on
the city’s road,
especially early in the
morning can be a good
opportunity to observe
these trees. Says Nalin
Sinha, founder of the
Delhi Cycling Club,
“While cycling, you
discover lots of things
which otherwise you
might miss.”
If you don’t want to cycle, you can enjoy these blooming beauties while waiting for the traffic signal to turn green. If you are lucky to have a driver — or are in a bus — just look around to spot this abundance of colour in nature.
Nandita Das, who travels seven km daily to work, says, “I capture flowering trees often in my mobile phone and share it with my friends on Facebook. I feel, we Delhiites are lucky as compared to other big cities.”
The wide roads and parks in the NDMC area throw up colourful surprises every few metres. The roads and parks maintained by the Delhi Development Authority (DDA) and the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD), too, have ample colour at this time of the year.
Pradip Krishen, the
author of Trees of
Delhi, a wonderful field
guide about the
Capital’s green wealth,
says, “Like canaries in
a mineshaft, one had
expected the city’s
trees to become early
casualties in this
dreadful unfolding of
cause and effect. That
this did not happen is a
tribute to Delhi’s civic
authorities. This is no
small achievement in the
face of an intense
hunger for land.”
Hindustan Times,
16th May 2011
Ladakh High in the mountains, it is a place where the very forces of nature have conjured to create a breathtaking landscape, notes URVASHI SARKAR
Snow-capped towering mountain peaks, brilliant azure skies, vast stretches of silent winding roads and a mesmerising mixture of snow, sparkling blue rivers and sand dunes make up the enigma that is Ladakh.
While a week long holiday in Ladakh was challenging owing to the high altitudes, we scaled in a short period of time the stunning vistas during the journeys and at the end of it every spell of nausea or breathlessness encountered was worth it.
Tourist season in Ladakh is usually from June till October. However, a group of us decided to risk it and visit Ladakh in April and we were not disappointed. Though we missed out on water sports and the carnivalesque feel of Leh which is a mark of tourist season, the varied hues of Ladakh's landscapes which we had mostly to ourselves were more than a compensation.
Leh is at an altitude of about 11000 feet above sea level. On the first day we were advised to stay indoors and acclimatise ourselves. The next day we set out for Nimu, 27 kilometres from Leh. Pretty views of the confluence of the Indus and Zanskar rivers can be seen here. Pathar Sahib Gurudwara and Magnetic Hill are other sites of interest enroute.
Likir monastery
The high point of the visit to Likir monastery, two hours from Nimu, was the sudden light snowfall. I was delighted as it was my first experience of snowfall and for a person from the plains, witnessing snowfall in an April summer seemed incredible.
The journey to Pangong Lake at an altitude of about 14000 feet proved to be the most challenging since we had travel through winding roads at very high altitudes. Expansive sheets of snow covered both sides of the roads and streaks of gradually melting snow crisscrossed brown mountains.
The Indian Army has outposts at various strategic points where tea and medical aid is thoughtfully provided to one and all free of cost. Chang La at a height of about 17500 feet is one such outpost. At the pass, a temple flanked by colourful flags with Buddhist chants in the backdrop of snow capped mountains made for a picturesque sight.
We discovered during our travels that most shops were shut owing to cold weather and lean tourist season; and to buy even one meal to eat along the way was challenging. Had our stay not been arranged by some Army officers we knew, we might have been in for a tough time.
Thus our food, accommodation and travel within Ladakh was taken care of.
The Pangong Lake extending up to the India China border offers stunning views owing to its sheer expanse and its contrast with surrounding brown mountains. Though mostly frozen, in parts where the lake was fluid, we spotted sparkling blue waters. Severe cold prevented us from stopping there long. During our night halt at a mess in Durbuk, we were glad of the giant “bukharis” which can warm up a room in jiffy.
After a day's rest we set out for Nubra Valley which took us ten hours to reach owing to a damaged snow tractor in the middle of the road causing many vehicles to get stuck. Cooperation among drivers in these roads is to a remarkable extent. The difficult terrain and weather seem to be in part responsible for it. We also crossed Khardung La at a height of about 17500 feet which is one of the highest motorable passes in the world pass enroute to Nubra Valley.
Some of our pleasantest moments were in Nubra Valley owing to the moderate weather and some green relief in the terrain. The rolling sand dunes in which we played and buried our feet with warm sand were a welcome change from the icy snow. An impressive sight in the valley is the new Buddha temple. “The old Buddha sits cross legged while the new Buddha sits with the legs down,” our driver, a Ladakhi local told us.
Following a night halt at Partapur, we returned to Leh to see the Shanti stupa which is worth a visit for sculptures of the Buddha. Going to the Leh market nearby, at the only German bakery we found open, we tried yak cheese which tasted just like regular cheese, only a tad saltier.
Though many shops
were closed, turquoise
jewellery was being
sold, albeit at
exorbitant rates. “I
love Tibet” bags and
Tibetan literature were
on sale at some shops
since Tibetan refugees
constitute some part of
the population.
Returning to Delhi on an
early morning flight the
next day, as the
mountains which had been
our constant companion
for a week disappeared
from sight, we solemnly
resolved to return to
Ladakh.
The Hindu, 16th
May 2011
Young blood
Dr
Amit Banerjee, Lok Nayak
Hospital’s longstanding
Medical Superintendent,
put in his papers last
week, citing personal
grounds. Sources in the
Delhi government’s
Health department say
this is the first of
many changes at the the
helm of government
hospitals. Leading
facilities such as DDU
and Guru Gobind Singh
hospitals will soon see
new doctors at the top.
This will be followed by
transfers of doctors at
the Directorate of
Health Services,
including a possible
shift in the Director’s
post as well. While many
officials cited these
changes as routine,
hospital sources said
these administrative
changes would be
followed by much junior
doctors making it to the
top posts — a move that
is raising many an
eyebrow in government
hospitals.
All in the family
Several senior
bureaucrats are slated
to retire this year,
including Chief
Secretary Rakesh Mehta,
who retires in March.
Food and Civil Supplies
Commissioner Jayshree
Raghuraman and Finance
Secretary J P Singh are
other prominent names.
The Delhi government
wanted to nominate
Raghuraman as member of
the NDMC council, but
since she was retiring
on January 31, the
government decided to
give the post to her
sister Rita Kumar.
Binding order
Despite being very
utilitarian,
cycle-rickshaws are
increasingly deemed a
menace, particularly in
the Chandni Chowk area.
So much so, that the
market associaion of the
Walled City has been
constantly writing to
the Lieutenant-Governor,
the Traffic department
and the Municipal
Corporation of Delhi
(MCD) to exercise a cap
on their numbers that
are permitted in any
given area.
Interestingly, all three
offices express absolute
powerlessness over the
matter, citing a High
Court order which states
that neither the MCD nor
the Traffic department
can impound or challan
rickshaws. The fast
developing city is also
struggling with an
increased number of
migrants, resulting in
many more rickshaws in
any given area than
actually required. A
senior government
official said there are
close to 10 lakh
rickshaws in the city,
and not even two per
cent of the
rickshaw-pullers had
permits — only a handful
were familiar with
traffic rules. “The High
Court order, however,
restricts us from taking
any action,” a senior
official said.
Glory days long
past
Discontentment among
Congress legislators in
Delhi seems to be
simmering relentlessly.
A legislator, who is in
his third term and is
deemed to be close to
Chief Minister Sheila
Dikshit, was chatting
with journalists at a
Cabinet minister’s room
last week about rampant
corruption across
departments. While
speaking about the
development work done
for the Commonwealth
Games, the legislator
admitted that corruption
is the biggest threat to
the government at
present. Even
legislators are finding
it tough to get
officials to execute
work without indulging
in corrupt practices. At
a meeting with Dikshit
this month, a senior
Congress legislator had
demanded that all
Cabinet ministers resign
on account of poor
performance.
Division of labour
The Ghaziabad police is
notorious for its
ineffectiveness in beat
policing, evident in the
city’s growing crime
figures. Ghaziabad SSP
Raghubir Lal is now
trying to seek help from
civilian counterparts
whose job profile comes
closest to the beat
constabulary — the
chowkidaars employed by
local colonies. The
police recently
undertook a PR exercise
to reach out to these
watchmen by distributing
torches and whistles to
them. Help was also
sought from them to curb
crime in their
respective areas.
Damage control
With the MCD elections
slated for next year,
councillors who have
been doing a lousy job
are being subjected to
tough interrogation by
BJP leaders. On
Saturday, Venkaiah Naidu
called a meeting of BJP
councillors at his
residence and told them
to behave themselves if
they hoped to win the
next elections. Those
who have been found
indulging in corruption
have been warned. “Naidu
said those who have
corruption charges
against them may not be
given a ticket at all if
they do not change
themselves,” said a
councillor.
Loud and clear
The Indian Medical
Association is on a
modernisation spree. The
country’s nodal
association of medical
practitioners has hired
a new PR agency to
manage their
communications. The
decision comes just
before nation- wide
protests begin against
the proposed
undergraduate rural
medicine course. The
IMA’s own PRO apart, the
agency has been
specially instructed to
follow “aggressive” PR
measures. Repeated mails
were sent to different
media organisations on
how such a course will
promote quackery by
endorsing ‘half-baked’
doctors. Medical
education should not be
compromised on the basis
of settings, whether
urban and rural, IMA
officials believe. “We
felt our view was not
being projected strongly
enough,” said a senior
office-bearer. The
organisation felt that
after the judiciary’s
nod, the political
backing for the proposal
was the last straw. “We
are the largest
association of qualified
and practising doctors
in the country. We felt
we must do more to
project our view,” he
added.
Dial M for match
A cricket match provided
the West Delhi police a
lead into the murder of
a 20-year-old vegetable
vendor in Southwest
Delhi’s Kakraula
village. The accused,
who was out to ‘defend’
his honour by preventing
the victim, his tenant,
from befriending his
16-year-old daughter,
was missing for three
days after the victim’s
body was found on
January 13. The police
zeroed in on him after
investigations revealed
that the man, who
despised cricket, had
reportedly invited the
victim and his friends
for a party at his
residence to watch the
India-South Africa match
the day of the incident.
Indian Express, 16th May 2011
In India, we have a propensity to treat our heritage as part of a flowing river. In a better mood I call it the votive figure syndrome, or when I am miffed about it, the shaadi shamiyana syndrome. With all love and respect, we instal pandals, place the deities in them, chant the correct mantras to invoke prana prathishtha and finally bid a tearful adieu before immersing the votive figure into a river or the ocean. These occasions are so many that it has become an intrinsic part of our psyche. These are such important aspects of our cultural moorings that they are virtually inseparable with notions of culture.
In such a scenario, virtually everything which is not part of here and now or damaged (khandit) in any way, must find itself at the bottom of the river or the sea. One has to just drag the sea and riverbeds and the booty, which is found will fill up many museums.
The recent report that Mamata Banerjee is unable to gather funds to set up railway museums, despite the buildings being ready at two locations, set off a train of thoughts (pun totally intended) about how we treat heritage. Many officials who were too scared to be quoted said that the Railways should be running trains not setting up museums. This is logical from their point of view. However, this is like saying why should we go nuclear, when we have so many empty stomachs to fill? These are obviously people with no sense of history, heritage or imagination.
Railways in India has such a vibrant history, which if not preserved, will just be lost forever. Babus should realise that these museums will recover the costs sooner than we think. Just a thought: Many steam engines are going to phase out soon; maybe these can become part of the exhibits of the mooted museums? By any stretch, UK takes the “bakery” when it comes to museums. You think of a subject, they have museum for it. It may be a small one-room place, but it is there, replete with printed history and documentation. Some of the unusual ones I can off hand recall are: fan museum, maritime museum, theatre museum, museum of textiles, museum of footwear, museum for kimonos, museum of porcelain, museum of Sherlock Holmes, museum of war etc.
In India, I can think of so many areas where we need to preserve for posterity, so many things and so many historical objects. When Sushma Swaraj was the minister of information and broadcasting, she had mooted the idea of a media museum. Considering we have so many firsts to our credit historically and such fast changing technology, the museum of media would have been a splendid idea. Media houses could have donated old machines and other exhibits and maybe even some land for the museum. But myopic media barons did not take it up. Similarly, we don’t have museum for cinema, theatre, dance and music. There could be a museum for beauty, capturing traditional objects and ingredients used in beautification.
Food is such a big deal in India and there is no museum of food, its traditional preparations, utensils, ovens, stoves, et al. Crafts museum should be the norm in regions especially in places where there are crafts pockets, like terracotta, paper mache, (Bihar and Kashmir have two diametrically distinct styles), metal crafts, folk and regional styles of painting, carpets, paper crafts, designs across the board. The list is indeed endless.
Shops attached to museums should sell replicas and create a niche for themselves. In fact we are still in a position to offer “replicas” that are “originals” rather than “copies”. As we in India live concurrently on so many planes and soon these things will be of times past and then we might wake up and start looking to preserve. And the time to recognize the urgency and capture them is now before it is too late. Private partners should be involved along with public enterprise and it should be mandatory for them to preserve and nurture crafts in regional centres.
Movements should be started for voluntary donations of objects and recognition of donors should be the norm. It should become a matter of pride for people to donate to museums.
These museums should not be dead and boring repositories, but instead they must be vibrant and living interactive centres, where the young and old can find something of interest. The idea is not to mummify culture but to preserve it. It is our bounden duty to make these repositories for future generations.
Hecklers will
invariably try to shoot
down the idea saying
there is no museum
culture in our country.
If there are not enough
museums, where will the
culture develop? Let us
not take it for granted
all that is flowing in
front of our eyes, but
will be history soon.
The Asian Age,
16th May 2011
These days when Delhi is preparing for the 100th year of the Coronation Durbar, not all are enthused, says R.V. SMITH
It is that time of the year when people in the Walled City particularly relive the dire events of 1857. So was it this past week on May 11 when members of the old families of Delhi offered fateha for those who laid down their lives during the Uprising, which had broken out a day earlier in Meerut. Few indeed are such residents now though 45 years ago there were some whose grandfathers had witnessed those days of mayhem.
There is a difference, however, this year which marks the centenary of the Coronation Durbar of George V and Queen Mary. Haji Zahuruddin Qureshi's son recalls that his father was ten years old when the Durbar was held and he was taken to the steps of the Jama Masjid by his maternal grandfather (nana) to watch the spectacle. It happened to be a cold, misty December morning but that did not deter the people of the area from occupying the stands facing the Red Fort. Just when the sun peeped out, the royal procession emerged from the fort but to native eyes all the horsemen appeared the same goras with deadpan faces. It was difficult for them to identify the king who too appeared to them like the rest. There was no halo round his head, no flag-bearer preceding him and there was no crown on his head either.
Sore disappointment
This was a sore disappointment as they expected the British monarch to be as conspicuous as the Moghul emperors, Bahadur Shah Zafar, and before him Akbar Shah Sani and Shah Alam nobody had to point them out to the onlookers, for they could be identified even from a distance. Not so when the scars of the Great Uprising had not fully healed. Ahmed Ali author of “Twilight in Delhi”, and scion of an old and revered family of the Capital himself, has written about a fakir known as Bahadur Shah, who only sang of ghazals of the ill-starred emperor. He has also mentioned Mirza Nasirul Mulk, Zafar's youngest son, who used to beg on the streets of Delhi and looked with dismay at the tamasha being staged by the firangis in 1911. Many of his kin were also beggars or cooks, masalchis, tonga and ekka drivers or sellers of cut fruit. Their women still observed purdah in dingy houses with gunny bag curtains on the doors. Their plight was not hidden from the then residents of Delhi many of whom seethed with rage at the pomp and show of the coronation which was akin to rubbing salt on old wounds.
The Tommies parading the roads or trying to instil order among the assembled crown were the butt of many a joke. They were described as red-faced monkeys or hoosh.
The rajas, maharajas and nawabs who had congregated for the show also did not escape censure and ridicule as they were considered stooges of the British, whose support to their foreign masters had resulted in the failure of the First War of Independence.
These days when Delhi is preparing for the 100th year of the Coronation Durbar, not all are enthused about the re-enactment of a show that was supposed to bring home the fact that the good old days of the Moghuls were over and the throne was now occupied by a King-Emperor who lived overseas.
Who was it who said
that though things
change they remain very
much the same? The
antagonistic feeling of
a century ago is still
very much alive. You
just have to scratch the
skin and see for
yourself. Hurt feelings
keep smouldering in the
heart long after the
deed is done.
The Hindu, 16th May 2011
It's a tussle between preserving heritage and fast-tracking development. Though the law prohibits construction within 300 metres of monuments, it hasn't deterred residents from seeking permission to build. And with the National Monuments Authority (NMA) headless, the queue for getting no-objection certificates is getting longer. Delhi tops the list with over 250 applications piling up with the authority, awaiting no-objection certificates (NOCs).
Member-secretary, NMA, Praveen Srivastava told TOI that field surveys had been undertaken in 50 per cent of applications awaiting NOCs. They were proposing a category wherein the state-level competent authority will be empowered to issue permission for minor repairs or urgent work. "It will take some time for people to become familiar with the process. We have asked superintending archaeologists from various circles to accept applications from those living in prohibited or regulated zones. These can then be forwarded to the authority,'' said Srivastava.
The challenge is to strike a balance between conservation and development. But experts say the law is stringent and doesn't allow much flexibility. The Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains (Amendment and Validation) Act, 2010, does not allow regulated zones to be within less than 200 metres of a monument. There is a blanket ban on construction within 100 metres. "There is a provision to expand the regulated zone, but we cannot make it less than 200 metres, no matter what the size, location or significance of the monument. Construction is prohibited within a radius of 300 metres of an ASI-protected monument,'' said Srivastava. Earlier, he was the additional director-general in ASI.
Srivastava admitted
there's a growing
restlessness among those
affected by the new law
as all permissions have
been cancelled for over
a year. "As applications
are piling up, we have
sent a proposal that the
authority's
member-secretary and ASI
director-general can
give permission in the
absence of a head. But
we are yet to get a
response. The
appointment has to be
made with a lot of care
and that's why the
process is being
delayed. Then
applications can be
disposed of within three
months,'' said
Srivastava.
Times of India, 16th May 2011
Hidden on the road from Chamrajnagar to Bangalore is a Chola town called Yelandur that was once home to a confidante of Tipu Sultan
We had no idea how we landed on the road leading to Yelandur. There was no scheduled stop planned here either .We were on the road, driving from Chamrajnagar to Bangalore, when the man at the wheel suddenly swerved to the right instead of heading straight and lo, Yelandur interrupted us on the way, with a burst of energy.
It was a Sunday and the farmers' day out. We caught the town, colourful and chaotic, in the midst of its weekly “santhe”. Heady bargains reached high decibel levels, as all the local produce were out on display. Cattle vendors jostled their way through. The sea of humanity flowed and ebbed as loads of plastic ware, household needs and knick-knacks completed the picture. The locals were happy to be photographed, but they had no time for conversations.
As I cut through the noise and stepped out of the market, I came face to face with a huge bungalow, looking rather resplendent in its white-washed glory. It was in the middle of a makeover. This was the old bungalow of Dewan Purnaiya, the man who rose from writing accounts for a grocer to becoming the first Dewan of the princely state of Mysore. A close confidante of Tipu Sultan, Dewan Purnaiya had also served under Hyder Ali and later on the Wodeyars. The bungalow was not opened to visitors, but I heard that it will soon house a museum. Locals whispered how treasures were found here. Later I learnt that several manuscripts and even antique coins had been found. Locals remember the town as a jagir or territory granted to the Dewan in the early 19th century, but the town has a history that dates back to the Later Cholas. According to the Mysore Gazetteer compiled by Hayavadana Rao, it was referred to as “Illaimaradur or the Young Maradur” in a Tamil inscription which also mentions an agrahara here. The Cholas called it Cholendrasimha Chaturvedi Mangalam.
No town is complete without an ancient temple and we discovered a couple – one near the market and the other adjacent to the Dewan's bungalow. The entrance of the latter was rather inviting, with an ornamental mandapa carved with sculptures of gods and goddesses on the pillars, panels, ceiling and the outer walls. This was a 16th century Gaurishwara temple built by the chieftains of the Padinadu or Hadinadu dynasty, feudatories under the Vijaynagar Empire.
We walked past the entrance to the many shrines of the temple which have been restored. The temple had unearthed a few inscriptions too. One of them mentions that it was originally built in 1500 by Singedepa and that the Mahadwara – the entrance – was added by Muddaraja, another chieftain, in 1654. Another inscription refers to it as “Eleyindur or the town of young moon” and compares it to “the eye or centre of a lotus surrounded by eight petals which are the eight hills.” Today, Yelandur connects you to one of them, the Billi Giri Rangan Hills, if you are heading from Bangalore.
I stood near an old
well and looked around.
Some men were fast
asleep under the trees,
while a few others were
gossiping. Meanwhile at
the market, the
bargaining had reached
an all-time frenzy. It
was just another day for
these locals lost in
their own little world.
The Hindu, 16th May 2011
With rare art pieces collected during his travels across the world, fashion designer JJ Valaya’s The Home of the Traveler represents various ancient dynasties resplendent in history. Team Viva reports
It wasn’t easy to acquire the paper-mache young Buddha of the early 20th century from Burma, but for fashion designer J J Valaya it was a question of passion for art. And soon after the designer set his eyes on it, the Shan-style Buddhist art got delivered to his Delhi home.
A few other masterpieces like Singhas, a pair of mythological lions from 19th century Thailand and a Cambodian sandstone sculpture also have similar stories related to their journey to Valaya’s home. “The more I travelled, the more I found myself inspired by the culture, art and architecture of different countries and my desire to bring back the most exquisite offerings grew stronger,” says Valaya who recently launched The Home of The Traveler (THT), a concept born out of the designer’s affinity to fine living.
THT conjures up romantic visions of a bygone time in Asia: of royal ceremonies hosted by great Kings, fabulously ornamented temples, the brooding majesty of a ruined monument, scenic glimpses of busy waterways and tropical luxuriance. Reveals the designer, “It is a place where kingliness and priesthood are intricately linked, as the King is the highest upholder of the Buddhist faith as well as constitutionally the head of the country. Starting with our first show SIAM - The Monk and The Monarch, I have attempted to bring together artistic nuances that traverse time and bind both these aspects ethereally. The artifacts represent various ancient dynasties resplendent in history, with each one speaking the distinct language of the civilization it once belonged to.”
Ask him about his favourite pieces and the designer is quick to reply, “Each one of them has been very carefully selected. Some of the interesting pieces are Buddha in Boyhood, a torso in paper-mache of young Buddha, found at the border to Burma, Monks with Begging Bowls — a set of five young monks in sandstone from the kilns of Mengrai and Throne of Buddha — traditional carved seat in Mandalay style from Myanmar, from early 20th Century, Burma.”
The designer wants to eventually amalgamate pieces of the past with modern day philosophies of art and architecture and create contemporary designs for a fine living. “If I had not been a fashion designer, perhaps I would have been an architect. All places of heritage and culture touch my heart no matter how diverse their stylistic offering,” he said, adding that places like Turkey, Russia and China are now on his list for future collections.
“It has to be those
places that are
untouched by mass
commercialisation and
have an element of
mystery and lost history
to them. The world is my
oyster!” comes his
philosophical reply.
The Pioneer, 16th May 2011
Union Minister for Forests and Environment Jairam Ramesh has said the Centre is planning a bigger project for the protection and restoration of Wular Lake, Asia’s largest fresh water lake situated in north Kashmir.
“The cleaning of Dal Lake project is on progress and the Union government is committed to a much bigger project for the protection and restoration of Wular Lake,” Ramesh said at the inaugural function of 3rd International Buyer-Seller meet here.
Speaking on the occasion, the Union Minister for Forests and Environment highlighted the initiative taken by him as the Minister of State for Industries and Commerce for the launch of buyer-seller meet in the state.
Lauding the young and energetic leadership of Omar Abdullah in steering the state out of the difficulties on development and other fronts, Ramesh said his personal and the support of his ministry would always be available to the state wherever and whenever required.
Ramesh also referred to the role of the Institute of Handicrafts Development, Entrepreneurship Development Institute and Carpet Development Centre in upgrading the skills in various fields, including handicraft sector.
The event was organised by the Kashmir Chamber of Commerce and Industries (KCCI) in collaboration with Jammu and Kashmir Bank. More than 40 stalls have been established in the three-day buyer-seller meet.
Chief Minister Omar
Abdullah appreciated the
efforts of the Union
Minister in the
development of
handicrafts sector in
the state and has said
his good offices will be
utilised to resolve the
issues in the Union
Forest and Environment
Ministry pertaining to
the handicraft and other
sectors.
The Tribune, 16th May 2011
The Archeological Survey of India (ASI) came in for some sharp criticism from the High Court as it censured the government body for its “typically bureaucratic” approach in denying information to a historian and failing to post information on its website for use by academicians.
Justice S Muralidhar, while hearing a petition by Professor R Nath, pulled up the ASI for its laxity in falling in line with the Right To Information (RTI) Act, which obligates every public body to upload necessary information on its website within 120 days of the transparency law coming into force.
The petition was filed through RTI lawyer Girija K Verma in 2008 but the ASI, especially its Agra circle, had failed to upload data on its website. Despite several reminders, the heritage body had failed to explain why information pertaining to the different circles of the ASI, including Agra, was not there on the website. Infuriated by the lapses, Justice Muralidhar summoned ASI Director General Gautam Sen Gupta.
Even as Gupta presented himself at the hearing, the ASI counsel admitted “negligence” on the part of the Agra Circle and submitted that all the circles have now been directed to put the information on the website so a hyperlink could be activated for visitors.
The counsel further handed over the documents, which contained information that Nath, a retired professor of history from Rajasthan University who has been studying Moghul monuments of Agra and Fatehpur Sikri for nearly half a century, had sought from the Agra circle in 2007.
Justice Muralidhar then enquired from the counsel whether any time limit was prescribed for uploading the information, the answer for which came in the negative.
“This is very serious. It is a statutory requirement. People keep running around, not knowing from where they can get the information. Don’t be so lax. Let me make it clear that the court is cracking the whip whereas the DG should have done it. The information is locked up for no reason,” remarked the judge.
Advocate Verma also stated that there must be a time limit for posting information on the website, to which the court agreed. “Historians and professors need valuable information for carry out their research, but you (ASI) have disentitled it to them. I am not satisfied with your overall general attitude,” Justice Muralidhar told the ASI counsel and added that it was “unfortunate” that they did not consider the advent of the RTI Act as an opportunity to disseminate information.
On a plea by Verma
that a penalty should be
imposed on the ASI for
not providing
information within the
stipulated time, the
court said it would
consider it at a
subsequent stage and the
petition must be kept
alive so the ASI commits
itself to the task.
“Actually, it is a
culture of
functionality. Kill
scholarship, kill
researches is the
attitude. It is nothing
but typical bureaucracy,
but as far as the High
Court is concerned, this
will have to change and
we will make it change,”
said Justice Muralidhar.
The court then asked DG
Gupta to issue further
instructions, indicating
time limits within which
the circle-wise websites
— with hyperlinks — will
be set up. “He will also
issue detailed
instructions on the
procedures to be
followed and the time
limits within which
certified printed copies
of the information
sought under the RTI
will be provided to the
applicants,” the court
directed, adding that
adequate publicity will
also given to the said
procedures.
Fixing the next
hearing for July, the
court asked the ASI to
file an affidavit on
compliance in four
weeks.
Indian Express, 18th May 2011
As Ahmedabad
celebrates 600 years of
existence, Raksha
Bharadia discovers an
up-to-date perspective
on the city in this
book.
A comprehensive and
much-awaited chronicle
of Gujarat’s leading
city since the 18th
century, Ahmedabad can
be seen as a tribute by
authors Achyut Yagnik
and Suchitra Sheth that
commemorates 600 years
of the founding of the
city.
The book provides an
up-to-date perspective
on the city that held
nationwide importance by
becoming one of the
central points as
Mahatma Gandhi’s
karmabhumi during
India’s freedom
movement.
From Royal City to
Megacity: The
introductory chapters
elaborate on Ahmedabad’s
royal past history that
began with its founding
in 1411 by Sultan Ahmed
Shah and progresses into
the significant literary
and religious influences
and political swings it
was subject to.
We also get a fair idea
of the everyday life and
the natural calamities
that affected it, time
and again. The authors
scrutinise the momentous
periods in Ahmedabad’s
history and there is no
dearth of information on
each and every aspect
that the book deals
with.
It throws a flood of
light on the development
of the city’s renowned
crafts and textiles, and
architecture (the jalis
and jharokas) which was
a ‘synthesis and
symbiosis’ of various
influences. It is rather
fascinating to learn
about the modification
of the simple jhoola
(swing) into intricately
carved and ornamented
ones, which found a
place in most
traditional paintings
and became an integral
item of export.
The establishment of the
distinctive pols
(colonies along narrow
streets) and parabdis
(shelter where grain and
water was kept for
birds) was a truly
noteworthy development.
Apart from presenting a
complete analysis of the
structured trade
association that existed
in Gujarat even in the
11th century, one of the
notable aspects of the
book is its extensive
study of the
introduction of modern
education in India,
which received a lot of
attention in the early
19th century, with the
objective of restoring
literature and backing
up the sciences.
As the authors examine
the educational
development, we learn
about how education had
affected the different
sections of the
population. This
analysis is particularly
meaningful in the
context of the turmoil
which the
multi-religious society
and a society that was
fast becoming more
industrialised, was
faced with. It is
interesting to note the
emphasis laid on
education for girls,
higher education and
growth of the
vernacular, which
eventually culminated in
the setting up of
printing presses (1845)
to print school text
books and in time
newspapers.
Amedabant, Amedavat,
Ahmadabath, Ahmdavad,
Karnavati and finally
Ahmedabad — A city with
several names and
numerous facets, which
in spite of being
‘Gandhi’s karmabhumi’
was not free of riots,
disorder and religious
anarchy. The city went
through catastrophic
transformations from the
mid-19th century.
Gradually, the ground
for each disaster became
more religious than
economic.
Notwithstanding the
efforts of Gandhi who
persevered to exemplify
that the people could
live together peacefully
despite religious
differences, the
long-established value
systems were eventually
undermined and by the
end of the 20th century,
we had a communally
divided Ahmedabad.
Achyut Yagnik and
Suchitra Sheth, who have
also co-authored The
Shaping of Modern
Gujarat: Plurality,
Hindutva and Beyond,
have presented an
adequate coverage of
this illustrious city,
which is attested by the
extensive bibliography
of the sources. Apart
from being rich in
information about the
contours of the growth,
development and the
tribulations of the
city, we have bits of
forgotten facts in
spurts which are novel
and valuable, for
example, the tomb of the
great Urdu poet Wali
Gujarati which was
destroyed by a furious
crowd during the
communal violence of
2002.
The next day the
government eradicated
the site by extending
the road over it. There
is no doubt that the
book has the potential
to reach a high
watermark of success,
but it does show certain
limitations. A vast
amount of data has been
put together, but there
are repetitions
especially in the
initial part, omission
of which could have
cemented the book and
made it comprehensive,
yet concise. The overall
language is lucid and
articulate, but the
style of narration is
somewhat humdrum and
rather pedagogic because
of which, it does not
hold the interest of the
reader throughout the
book.
Putting in bits of
attention-grabbing
trivia and incidents,
could have made it a
more enjoyable read. In
all fairness however, it
cannot be ignored that,
the book belongs to the
factual and historical
genre, which leaves
limited scope for
creative ingenuity.
The preceding
observations are only to
suggest further possible
enrichment of the book,
hence, the lack of these
by no means, diminish
its intrinsic importance
which is a prominent
addition to the list of
the very best
biographies. It covers
almost the entire
spectrum of what one
would want to know about
the city and its journey
from a royal city to a
mega city.
The Pioneer, 19th May 2011
Now, you can see
masterpieces of the
country's art under one
roof. On the occasion of
international museum
day, Archaeological
Survey of India (ASI)
inaugurated a new
gallery in the
children's museum at
Siri Fort which boasts
of life-size replicas of
art work like Didarganj
Yakshi, Gudimallam Siva,
Preaching Buddha,
Mahishamardini,
Mahabalipuram, Rudra
Siva, Jain Statue
Gomateshwar, Jesus
Christ on Cross etc.
At present there are 22
pieces of art on display
with elaborate
description but ASI
Delhi circle chief KK
Mohammed, who conceived
the project, said they
were planning to bring
the number to about a
hundred in the coming
months. "We proposed to
bring these masterpieces
under a single umbrella,
which we thought would
be a great opportunity
especially for children.
They will not have to go
to various states to see
them. These size
replicas are just like
the original. The new
gallery will soon become
a huge hit with
visitors,'' said
Mohammed.
The day was also
celebrated at the
children's museum at a
function organized
jointly by
Archaeological Survey of
India, Delhi circle and
the Northern Branch
Museum of the ASI.
Social activist Ajeet
Cour was the chief guest
and a painting
competition was
organized in which
students of various
schools participated.
The winners were given
away prizes at the end
of the function. The
competition was open to
children of class VIII
and IX. The ASI has been
celebrating the day
since 1977.
Times of India, 19th May 2011
Charandeep Singh takes a look at some family forts of Punjab and Himachal Pradesh, which continue to maintain their royal customs and traditions
Undivided Punjab’s martial history and cultural heritage is chronicled in many forts that dot various parts of the state. Luckily, most of those who have inherited these stellar monuments are strong willed to preserve these heritage buildings. Gurjitinder Singh Virk (64) runs a fish farm at Sri Chamkaur Sahib. "The only unaccomplished task I have in my life is to resurrect the Kandhola Fort, which was bequeathed to me. The fort is in a state of dilapidation. I have got the blueprints ready, on how to reconstruct this majestic old structure. I would be using the same ‘Nanakshahi brick’, which was used in the original structure," informs Gurjitinder. Kandhola Fort is spread over one acre and the reconstruction would cost nearly Rs 6 crore.
Is it an act of obsession? "No, it is the preservation of my family heritage, which, if not preserved, will soon go into oblivion. I have to restore my fort so that my family name continues," observes Gurjitinder. `A0
To maintain these forts in their puritanical form is a Herculean task. But it also gives an insight to the coming generations about the life and times of their forefathers. "I have maintained the structure in its original form. Even the wallpapers remain the same as when my grandfather renovated it in 1940. I have also preserved the Gobelin tapestries and cabinets from Doge’s Palace in Venice. You can find these only here or in some old British mansions in England. I have maintained the same lifestyle and use the same old silverware belonging to my grandfather in which the tea is still served, and even the distinct style with which the food is served and table is laid, still continues. This continuance of the old royal lifestyle is the intangible heritage which I have preserved and passed on to my son and grandson," says a beaming Kanwar Ratanjit Singh of Chapslee House, Shimla, which was the summer residence of Maharaja of Kapurthala.
With many original owners still residing in forts, many of which are away from the urban landscape and culture, life can be a bit secluded and monotonous. There are no neighbours around. Even the urban centres are far away and to commute everyday can be cumbersome. "I was born and brought up in Chandigarh. After marriage, I had to live in the Bharatgarh fort where my in-laws resided. It was a cultural shock for me. At times, loneliness used to catch up. But I adjusted and now I feel proud of myself, since I am preserving a legacy with my family," expresses Maninder Kaur who is married to a descendent of Singhpuria Misl and owner of Bharatgarh Fort, near Anandpur Sahib.
These forts have special significance in their family folklore also. "We have the samadhs of all our ancestors right on the entrance of our fort. On Diwali we light candles on these samadhs. All our family marriages also take place in the fort only. We take pride in calling ourselves as the Kathgarh family," says Rajpal Singh Mahal (87), oldest member of the Kathgarh family. This fort is near Nawanshahr.
The maintenance of these forts takes quite a toll on the finances of the owners. But some enterprising minds have converted their property into heritage stays so that these properties become sustainable. "These forts as such are white elephants. It is easier to maintain a new structure with similar dimensions, rather than maintaining these ancient structures. Since the size is very big, it becomes a bit easy to encash the vacant area and convert them into heritage stays so that they become self sustainable," adds Amar Chandel, who has converted his Ramgarh Fort into a heritage hotel.
On the issue of commercialising the heritage properties Kanwar Ratanjit Singh of Chapslee has an interesting anecdote, "When I shifted to Chapslee House in the early 1970s, we started a school there. To fund the expenses of the school, I was toying with the idea of converting Chapslee House into a guesthouse. Then a friend of mine gifted me a book, written by Lord Bedford, titled How to be a snob? He wrote that if the royalty opens up their residences, the commoners will have a privilege to see these residences and they will even pay for it. I, too, opened up Chapslee Palace for people. Now people come to see Chapslee House for which they pay me," informs Kanwar Ratanjit.
The owners of Bharatgarh Fort also plan to convert a secluded portion of the fort into a heritage resort. "We spend around Rs 7 lakh annually on the maintenance of the fort. We thought of converting a portion into a heritage stay, so that the fort becomes self sustainable", says Deepinder Singh of Bharatgarh Fort.`A0
This concept of having a brush with the royalty and enjoying a stay in the environs of these forts has gone down very well with the public at large. Most of these forts have some customs and traditions, endemic to them. For example, the Ramgarh royal family is of strict vegetarians and the same trend continues in their heritage stay also.
Most of these heritage stays or resorts are individual efforts by the owners. A light push from the state government can make these heritage stays a hit with tourists. If these heritage stays are promoted at a national level — as is being done in Rajasthan and even in some European nations, who are promoting their castles.
Since the maintenance
of these properties a
costly affair, doesn’t
it make sense to dispose
them off? `A0"This is my
heritage. It is
priceless. I cannot even
put a price on it,’
observes Kanwar
Ratanjit. "These ancient
structures are the
hallmark of our
existence. I am the
ninth successive
generation living in
this fort, I cannot even
think of selling it up,"
winds up Deepinder Singh
of Bharatgarh, with
pride in his eyes.
The Tribune, 21st May 2011
A sombre-looking
earthen Grecian face
stared down at us as we
waited in the foyer of
art-patron Dr
Harikishore Kejriwal’s
home in Bangalore. The
door alongside opened
into a room where framed
letters covered an
entire wall.
Kejriwal entered. A
sprightly octogenarian
with a childlike smile
and infectious
enthusiasm, he ushered
us inside. And walked
us, very energetically,
through his awesome
home. Sculptures,
paintings, coins,
porcelainware,
manuscripts, scrolls,
carpets, metalware and
also stuccos dating back
to the 3rd century BC,
and very rare specimens…
the house was a stunning
private museum. Many of
the exquisite objets
d’art took our breath
away. Three hours into
our visit and we had
barely managed brief
glimpses of this amazing
private art collection —
such was the vast
quantity and variety on
display.
The collection was built
by him from 1948 onwards
— the love for art
instilled by his father
Ramkishore Kejriwal, a
well-known art promoter
of then Calcutta.
Visitors to their home
included some best known
artists of that time —
Jamini Roy, Nandalal
Bose, etc. And
Kejriwal’s education at
Hindu School — the
hotbed of culture — and
association with the
Tagore family, and other
cultural stalwarts and
art patrons further
reinforced this passion.
Right beside the front
door were earthen
stuccos excavated in
Bengal dating back to
3rd century BC when
Alexander invaded India.
The adjacent room had
walls filled with framed
letters from stalwarts
like Mahatma Gandhi,
Rabindranath Tagore
(including his last
letter), Subhash Chandra
Bose, etc.
Walking further into the
home, we encountered
more gems. Every shelf,
wall and tabletop held
treasures. A metal knife
from the Harappan
civilisation, a
handwritten Quran from
13th century AD;
European candelabras
from the time of Louis
the 15th; a sixth
century AD Shiva Linga
and bust; a Buddha from
the Mauryan period; 12th
century Jain
Kalpasutras; a richly
detailed 15th century
wooden panel from Tamil
Nadu depicting Girija
Kalyanam
(Shiva-Parvathi’s
marriage); figures in
bricks from the 18th
century Bishnupur
terracotta temples; and
gorgeous Tibetan
tankhas, and rare
Persian jamavars and
carpets... “Some carpets
have 3,500 knots per
square inch. The one
with the Jahangir figure
in wool and silk is from
1612 AD,” he revealed.
The corners of the
drawing rooms in all his
flats and their
entrances had large
statues mounted on
pedestals. In the rooms,
magnificent statues of
Vishnu, Chola bronzes,
and seated and standing
Buddhas (from Burma and
Indonesia) jostled for
space beside Kangra and
Mughal era paintings and
the more modern ones by
Jamini Roy, Rabindranath
Tagore, Abanindranath
Tagore, Svetoslav
Roerich, etc.
Every object evoked a
memory — either
associated with its
acquisition or about the
artist himself. Kejriwal
regaled us with those
stories. And some
recalled poetry — a
stunning Mughal era
carpet had him breaking
into Mirza Ghalib’s
poetry; European
sculptures had him
quoting John Keats and
Robert Browning; Jamini
Roy paintings made him
recall Tagore’s poems...
And all objects were
aesthetically displayed.
But then, Kejriwal has
visited some of the
world’s best art
galleries and in India,
he is vice-president of
Karnataka Chitrakala
Parishat; trustee, Birla
Academy of Art and
Culture, etc.
He has donated a
substantial part of his
collection of art and
artefacts to Karnataka
Chitrakala Parishat
where they are displayed
in several galleries. He
gave away about 350
paintings and drawings,
and 250 sculptures from
India as well as
artworks by the great
masters of Europe. It
was a magnificent
gesture. Very few Indian
collectors have done
this. In the West,
however, many art
collectors donate their
collections readily to
museums.
We paused for a drink of
water at the dining
table. Above, there was
another eye-catcher — a
12th-century dancing
Ganesha flanked by 17th
century Rajasthani
paintings depicting
Krishna Leela. Alongside
was a shelf dotted with
more priceless objects —
mostly busts — found in
excavations in Andhra
Pradesh, including a
metal Saraswati from the
19th century. And, on
either side of this (and
other dining tables)
were shelves lined with
exquisite porcelain-ware
— crockery, flower
vases, lamps, figurines,
etc. They were made in
factories in Germany,
France, and England;
sport famous brand
names; and many date
back to 17th and 18th
centuries.
The collection grew over
decades and from many
sources. Many items were
bought from dealers and
brokers who brought the
items to him or were
purchased directly from
shops. “As an art
collector I instantly
recognised a precious
piece,” he revealed.
With this unerring eye for the perfect antique, he picked up invaluable objects including fabulous stone statues of Shiva and Parvathi from Tamil Nadu (12th century) and a magnificent 9th century Vishnu statue from Mysore. “Some objects were bought from families who wanted to sell off their artefacts. A few items were bought from old palaces.”
He pointed to ornate
gilded mirrors made in
France. “These, for
example, were bought
from Cooch Behar Palace.
The Tagore letters were
gifted to me by his
daughter-in-law Pratima
Thakur.” But Kejriwal
was wise enough to
insist that Pratima also
hand over a letter
saying they were gifted
to him by her. “Above
all, the collection grew
because I felt a love
and respect for our
heritage and a great
desire to preserve it
for posterity,” he says.
From young art students
to Nobel laureates, the
director of the British
Museum, London, and of
Asian Art Museum, San
Francisco, business
barons, legendary Indian
artistes and famous art
connoisseurs, they have
all visited this
art-rich home and left
with glowing praise,
much of it recorded in
the visitors’ books.
Our visit had us
requesting, at the end,
another walk-through at
another time. Actually,
several more, we
corrected ourselves. It
is a home whose
treasures need weeks to
explore and understand,
we said. Kejriwal, who
is as modest about his
collection as he is fond
of it, smiled: “I
understand. Even as
someone living with this
collection, I am
discovering new facets
about it everyday!”
Deccan Herald, 22nd May 2011
Maharaja Fateh
Bahadur Sahi, a
contemporary of Tipu
Sultan, waged a
guerrilla war against
the British for about 30
years to oust them. His
rebellion surpassed
almost all uprisings
before and after him.
Remembering the obscure,
but evergreen hero….
The British kept Fateh
in good humour, fearing
his disruptive
activities. The district
collector recommended
his pardon for the
murder, and he was
allowed to return home
at Huseypur.
This is a semi-wild
terrain on the UP-Bihar
border hemmed by the two
tributaries of the Ganga
— the Ghaghara and the
Gandak. Though remote
and backward, its
environment is enticing.
Kushinagar, where the
Buddha breathed his
last, is situated on its
west, and Balmiki Nagar,
the abode of Valmiki,
the author of the
Ramayana, in the east.
In between the two, one
may hear of great yogis
Gorakhnath and
Bhartharihari. Move on
and hints of history
wobble out everywhere.
To add to the romance of
the ambiance, you may
hear folklores admiring
an obscure but
conspicuous hero of the
region — Maharaja Fateh
Bahadur Sahi. Historians
do not talk of him; but
the locals remember him
for his valour and love
for freedom.
Who is
this mysterious hero?
Fateh Bahadur Sahi was
an independent ruler of
this region whose
territory spread across
the Bihar-UP border. He
belonged to the
erstwhile Huseypur
estate of the old Saran
district of Bihar, from
which descended the
later-day Tamkuhi Raj of
the Kushinagar district
of Uttar Pradesh and the
Hathwa Raj of Gapalganj
district in Bihar.
Among his successors, Kalyan Mal was an illustrious king and a contemporary of Akbar. The latter decorated him with the title of “Maharaja Bahadur”, which Jahangir reconfirmed with an additional title of “Shahi”, on the 87 {+t} {+h} raja, Kshemkaran. Kalyan Mal founded his capital at Kalyanpur (named after him) near Gopalganj, which was later on shifted to Huseypur. It was here that Fateh was born a son to Sardar Sahi, and was crowned as the 99 {+t} {+h} king in 1750 — seven years before the battle of Plassey.
Fateh Sahi's estate spread into the territories of Awadh and Bengal. So, when the East India Company gained control over these areas after the battle of Buxur in 1765, it demanded revenue from him. But he refused to oblige, challenging their legitimacy, and mobilised his supporters against them in 1767. He could be dislodged only when the British troops were sent in from Patna, after which he fled into the jungles of Gorakhpur.
Raids from the
jungle
Although dislodged from
Huseypur, Fateh Sahi
continued to obstruct
the collection of
revenue in his former
territory by launching
raids from the jungle.
In 1772, he marched into
Huseypur and killed the
Company's district
revenue farmer. Yet, the
British kept Fateh in
good humour, fearing his
disruptive activities.
The district collector
recommended his pardon
for the murder, and he
was allowed to return
home at Huseypur. He was
offered pension with a
promise to stop any
military action against
him; additionally, he
was advised to get full
autonomy within his
territory in lieu of a
payment of Rs. 25 lakh
and permission for the
circulation of British
currency in his estate.
But Sahi did not agree;
instead, he chose to be
on war forever. Two
months later, he left
home and returned to his
Gorakhpur hideout in the
Bagjogni jungle. The
British then designated
Mir Jamal as their
superintendent of the
Huseypur revenue and the
estate was farmed out to
Basant Sahi, a
pro-British cousin of
Fateh Sahi.
Taking lead from Fateh, several local chiefs challenged the British authority during 1773-74 and refused to pay taxes. Biding his time, Fateh again marched into Saran in 1775. On May 3, on intelligence about the enemy camping at Jadopur near Huseypur, he dashed through darkness with a 1000-strong cavalry to reach the enemy camp just before dawn. In the bloody skirmish that followed, he killed cousin Basant Sahi and Mir Jamal, and escaped with the booty to his forest fastness. Hundreds were left behind dead and wounded. This happened in spite of the vigil of two companies of sepoys stationed in the neighbourhood to contain him. Basant Sahi's head was cut off and sent to his widow, who committed sati along with 13 aides whose husbands too were killed in the battle. The 14 stupas containing their ashes at Huseypur are worshiped till date.
During his rebellion in August 1781, Raja Chait Singh of Banaras tried to take advantage of the anti-British uprisings in Bihar. He financed Fateh Sahi, a relation, and encouraged him to kill the British and their sepoys. A formidable alliance was forged among the rajas of Huseypur and Majhauli, and the Padrauna and Narrowneys zamindars. Several zamindars from Saran supported Sahi secretly. In October, they assembled a force of 20,000 men at Munjoora and plundered and captured the Company's military station (established to suppress Fateh) at Baragaon. Panicked and helpless, the Saran Collector Grome approached, for help, the anti-Fateh clique of the royal family headed by Dhujju Singh, a family friend and guardian of Basant's minor son. Together, they fought a bloody war with Fateh and compelled him to retreat to the jungle. His Huseypur fort was razed to ground. In reward, Dhujju was called for by Warren Hastings at Banaras and decorated with a khelat of gold cloth. The British, however, did not dare punish any of the supporters of Fateh, fearing a mass revolt against the British in the region.
Fateh did not launch
any major attack after
that, except periodic
incursions. His last
raid to Champaran
occurred in 1795. There
is little information
about his life
thereafter. According to
the Hathwa Raj
chronicle, he became an
ascetic in 1808.
Definitely, he was not
caught or killed by the
British. Had it been so,
they would surely have
trumpeted the capture of
their dreaded enemy.
Generations later
In fact, the British
were so haunted by Fateh
that his confiscated
estate of Huseypur was
conferred, by
Cornwallis, on
Chattardhari Sahi of the
pro-British branch of
the family, much later
in 1791 and the title of
“Maharaja Bahadur” not
until 1837 (there could
not be two rulers —
Fateh being the original
— of the same estate).
After the demolition of
the Huseypur fort, Fateh
had established his
capital at Tamkuhi where
the 114 th generation of
his dynasty lives today;
the descendents of
Basant Sahi moved to
Hathwa. The remnants of
the Huseypur fort are
still extant with
numerous memorial spots
in the surroundings.
Fateh Sahi was probably the first Indian ruler to revolt against the British on such a scale. He waged a guerrilla war against them for about 30 years, without any wavering in his goal to oust them. The British countered him with all their strength and resources. The hectic correspondence among the Company officials, however, vividly describes their frustration and travels, as they were unable to rein him in. They also declared a reward of Rs. 20,000 on his head, but in vain. Frustrated and distraught, they stooped to nasty tricks. Presuming that Fateh would participate in the marriage of his daughter, they surrounded the fort with the British forces and intelligence, waiting for the kill. But they could know of him only after he had left. He dressed as a pundit and walked on the traditional wooden sandals ( kharaun) well in front of the waiting soldiers!
During the hostilities, Fateh Sahi is believed to have collaborated with the king of Banaras, Mughal Emperor Shah Alam II, nawabs of Awadh and Bengal, and many chieftains and zamindars of UP and Bihar. He received wide and sustained support from the common people and his subject who paid him taxes even in exile. His war against the British may probably be considered as India's First War of Independence and he as its hero. He was a contemporary of Tipu Sultan whom the British defeated and killed brutally; but Sahi was never caught or surrendered to them. He rose against them before Tipu and almost a century before the Revolt of 1857 — India's First War of Independence. In terms of determination, and intensity and duration of aggression, Sahi's rebellion surpassed almost all uprisings before and after him. Sadly, no historian has worked on him seriously. Of late, there is a sudden surge of interest in him, however. The locals have produced tracts, novels, plays, even an epic on him.
(Help received from
Vaidurya Pratap Sahi, a
114th generation scion
of Fateh Bahadur Sahi,
his family, and Prof.
Rai Murari of Patna
University is
acknowledged
gratefully.)
The Hindu, 22nd May 2011
The famously neutral
Swiss are involved, this
time, in a
transcontinental rescue
mission to free a
forgotten people. The
works of great artists
of India are on show
till August 20 at the
Museum Rietberg, Zurich.
Why are so many early
Indian paintings so
small as to be labelled
miniatures? Would a
large canvas not free up
the artist, the way the
novel liberates the
writer to deepen plot
and characters in
greater detail? Why
would an entire colony
of authors, for
instance, opt to slave
over the short story?
The artist Purkhu — one
of our foremost
photojournalists, active
between 1780 and 1820 —
provides an answer
through a painting with
an exhaustively
explanatory title,
Maharaja Sansar Chand of
Kangra Contemplates
Paintings with his
Courtiers. The king and
his cohorts hold in
their hands
illustrations of women,
and the painter himself
stands at a corner,
clutching a striped
cover that possibly
contained the pictures
being passed around, the
way we returned from
vacations and huddled
with family and handed
out photographs before
the digital camera
transformed that warm
image into isolated
individuals ghostlit by
laptop screens at 2.00
a.m.
Closer view
This, Purkhu says, was
how paintings were once
viewed in courts – not
by standing five feet
away from a large canvas
but by sitting down and
poring over detail in a
picture clasped in the
palm. Eventually, when
paintings grew bigger, a
new set of questions
arose. How did painters,
hitherto masters of
compression, grapple
with the expanse of real
estate in front of them?
Did they anticipate the
photographic
technologies of the zoom
and the blowup and
enhance the central
object without losing
focus? Or did their
techniques evolve? The
Udaipur artist Tara
provides an answer
through a newfound
elaborateness in the
palace scenes, with
facades that protrude
and recede with
increased vigour and
perspective, and with a
fresh gaze that
incorporated the aerial
view in addition to the
frontal. In Maharana
Sarup Singh Playing
Holi, exuberant bands of
colours (leaping across
the frame like small,
single-hued rainbow
arcs) contrast with
orderly rows of
onlookers, courtly
etiquette uncompromised
by festivity.
For centuries, Indian art was dominated not by Purkhu or Tara but a painter also found in numerous volumes of poetry – that self-effacing gent who called himself Anonymous. The committed art scholar and the keen-eyed connoisseur might hold forth on Tara's experiments with European techniques or Sahibuddin's attempts to suggest movement within the frame, but these names were barely known to the man on the street, the way a Michelangelo or a Rembrandt is familiar to eyes and ears around the world. Indian artists left behind no records, no diaries; their art was their autobiography. But now, thanks to Eberhard Fischer, Jorrit Britschgi and their team from Museum Rietberg, Zürich, these artists are no longer anonymous. They have been resurrected in an exhibition that opened the weekend after Easter, the day that saw the resurrection of a different kind of creator, a carpenter.
The exhibition, titled The Way of the Master — The Great Artists of India, 1100–1900, resides in the museum's basement, and the descent from the brightly lit entrance above – home to the gift shop and the information desk and other accoutrements of the business of art in the present day – carries the impression of navigating a wormhole to a land that time forgot. Fittingly, the painting that greets the visitor is a reminder. Titled Self-Portrait and Portraits of Artists, its margins feature miniature portraits of the painter (Daulat) along with some of the best-known artists of his time – and in a swashbucklingly romantic gesture, Daulat's image has been isolated and enhanced into separate portrait. (The original painting, far smaller in size, hangs alongside in shame, a rebuke to any culture that fails to remember its creators.) The unheralded painter has been rescued, in other words, from the margins he was confined to, and he is now the subject of a breathtaking show that celebrates him and many others like him who toiled away at the margins of courts, in the margins of history.
The display spans from the book cover and folios from a Pala-period Pancharaksha manuscript — eighth to late twelfth century; these Buddhist palm-leaf manuscripts are among the earliest examples of Indian painting, and an early instance of art that was held in the hand and inspected — to the ethnographic portraits commissioned by Scottish brothers William and James Fraser, both civil servants with the British East India Company, fascinated by the infinite dimensions of a new country and its people. The numbers are so formidable — 800 years of Indian painting; 200 masterpieces; more than 40 artists — that the only sane recourse, on a given day, is to duck into a corner and dwell on its treasures. The corner I pick is devoted to the Kota Master C — an anonymous artist designated only by alphabet, like his compatriots A and B. The name of the painting reveals its contents, Rama, Lakshmana, and the Army of Monkeys and Bears Besiege Lanka, but not the bold colours in its form, an orange battleground bordered by red splashes of bloodshed.
Old records
Why are these artists
being recognised and
revered in a country so
far away from the one
they belonged to and in
whose kings they found
generous patrons? Why
isn't India the largest
lender of paintings to
this exhibition? Why,
with the exception of
the distinguished art
historian BN Goswamy,
hasn't any Indian expert
donated his time and
services? Forget not
originating in India,
why is this exhibition
not even stopping by the
country, so that its
people can finally claim
their own Renoirs and
Raphaels? These,
finally, are questions
that find no answers in
the exhibition, which
runs May 1 through
August 21, 2011, after
which it will travel to
The Metropolitan Museum
of Art, New York. A
press release boasts,
rightfully, “Never
before has it been
possible in the West to
acquaint oneself with
the entire history of
Indian painting at a
single exhibition.” They
might have added, “And
never, alas, in the
East.”
The Hindu, 22nd May 2011
Chhau dance
originated in the
Purulia district of West
Bengal and spread to the
neighbouring areas of
Patkun in Ranchi,
Saraikella in Bihar and
Mayurbhanj in Orissa.
Although the dance was
patronised by the local
rajas, it was never an
exclusive royal
‘preserve’ . In fact,
many of the performers
are drawn from the
‘economically deprived
classes’ and the dance
is enjoyed by princes
and paupers alike.
In Purulia, the land of
its origin, Chhau dances
are performed by the
people, for the people —
without the patronage of
any particular family or
individual. However, in
the other areas, with
the fall of the royal
families, the popularity
of this excellent dance
form has, to an extent,
declined.
Chhau is primarily a
mask dance, a kind of
dance-drama performed
without dialogue. The
masks used for the dance
are made of pulp and
clay by mask-makers
known as sutradhars
hailing from Charida, a
village in Purulia
district.
Like Kathakali of Kerala
and Manipuri of Assam,
Chhau dance is probably
an ancient cultural
tradition which
incorporates tribal,
folk and classical
elements. The main
characteristic of this
dance is the use of
masks denoting tribal
gods. Folk songs like
jhumur or tusu or jaoya,
and episodes from the
Ramayana, the
Mahabharata and the
puranas are an integral
part of this dance form.
This dance is performed
in the open air with the
audience sitting around
the performers in a
circle. Generally, the
performance starts at
ten in the night and
continues till the next
morning. First, each
group of musicians
enters the stage, plays
their instruments, sings
and dances. Then the
vocalists come with
folded hands and sing a
brief invocation to
Ganesha. Finally,
drummers begin to beat
their drums in a frenzy
and the dance begins
with the appearance of
Ganesha who is followed
by other dancers wearing
suitable masks.
Earlier, Chhau dances
were performed without
props. However, present
day dancers use swords,
shields, bows, arrows,
and even mechanical
devices. Colourful and
attractive, it sure is a
dance form that leaves
the audience spellbound.
Deccan Herald, 22nd May 2011
The Mandya district
administration is making
efforts to get a place
for the temple town of
Melkote in the 'World
Heritage Site' list,
which is recognised by
Unesco.
The State government
constituted the Melkote
Development Authority
two months ago for the
overall development and
conservation of the 12th
century historic town,
which houses two major
temples and nearly 20
small temples.
The Authority,
comprising 12 members
including Mandya Deputy
Commissioner Dr P C
Jaffer, held its first
meeting recently to
chalk out an action
plan. It was here that
the idea of a place for
Melkote in the 'World
Heritage Site' list was
conceptualised.
While Rs two crore was
allocated in the
previous year's budget,
the government has
announced an additional
budget of Rs 10 crore
this year, to be spent
by the Authority on
development work in the
town.
Jaffer said presently,
Rs one crore was being
spent on repair works at
the main temples -
Cheluvanarayanaswamy
temple at the foot of
the hillock and
Yoganarasimha temple
atop the hillock. Use of
plastic has already been
banned in Melkote, while
underground drainage
work has been taken up,
said Jaffer. He added
that a blueprint would
be prepared soon.
Historian Thailoor
Venkatakrishna, who is
also a member of the
Authority, said the idea
was to bring back the
natural beauty of
Melkote, for which a
afforestation project
has been undertaken.
"Saint Ramanujacharya
named the main temple
Cheluvanarayanaswamy
Devalaya, because of the
surrounding natural
beauty of Melkote. The
Authority wants to
recreate this
environment. Efforts are
on to ensure that any
new house that comes up
is in sync with the
existing structures, so
that the heritage status
is maintained," said
Venkatakrishna.
The historian said it
was also important to
protect the rocks in the
town, some of which have
line drawings belonging
to ancient times.
Archaeologists have even
unearthed pots and pans
which are said to be
3,000 years old.
Venkatakrishna said
Melkote's cultural and
traditional practices,
which have a heritage
status, were also in
need of revival. Melkote
has around 76 'mantapas'
and 29 'kalyanis'
(tanks). The district
administration has begun
work on desilting these
man-made ponds or tanks.
Deputy Conservator of
Forests of Mandya, Vinay
Kumar, said the forest
department was in the
process of creating
various 'daivavanas'
which will go by the
names like
'Dharmikavana',
'Smrithivana',
'Navagrahavana' and
'Saptarishivana'.
Re-plantation would be
taken up on about 200
hectares in and around
Melkote, where the
department had
identified over 200 rare
and endangered floral
species, some of which
date back to the
pre-historic times.
He said that the naked
seed plants called Cycas
Circinalis, endangered
species like Gardenia
Gummifera and the
commonly used medicinal
plant Boswellia Sarreta
were being destroyed by
constant grazing and
human interference. The
department will engage
in natural regeneration
by sowing seeds of these
plants, at the same time
trying to protect the
soil moisture of the
region.
Deccan Herald, 22nd May 2011
As we zipped down
from Chennai to
Puducherry on the super,
high-tech East Coast
Road, we passed by a
mélange of eclectic
tourist attractions like
Artists’ Village, the
Crocodile Bank,
Dakshinachitra, the
world renowned 'Pallava'
temples of
Mahabalipuram, and the
Tamil Nadu Tourism
Development
Corporation's Boating
Centres at the
backwaters of Muttukkadu
and Mudaliar Kuppam.
The surf breaking on
endless coastline,
interspersed with
stretches of casuarinas
groves, was a welcome
relief from the
amusement park and food
courts along the road.
Just 50 km before
Puducherry, a green
signboard beckoned us to
the unobtrusive fishing
hamlet of Kadapakkam.
From the main road, we
took a 3 km detour and
stumbled upon Alambara
Fort, an unknown
treasure bequeathed by
the Mughals along the
Coromandel Coast.
As we reached the
portals of the fort, an
eerie silence greeted us
for there was not a soul
in sight. Images and
sounds of gunshots,
artillery and soldiers
of a bygone era flashed
across our minds,
filling us with a sense
of fear and wonder. The
splash of the sea added
to the mystery and awe
of the crumbling
edifice. Overlooking the
breathtaking backdrop of
the sea and the
backwaters of many
beaches that run through
Mahabalipuram, the ruins
of the brick and lime
mortar fort are splendid
to behold, with their
earthy colour. The
intricate steps and
watch-towers conjured
visions of intriguing
battles fought for the
supremacy of trade.
The place resonates with
history and abounds in
several scattered ruins
of the imposing
historical monuments
that transport one to
the glorious past, to a
time when Alambara was a
busy outpost for the
Arcot Nawabs, before
they shifted their
operations to
Puducherry. It was an
important trading centre
on the Coromandel Coast
for the spice trade,
enticing enterprising
voyagers, seafarers, and
traders from the world.
It also finds a mention
in Tamil literary works.
We could visualise how
the waterfront would
have been. During 1760,
the English had
destroyed the
100-metre-long dockyard
in front of the fort,
where silk, salt, ghee
and condiments were
exported.
An Archeological Survey
of India (ASI) board
mentions that the
Alambara Fort was built
by the Mughals in the
18th century and served
as a port in ancient
Tamil Nadu. The Nawab of
Carnatic, Dost Ali Khan,
had commissioned its
construction. The
Mughals subsequently
bequeathed the fort to
the French, who were
under the commandership
of Dupleix, the Governor
General of the French
establishment in India
during the 18th century.
In 1760, the British
destroyed a major
portion of the fort. The
tsunami of 2004 further
ravaged the fort. Now, a
few cannons still
survive.
As I clambered the
intricate steps leading
to the watchtower of the
fort, I thought of how
majestic it appeared,
with its red bricks and
limestone coating,
typical aspects of
Mughal architecture. The
view from the top of the
watchtower was stunning.
We could see the
backwaters, fishing
boats, palm trees, and
other little beaches in
the distance, on our
left. The remnants of
the fort looked like
laterite cliffs with
deep fissures in some,
protruding into the sea.
Gnarled trunks and roots
of trees clung to the
fort’s crumbling walls.
The vast expanse
encircling the fort was
beguiling and
spectacular. This
picturesque place is
also a popular filming
location. We hopped onto
a fishing boat and the
boatman ferried us to a
shallow stretch of water
where we tried our hand
at some net fishing.
Soon, we approached a
small stretch of sand in
the middle of the
waters. The men docked
the boat on its shores.
At low tide, one can
dally in knee-deep
waters for hours on end
and wade across to this
stretch of land. We
returned after spending
blissful hours watching
the waves playing
hide-and-seek with the
shore. I was tempted to
run along the glistening
white beach, which is
uncontaminated by
madding crowds. There
are no shops or vendors
to hassle us and the
absolute solitude it
guarantees is the
beach’s main charm.
We watched the fishermen
heading out on their
boats and turning into
tiny silhouettes on the
horizon, their nets
flying over the water.
On the way back, we
stopped by the fish
market to buy some
prawns and crabs which
are sold very cheap.
The nearest airport and
railway station are at
Chennai to reach
Alambara Fort. But the
best bet is by road, 100
km from Chennai, and 50
km from Pudducherry,
near Kadapakkam. One can
take the East Coast Road
from Chennai after
driving past
Mahabalipuram and look
for a small green sign
for ‘Kadapakkam’ on the
left. From Kadapakkam,
take a narrow road to
the left and keep going
straight till you reach
the Alambara Fort.
Deccan Herald, 22nd May 2011
Shahjahanabad Redevelopment Corporation Ltd has become the latest heritage body to help in conservation of ancient structures by deciding to hold heritage walks in the archaeologically rich zones in nine districts, including old Delhi, Mehrauli and Lodi Gardens.
One such walk was held on Saturday under the guidance of heritage consultant Dr Navina Jafa, who took visitors on a two-hour tour to explore the rich heritage of the Mehrauli Archaeological Park.
Saturday's participation was not too large because of the bad weather but some poeple turned up. The walk started at Mehrauli's flower market and then went through several historical sites like Jamali-Kamali, Balban's Tomb, Rajon ki baoli, the tomb summer house of British resident Metcalfe etc. Throughout, Dr Jafa was explaining the significance of these sites and what they represent.
The enthralled visitors had a gala time learning more about the historical sites and the rich archaeology of the park. "I've come here after 10 to 15 years and then this place was just like a jhuggi settlement. I would not have guessed there were so many important historical monuments in the park," said entrepreneur Priya Paul, one of the participants.
The walk was advertised through emails, word of mouth and social networking sites. "The Mehrauli landscape in Delhi is one of the oldest lived area of the city. Spectacular monuments and buildings index and catalogue the lived history of different communities in different times. As one of the oldest lived areas of Delhi, the space reverberates with the presence of Sufis to opulent decadent English officers, from Lodis to Mughals, from rich contemporary citizens to slum-dwellers," said an official.
According to Jafa, the way to involve people more in heritage conservation and get them to participate more in walks is all about presentation. "You have to know how to captivate the audience and understand their perspective on what would interest them in the walks. Although SRDC is relatively a new organization, we are working towards making more and more people involved in this campaign. We recently trained 165 school teachers from 200 schools to involve children more in spreading awareness."
He added: "Our second
walk will now be with
the locals and residents
of Mehrauli. We will
bring them to the
Mehrauli Archaeological
Park and tell them about
the rich history of the
place."
Times of India,
22nd May 2011
Violations
An agreement which vaguely indicates location and does not mention the size and details of land can be at best describe as a ‘bogus document’, indicating a deep conspiracy to give away the state’s precious assets. With such a benevolent government in place there is no need to enter ‘benami’ land deals
- Revenue Official The allotment of forest land to private parties for the 10 eco-tourism projects in violation of the Forest Conservation Act and state’s own policy is turning out to be a major scam with startling ambiguities and shortcomings in the “Memorandum of Agreement” in which even the total allotted area, leave aside the details of land as per the revenue records, has not been specified.
With no mention of land details in the agreement the private parties have occupied huge forest areas and built big structures, opened restaurants, bars and spa in blatant violation of the state eco-tourism policy.
Revenue officials maintain, “An agreement which vaguely indicates location and does not mention the size and details of land can be at best described as a ‘bogus document’, indicating a deep conspiracy to give away the state’s precious assets. With such a benevolent government in place there is no need to enter ‘benami’ land deals.”
In the “Expression of Interest” an area of approximately one hectare was mentioned, but at the Shoghi location, close to the national highway, the promoter had occupied over 2.5 hectare. Enquiries by The Tribune reveal that the land had been allotted for a meagre Rs 1.22 lakh per annum. In fact, the annual amount for the 10 projects varies from Rs 80,000 to Rs 1.25 lakh per annum, which is peanuts when compared to the Potter Hill project, allotted earlier, which is fetching over Rs 16 lakh. Even in the remote village of Kareri in Kangra, visited only by nomadic shepherds and trekkers, the local eco-society is earning annual revenue of Rs 48,000. Intriguingly, no reserve price for awarding the projects was fixed. One party from Nagpur bagged six out of the 10 projects.
There is an uncanny similarity in the pattern allotment of eco-tourism projects and private universities, most of which have come up in Solan district. Five out of the 10 eco-tourism locations are between Shoghi and Kasuali, close to the national highway, where the value of land is quite high. A 25,000 sq m piece of land for developing a tourist resort will cost several crores of rupees.
This is entirely against the eco-tourism policy which provides for constitution of eco-tourism societies under the divisional forest officers to promote environment-friendly activities like trekking, nature walks and mountaineering by involving the local community in the interior areas of the state where no tourism infrastructure is available. There is no mention of activities like bars, spa and restaurants and the arrangement for the stay of tourists has to be made in tents and other temporary structures. Further, the Kasauli-Shimla belt which already has hundreds of hotels, does not qualify for eco-tourism projects the objective of which is to open the unexplored inner areas to tourism without harming the environment.
In the case of Kangra
Forest Rest House site,
the allottee has raised
ugly structures in
violation of policy,
whereas at the Ala site
in Dalhousie the old
inspection hut has been
transformed into a
restaurant.
The Tribune, 23rd
May 2011
Controversy has flared
up in the Ranthambore
Tiger Reserve in
Rajasthan over canal
construction dividing
the National Park and
Sawai Mansingh
Sanctuary. The
construction work
permitted by the State
Government despite the
rejection by the
National Board for
Wildlife (NBWL) has now
been temporarily put on
hold following the
intervention of Chief
Secretary under pressure
of the green lobby. The
NBWL had twice rejected
the State Government’s
proposal to allow
construction on the
site.
This has, however, put
the villagers on war
path in the
water-starved State. The
villagers are agitating
for the resumption of
the work. State Chief
Wildlife warden UM Sahai
said, “The situation is
under control and the
district administration
is trying to pacify the
villagers”. “We have
held meeting with the
water resources
department to discuss
the issue,” he added.
But that has not
pacified some members of
the NBWL and wildlife
experts. “In what
circumstances was
construction allowed in
the first place despite
the fact that the
standing committee of
National Board for
Wildlife rejected the
proposal twice during
2005-06 after site
inspection?” They
wonder.
Construction had been on
April 19 after the
foundation laying stone
ceremony by the local MP
Namo Narayan Meena, who
is also Minister of
State for Finance.
Expressing concern over
the development, eminent
tiger conservationist PK
Sen based on his site
visit said, “Hills on
both sides form a vital
corridor for movement of
wild animals — with the
construction of this
canal entire 3-km long
vital corridor will be
completely lost”.
Further, when the
present standing
committee has not given
clearance, it is gross
violation of Wildlife
Protection Act and
Forest Conservation Act,
he pointed out.
The land requirement for
the proposed structure
is two hectares. It is
approximately 3 km long
10-12 meters in width
and depth varying from 5
feet-20 feet. The NBWL
members alleged that the
State Government had
managed to get sanction
from the MoEF by wrongly
referring it under the
provisions of Forest
Conservation Act, when
the area is bordering
the tiger reserve and
sanctuary. “The sanction
of NBWL was absolutely
necessary”, they pointed
out.
A senior State forest
official on the
condition of anonymity
pointed out much hue and
cry is being raised over
the issue. It is not
even a canal but nallah
for diversion of rain
water. “We had got
sanction from the
Regional office of the
MoEF in 2008 itself.
Almost 25-27 villages
are expected to
benefit,” he added.
Member Secretary
National Tiger
Conservation Authority
(NTCA) Dr Rajesh Gopal
refused to comment on
the issue.
According to
conservation biologist
Dharmendra Khandal
working in the area,
“The approval was
granted by twisting the
proposal and getting it
cleared under Forest
Appraisal Committee
(FAC) when it was
mandatory to bring it
before the standing
committee of NBWL.
:How the forest
officials have given a
go-ahead for this
project without
consulting the legal
provisions and the
National Tiger
Conservation Authority
happens to be a million
dollar question,” he
asks.
A member of NBWL on the
condition of anonymity
said, Ranthambhore
National Park and Sawai
Mansingh Sanctuary are
crossed by large number
of herbivores animals in
all the seasons. Going
by the depth of the
canal, no animal will be
able to cross the
structure which may
cause more deaths.
“Further, it is reported
that a tiger (T-30) has
made its home range in
Sawai Mansingh
Sanctuary,” the member
said.
The Pioneer, 23rd May 2011
The stone alignment at Vibhutihalli in Yadgir district was used to track annual events like solstices and equinoxes. Meera Iyer visits the site and marvels at the ingenuity of our ancestors.
As you drive down the highway from Shahpur towards Bangalore, about half a kilometre past a town called Vibhutihalli in Yadgir district, you will notice the arid brown landscape suddenly broken by a patch of green. A small and unusual grove of tamarind trees stands here. Unusual because interspersed amongst the trees are row upon row of stones, each a metre or more high. Some are right under the trees, others stand in neat lines between rows of trees. This stone grid, now hidden under the trees, once served as a calendar for the ancients.
The modern history of the Vibhutihalli stone alignment dates back to the 1850s when Capt Meadows Taylor, an administrator with the Nizam’s government, discovered this ‘curious spot’. He describes how the ground has been marked out in parallel or diagonal lines to form squares, the points of the squares being formed of large granite boulders. He presumes these boulders were rolled down from the neighbouring hills, but, “at what expense of labour, and with what patience!” Taylor speculated that the stone grid was eventually meant to hold cairns and burials, an idea strengthened by his finding of some cairns within the alignment.
But we owe our understanding of the site to N Kameswara Rao, who recently retired from the Indian Institute of Astrophysics. In between publishing cutting-edge research on stellar spectra and buckyballs in space, Rao has also devoted much time to studying astronomy in ancient India.
Rao and his colleagues who investigated this stone alignment believe that Vibhutihalli’s rows of stones were used to track annual events such as solstices and equinoxes. Rao explains how if you stand facing east at dawn around an equinox, either March 21 or September 22, you will find that the rows of stones running east-west point directly to where the sun rises. You can also find positions in the alignment from where you can look along diagonal stones to predict where the sun will rise and set during the summer solstice. A point I found most interesting: during the equinox, the sun sets exactly in the dip between two hillocks that stand just across the road.
Carefully planned site
This implies that the people who set up Vibhutihalli’s alignment chose the site very carefully indeed. Rao agrees: “An enormous amount of planning and previous experience was needed to establish this site.” He believes that this was probably not the first attempt at establishing a site to monitor annual events. Corroborating this view is the fact that other alignment sites have been found in the region around north Karnataka and parts of Andhra Pradesh, many of them much smaller than Vibhutihalli. Presumably, some of these were pilot projects.
But what was the purpose of monitoring events such as solstices and equinoxes? “Tracking something that repeats, like seasons, was the basis of ancient civilisations. Survival often depended on being able to predict when the seasons would change…and it all came from keeping an eye on the sky,” explains Rao. Harvesting, sowing, hunting, moving to better pastures, moving for shelter – much of ancient humans’ lifecycles was closely tied to the changing seasons.
As he spoke, I recalled long-forgotten lessons from my school geography and biology classes. On the vernal equinox in March, day and night are about equal. Days get longer till the summer solstice in June when we have the longest day. Day length decreases once again till day and night are equal during the September equinox and then decreases some more till the winter solstice in December, when we have the shortest day. And day length matters a lot to many plants. Panicles in some varieties of sorghum, for example, form on or around the autumn equinox in September. Barley plants produce leaves at different rates depending on whether it is before or after an equinox. Clearly, the ancients had an eye on the sky but also one on the ground to observe how these changes were inter-related.
Other markers on the horizon
There are other markers on Vibhutihalli’s horizon that probably contributed to the site. Just south of the alignment site is a hillock with two distinctive pillar-shaped rocks. Stand facing these and you will find that the north-south rows of stones line up perfectly with the taller of the pillar rocks. Rao thinks it is probable that this rock was used to help line up some of the stone rows.
Perhaps there are other markers on the horizon that would help mark and monitor calendric events here. Investigating this would require a clear view of the horizon.
Unfortunately, at Vibhutihalli, the horizon can scarcely be seen because of the trees that were planted here by the Forest Department sometime in the 1970s. I couldn’t help but wonder why they chose this particular spot for afforestation. Some of the stones seem to have been moved during the planting while others have been slightly dislodged by the trees growing next to them.
‘This is how it has always been’
The ancient site is now under the aegis of the Archaeological Survey of India, which recently put up a fence around the alignment. But a Forest Department nursery continues to function inside. I chatted with some of the workers there, asking them if they knew anything about the stone grid. “We have no idea,” was the response, a view echoed by a farmer, Hanumanthappa, who added, “I just know that this is how it has always been, even in my father’s times.”
Of course, the Vibhutihalli stone alignment has been around for much longer than Hanumanthappa’s father’s times. Rao thinks it might have been established 3,400 to 3,800 years ago, during the time when our ancestors began depending more on agriculture and less on foraging for food.
As I stood looking
along the rows of
stones, I wondered how
people would have gone
about planning for this
calendar in stone so
many thousands of years
ago. How did they
organise the labour for
establishing the
alignment with such
great care and with such
staggering effort? How
long did it take them?
And who ‘read’ the
calendars? There are no
inscriptions to guide us
here but perhaps
archaeologists will one
day uncover the secrets
of the stones. Till
then, I can only marvel
at the ingenuity of our
ancestors.
Deccan Herald, 24th May 2011
The United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (Unesco) recently shortlisted the Western Ghats for inclusion in the World Heritage list, taking this biodiversity rich area a step closer to protection from landuse change and other developmental activities.
The 39
serial sites in the
Unesco shortlist include
four sites in
Maharashtra
(Sahyadri)—Kas Plateau,
Koyna wildlife
sanctuary, Chandoli
national park and
Radhanagari wildlife
sanctuary. All the sites
are rich in biodiversity
and need conservation.
The 39 serial sites are
spread across
Maharashtra, Karnataka,
Kerala and TN. Jagdish
Krishnaswamy, senior
fellow, Ashoka Trust for
Research in Ecology and
Environment, and member
of the Western Ghats
natural heritage
management committee
constituted by the
ministry of environment,
told TOI the
shortlisting takes these
39 sites a step closer
to their inscription in
the World Heritage list.
Times of India,
24th May 2011
The State is full of historical monuments, beautiful lakes, hills, jungles and beaches. The district of Kolar is no exception, even though it became smaller after the creation of Chikkaballapur district on the northern part. Kolar is a sleepy town, famous for the Sahasrashringi range of hills.
The Avani hill is about 30 km from the town on Kolar-Mulbagal route and is famous for its temples.
The main attraction of Avani is the ancient Ramalingeswara temple, built by the Cholas in the 11th century and subsequently renovated by later-day rulers. In the 16th century, it was renovated by the Vijayanagara rulers. The principal deity is that of Goddess Kamakshi. It is accompanied by a Shiva linga known as Ramalingeswara. The beautiful mantapas are added attractions of the temple. The other shrines are Lakshmaneswara, Bharateswara, Shatrughneswara, Hanumantheswara, Ganesha and Subrahmanya. There is a temple dedicated to Lord Jambubana, who was a devotee of Lord Rama. The images of ashtadikpalas (eight sentries) and saptamatrikas (seven mothers) along with Uma maheswara can be seen on the walls and the ceiling of the temple.
The 500-year-old Sharada Math was built as a branch of the famed Sringeri Sharada Peetha, established by Adi Shankara in Sringeri. The hill is a major draw for tourists. After reaching the mid-point of the hill, I saw the flat surface, smaller shrines, a beautiful mantapa and a small water body full of crystal clear water. Many trees surround those structures. The mantapas were probably built by the royalty as a place for relaxation during their tours and pilgrimages. The inscriptions on the stones narrate the history of the place, but authorities should pay serious thought to preserve these records before they are destroyed by forces of nature. Some of the inscriptions were damaged owing to quarrying undertaken in the region. The Ekantha Ramaswamy temple and the Pancha Pandava temple are also located in the vicinity. According to mythology, Pandavas visited these parts during their exile and worshipped Lord Shiva here. Mythology has it that the great epic poet Valmiki also stayed here and offered shelter to Sita in a cave and that her twins Lava and Kusha were born here. The hill here is called Valmiki parvatha. There is a Parvathi temple atop the hill. There are beautiful rock formations and depressions in the area. The myth is that these depressions were caused by the vessels used by Sita for cooking. One giant rock is called the Thottilu Gundu which is close to the Ekantha Rama temple. Other rocks here go by the names of Kuduregundu and Horalu gundu. Avani can be a major tourist destination, but the Tourism Department and the Archaeological Departments should work together to preserve the monuments and post security personnel at the place.
How to get there
Avani hill is about 95 km from Bangalore and 30 km from Kolar town. Lots of buses are available from Bangalore to Kolar and Mulbagal. The place is just 10 km before Mulbagal.
Accommodation is
available only in Kolar.
Mulbagal, which is
nearby, is famous for
its Anjaneya temple and
Narasimha tirtha.
Kurudamale, famous for
the Ganesha temple, is
also close to Avani.
Deccan Herald, 24th May 2011
In its 10 years of existence, Wikipedia, the global online encyclopedia, has amassed an archive of 18 million entries in 279 languages. It is one of the 10 most popular Web sites on the Internet.
But is the volunteer-driven data depository an endangered world cultural treasure worthy of protection, like French cuisine, the Argentine tango or the Grand Canyon?
That is the long-shot bet being made by Wikipedia, which plans to begin a global petition drive Tuesday to earn a spot on one of the world heritage lists of the U.N. Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation.
The bid, the first by a digital entity for a place on a Unesco list, will no doubt be controversial among heritage professionals advising Unesco, who tend to view online innovation as lacking the necessary effect or maturity for listing.
“Heritage professionals tend to be rather conservative types, or they wouldn’t choose this kind of occupation,” said Britta Rudolff, a heritage consultant who teaches on the subject at the Brandenburg University of Technology in Cottbus, Germany. “They like to play with the past, and something only a decade old is going to face challenges.”
The idea of landing Wikipedia on a Unesco world heritage list came out of Germany, where volunteers have produced 1.2 million entries, second only to the number in English. Wikipedia’s German overseer, a Berlin nonprofit called Wikimedia, proposed the idea in March to Wikipedia chapters at a global conference in the German capital.
The reception was enthusiastic, said a Wikipedia co-founder, Jimmy Wales.
“The basic idea is to recognise that Wikipedia is this amazing global cultural phenomena that has transformed the lives of hundreds of thousands of people,” Wales said in an interview. He said the online encyclopedia had helped educate people around the world, providing a wealth of basic facts, background information and key context.
“I think Wikipedia is playing a significant role in spreading information in Iranian society at the moment,” said one Iranian college student in Germany, who is a regular contributor to Wikipedia’s Farsi content, which includes 128,000 entries. The student, who did not want to be identified for fear of government reprisal against his family, said that about 100 students accounted for the bulk of Wikipedia Farsi entries.
Similarly, in South Africa, Wikipedia is playing a role in providing free information and learning materials in schools, many of which lack the money to buy books and maintain libraries, said Charlene Foster, an organiser of Wikipedia South Africa. The group in March began generating entries in Afrikaans and Northern Sotho and will do so eventually in the country’s nine other official languages.
“South Africa and the African continent has been marginalised in terms of information and cultural value,” Foster said. “But Wikipedia is helping us with access to information for education not found in libraries.”
On a practical level, Wikipedia will have to do more than just gather signatures on a petition. Under Unesco rules, Wikipedia must find a country to sponsor its nomination to either the World Heritage or Intangible Cultural Heritage List. In the interview, Wales said he hoped that Germany would sponsor Wikipedia’s bid for the World Heritage list.
Getting nominated for the Intangible Cultural Heritage list will be more difficult. The United States and Germany are not signatories to the 2003 convention that created this list and cannot act as sponsors. But South Africa did sign on, and Foster, who lives in Johannesburg, said she was in the early stages of asking officials in the government to discuss the country’s making a bid on behalf of Wikipedia for one of the lists.
Even if Wikipedia’s South African supporters can persuade their government to nominate Wikipedia, getting selected is by no means guaranteed. Winners are selected by an intergovernmental committee of 24 countries. For the intangible heritage list, those members include Iran and Cuba.
Wikipedia is hoping to earn a place on Unesco’s most prestigious list, the World Heritage List, which so far includes only historic monuments and natural sites like the Great Barrier Reef and the Great Wall of China. Failing that, Wikipedia could aim for Unesco’s Intangible Cultural Heritage List, a lesser-known directory that includes endangered traditions and practices, like flamenco.
Getting Wikipedia on either list will be an uphill battle. It will have to negotiate a complicated approval process and overcome the skeptical regard of Unesco and heritage consultants to be considered for recognition. Susan Williams, the head of external media relations at Unesco in Paris, said a bid by a digital entity like Wikipedia would be unprecedented.
“Anyone can apply,” said Williams, who added that she was not aware of Wikipedia’s plans. “But it may have difficulty fulfilling the criteria.” One of the criteria for inclusion, she said, is that the culture or practice be endangered.
She said that
Wikipedia might consider
applying for a third,
even less known honor,
the Unesco Memory of the
World Register list,
which recognizes
valuable archive
holdings and library
collections. That list,
however, lacks the
prestige of the others,
which are funded more
generously and promoted
more assiduously by
Unesco and its member
countries.
Deccan Herald, 25th May 2011
A growing glacial lake
near Mt Everest is again
ringing the alarm bells
on melting ice in the
high Himalayas that
potentially threatens
the water resources of
several countries,
including India.
The Imja glacier, close
to the Mt Everest base
camp in the Hindu Kush
Himalayas, is a hot
discussion subject among
glaciologists. While
satellite images confirm
many glaciers in the
region are retreating,
Imja's story is
particularly
interesting.
In the archival photos of the 1950s, there was no lake, but recent photographs show a large glacial lake that's increasing in size every year. Trekking maps of the '50s too don't show the Imja glacial lake at all.
These could be a sign of accelerated glacier retreat due to rising global temperatures, experts warn, adding that glacier thinning and retreat in the Himalayas has resulted in formation of new lakes and enlargement of existing ones due to accumulation of melt water behind loosely consolidated moraine dams.
The Imja glacier,
which falls on a popular
trekking route, had
nothing but a few melt
ponds some decades ago.
By 1984, the ponds had
transformed into a lake
of approximately 0.4sq
km. Photographs of Imja
glacier were obtained on
special flight missions
for production of the
1988 map of Mount
Everest region sponsored
by the National
Geographic Society.
Times of India, 26th May 2011
Sitting in Karnataka’s most beautiful buildings, and running your hands through the cursive writings of Mark Cubbon, while being comfortably enveloped by endless arrays of mildewed literature and soothed by the rhythmic drumming of the summer rain – it’s easy to get lost to the world.
This is a luxury that research scholars from across the world get to experience in a small area carved out for them in the basement of the imposing Vidhana Soudha, where historic records dating back to 1799 are being preserved and maintained by the Archives section of the Department of Kannada and Culture
Renovation
The department has
now embarked upon a
project to modernise
this area, which is
expected to be completed
in three to six months.
The PWD, which has been entrusted with the renovation work, has begun its job, according to Kanchivaradaiah, Director of the State Archives. The project will cost Rs 17 lakh.
The section has over three lakh records and documents of historic importance. As a good number of researchers make use of the available records, seating area is being spruced up, the director said.
Lamination
Around 60 research
scholars have spent
precious hours in this
section in the last
three years, to research
on subjects including –
political development of
education in Karnataka;
works pertaining to Sir
M Visvesvaraya;
colonisation of Mysore;
Role of Women in
Panchayat Raj System,
etc.
A large number of documents and records are getting laminated. In the present year, Rs 25 lakh was spent to laminate 1,788 records.
The work of
de-acidifying the
yellowing and musty
pages, and laminating
them using German tissue
has been outsourced to a
private company in
Thiruvallur in Chennai.
The firm charges Rs 32
to laminate a page.
Deccan Herald, 26th May 2011
The directorate of archaeology, Assam collected 9 pieces of stone architectural relics from Dhirenpara of Fatasil Ambari area today which were first noticed by Mintu Ali, a local youth of the area, a press release said.
Out of these nine pieces, two were recovered by the officials of the Directorate ofArchaeology from the residence of Mohammad Ali, a resident of Dhirenpara.
Dr HN Dutta, director of the directorate of Archaeology, Assam immediately
rushed to the spot aongwith Ranjana Sarma, Director (Exploration & Excavation
Branch), Chabina Hasan, Exploration officer of the directorate, Nilkamal Singh,
a research scholar and taking into consideration the entire situation, the
directorate of Archaeology took all the necessary steps and finally today at
9.00 am collected the stone architectural relics, along with the help of the
local people Mintu Ali, Imtiaz Ali, Arjun Das, Suman Dey and Nipen Chakraborty
under the guidance of the officials of the Directorate of Archaeology, Assam.
The Assam Tribune, 26th May 2011
A colourful tiny migratory bird has thrilled bird watchers as it has wandered over the Bangalore horizon for the first time.
The European Roller (Coracias garrulus), is a regular migrator to some parts of the State every year.
However as a first record, it has now been sighted by three bird watchers, Vinay K, P Manjunath and Clement Francis.
The bird, sighted near Dasanapura enroute to Nelamangala, is a first sighting in the City and has thrilled the bird watchers.
“As per my knowledge, this is the first sighting of this bird. It is indeed a surprise,” said Dr M B Krishna, well-known ornithologist in the City.
The stocky bird, the size of a pigeon measures between 29–32 cm in length with a 52–58 cm wingspan.
It is mainly blue with an orange-brown back and perch prominently on trees, posts or overhead wires, like giant shrikes, watching for the large insects, small reptiles, rodents and frogs that they eat.
This species is striking in its strong direct flight, with the brilliant blue contrasting with black flight feathers. The call is a harsh crow-like sound. It gives a raucous series of calls when nervous.
“European Roller is a long time migrator and arrives by the end of summer in India,” said Manjunath, Secretary, Green Cross.
Endangered
“The population breeds in Europe, spends winter in Africa and comes to India
through middle east. It enters India through Gujarat, Kutch and Rajasthan,” he
added.
Clement Francis, bird expert and well-known photographer says that since 2004, the bird has been classified as ‘near threatened’ and now listed as ‘critically endangered.’
“Due to over hunting in Oman and other Gulf countries, their population has dwindled. Also due to the extensive use of pesticides since the 1990s in farming areas all along their migratory path, the insect population they prey upon, especially the locusts and grasshopper, has reduced in number,” he explained.
The birds, with a population of almost a million breeding pairs 20 years ago, have now reduced to 50,000- 75,000 breeding pairs in Europe, adds Francis. Clement said that he had sighted this bird in Ranebennur in Haveri district and places like Tilakwadi on the outskirts of Belgaum, a few years ago.
Similarity
A common man who sees this might confuse it with Blue Jay, which is the
State bird (Nilakanta in Kannada).
However Clement and Manjunath, explaining the difference, say that Blue Jay
or Indian Roller has lilac colour marking on its face, while the European Roller
has a blue head.
It has no marking on the head and possesses chestnut colouration on wing and
back.
In addition to this, the Indian Roller has bluish, lighter and darker blue
wing colour combination.
Deccan Herald, 28th May 2011
Culture minister Kumari Selja has directed the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) to launch a massive public awareness campaign and sensitize the citizens to the provisions of the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains, Amendment and Validation (AMASRA) Act.
Addressing the 35th meeting of the Central Advisory Board of Archaeology, she said, "We need to co-opt the willingness of every citizen so that the enactment is appreciated by them in the larger context and not perceived as a threat or impediment to their existence." The minister said that in the amended form the Act would be a useful tool in the preservation of monuments and heritage.
"The amended Act also provides for considering the requests of the public to
allow repairs in prohibited areas. The Act also says competent authorities will
draft monument-specific heritage by-laws," she said.
Times of India, 28th May 2011
The Academy of Sanskrit Research, in Melkote, Karnataka, houses ancient manuscripts, which are slowly being digitised
We arrive at the library block, half-expecting to be assailed by the dust of centuries. Instead, a faint citrus smell leads us, growing heavy with each step, into a room stacked to the ceiling with dirt-brown palm-leaf manuscripts. With its green metal shelves and lack of air-conditioning, this room at the Academy of Sanskrit Research, perched on a serene hill in Melkote, a temple town three hours by road from Bangalore, is a fount of ancient knowledge. And Bitte Gowda, a small, old man with a ready smile, has helped preserve it since 1978.
Dipping a brush in a bowl of citronella oil, a natural insect repellant that also helps keep palm leaves from crumbling, Gowda paints over each folio of a thick, wood-bound bundle that lies untied on his desk. “On an average, I cover 10 bundles a day,” he says. The oil is potent enough to give one a headache, but it has done worse. It cost a lady here her right eye, Gowda says.
“There are over 9,900 works in 5,000-plus bundles in this room. Some of the manuscripts date back 400 years and the works go back to the 6th-8th century BC. Our focus is not so much on laukika sahitya (literature for the common man) as on shastras (scriptures),” says S Kumara, the registrar. Like most residents of this town untouched by time — there are no avenues of modern entertainment here, no hotels, and only a small “mess” or two to lunch at — Kumara speaks in chaste, Brahminical Tamil and wears a vertical red line on his forehead, a sign of allegiance to Vaishnavism or Vishishtadvaita, the non-dualistic school of Vedanta philosophy founded by Ramanuja, who is said to have been exiled by a Chola king to Melkote for over a decade. “This town has always been a centre for traditional knowledge and culture. We are trying to set up a Sanskrit university here, but the authorities haven’t blessed us with their approval yet,” Kumara says.
The Academy, established by the government in 1976 to promote Sanskrit scholarship and the study of Vishishtadvaita, gets about Rs 1 crore in funding every year and is in the midst of a digitisation drive, initiated under the National Manuscript Mission in 2003. Progress has been slow, however, with only 25 per cent of the manuscripts scanned till date. Hanumantha Rao, the manuscriptologist who has helped scan and copy to CDs over 15,000 palm leaf folios, explains why. “A work is digitised only after it is published (the Academy has its own printing press), due to concerns that others might try to take credit for the work we have put in,” he says.
It is not easy to make sense of a manuscript, so publications often have long gestation periods, reasons RK Narayan, one of only two scholars at the Academy who speak English. “Often, a bundle of palm leaves will contain several works, but nowhere will it say sampurnam (the end). One has to infer from the change in meter and line continuity where one work or chapter ends and the next begins. Also, classical Sanskrit texts are famous for their slesha — that is, every subsequent reading brings out meanings that weren’t obvious in the previous reading,” he says. Once a text is copied out in full and linguistically analysed, scholars must compare it with editions of the work available in other libraries, and determine if there are important variations worthy of publication.
In an adjacent room, which houses 30,000 printed books on the Vedas, shastras, Ayurveda, astronomy, astrology and other subjects, librarian Chandrashekhar says 2,000 of them have been digitised and made available online as part of the Digital Library of India project. “We were doing well till six months ago, when the two mega-scanners donated by the Indian Institute of Science stopped working. It will cost Rs 12 lakh to buy a scanner now. The alternative is to bring new sensors from Singapore. We can afford neither,” he says.
In the musty library, the unlikely home of rare books from the early 1900s, the scanners — big, white and reminiscent of a hospital — look oddly anachronistic, as do Chandrashekhar’s Western clothes. Everyone else, including the 13 scholars who research and publish commentaries on various works, is dressed in pristine white veshtis. Even Selvanarayan, a young electrical engineer who designs software aids for teaching Sanskrit. With an MA in Sanskrit and Kannada, he has been writing code in Visual Basic for the past 10 years and has developed dozens of programs, which he plans to integrate into a basic five-year course for students of Sanskrit. Demonstrating one of them, called the Sandhi Engine, he says it works on Panini’s grammatical rules on the joining of words. Input two word — say deva (god) and aalaya (home) — and it spits out the result: devalaya (temple). “I was born in Melkote and though I studied in Bangalore, I wanted to return and contribute to the Sanskrit culture here,” the engineer says, switching effortlessly from the poetic pomp of Sanskrit to scholarly Tamil to everyday Kannada.
The scholars here are well-versed in Devanagari, Manipravala and Granthalipi, the latter two being archaic scripts that incorporate south Indian languages into Sanskrit. Narayan, named after the deity of the town, holds up for examination a folio from a Ramayana manuscript, one of the few displayed in a glass case in the palm leaf library. Crammed with text — 24 lines of it — it is carved with small, impossibly intricate letters. Typed up, the text in one folio will take up four pages, says manuscriptologist Rao. “In Devanagari, you write under a line, which makes the palm leaf susceptible to cleaving along the line. This is why Manipravala, with its rounded letters, was preferred,” Narayan says, adding, “Our ancestors thought of everything, they knew everything.”
“Everything” being the key word. With interest in traditional knowledge growing, the Academy has been seeking to reconcile ancient texts with modern science, desperate to justify to the world that Vedic India was the fountainhead of all knowledge. In the research wing, a yellow building with huge circular windows and peeling plaster, a hall upstairs bears testimony to these often contrived efforts. Arranged along the walls of the hall, inaugurated last year, are 150 posters on various sciences, annotated with obscure excerpts from the Vedas as “proof” that ancient Indians were adept at everything from designing flying vehicles to cornea grafting. Calculations on the velocity of light and exacting instructions on purification of iron crowd some of these posters; others bear more oblique references. A quotation from Kumarasambhava mentions “the creation of two sons, Agastya and Vasishtha, from one utensil”. According to Academy scholars, this is an unmistakable reference to test tube babies and IVF.
When the Academy put up a stall at the Sanskrit Book Fair held early this year in Bangalore, books on science and technology in ancient India flew off the shelves, says Anandazhvan, a researcher who was in Bangalore for the event. Narayan, whose field of research is agriculture in Vedic India, says several agricultural universities as well as the Department of Ayush have knocked on the Academy’s doors seeking collaboration. “We have 28 previously unpublished manuscripts on Ayurveda. We are looking at publishing them and planting useful herbs in our gardens,” Kumara says.
Driving back to
Bangalore, we look out
the window at the
picturesque square tanks
dotting Melkote. Like
the small flight of
steps easing one’s
descent into the water,
the Academy, too, is a
place of transition from
the past to the present.
What lies beneath the
water, though, is
anybody’s guess.
Indian Express, 29th May 2011
Varied hues unify to furnish the vibrant spectrum of Indian handicraft.
The craft of toy making
is an important part of
this vast handicraft
industry — a rich
tradition thriving in
different parts of the
country.
The diversity of this
craft is immense and
provides prominence to
various states
acknowledged for
producing widely famous
ethnic toys made of
clay, wood, cloth, jute,
metal, pith cane,
leather and bamboo.
Beautifully crafted with
skilled hands, these
toys made in the form of
animals, dolls or
deities are
predominantly seen as
children’s play things,
but in reality, they
play a significant role
in promoting the culture
and tradition of the
specific area beyond its
geographical limits,
besides symbolising the
religious sentiments of
the artisans.
The state of Madhya
Pradesh is renowned
across the country for
its clay toys. Much fame
is brought to the state
through the contribution
of artisans belonging to
the Gond tribe,
popularly acknowledged
for its cultural
heritage. The tribesmen
excel in wood craft and
bamboo craft and
showcase their talent in
the shape of various
handcrafted items.
The role of local and
tribal people in
promoting the culture of
handmade toys is
absolutely undeniable in
various regions. The
sole reason the craft
manages to survive is
that it is carried on as
a tradition through
generations. In Assam,
it is said the
traditional art of
making cloth dolls is
taken more as a family
custom where daughters
eagerly learn the skill
from their mothers. The
Goal Para community of
Assam is famous for its
toys made of clay and
cloth.
Although the animal form
remains the most popular
form of making toys,
bride and groom dolls,
mythological figures and
religious deities also
enjoy the fascination of
artisans as well as that
of buyers. These toys
are best showcased
during religious
festivities and regional
carnivals.
Craftsmen can go to any
length to experiment
with the choice of
medium to furnish a toy.
It is said that in
Andhra Pradesh, artisans
make use of a mixture of
clay, cow dung and saw
dust to make toys which
are later neatly and
beautifully painted in
bright colours.
Deccan Herald, 29thMay 2011
The term
‘Satkhanda’ literally
means ‘seven storey’,
but this heritage
monument in Lucknow,
which dates back to
1837, is only a
four-storeyed circular
structure standing tall
opposite the famous
Hussainabad Imambara
Though it has been
subject to vandalism and
is in ruins today, it
still retains its old
splendour and is visited
by a large number of
tourists.
Mohammad Ali Shah, the
third king of Oudh
(Awadh), who started its
construction almost 170
years back, wanted it to
be the tallest structure
in the world and look
like a medieval painting
of the Tower of Babel or
the Leaning Tower of
Pisa, as he had heard a
lot about them from the
visitors to his court
from abroad.
The Awadh historians say
that the nawab, who was
very impressed with
Greek architecture, also
wanted the structure to
be the ‘Eighth wonder of
the world’.
It was said to be
originally visualised as
a place from where the
king could have a bird’s
eye view of the city of
Lucknow.
Strangely there are
varied records about the
number of storeys in the
building. While some say
that it was originally
planned as a
seven-storeyed building,
there are others who
mention about a
nine-storeyed structure
and some even claim a
six-storeyed structure.
Some experts opine that
the nawab had actually
planned ‘Naumachia’
(nine-storeyed building)
and not ‘Satkhanda’. Ram
Sakai, a writer of Awadh
history, has mentioned
about ‘Naumachia’.
Abdul Halim Sharar,
another writer, in his
book, says that five
storeys of the building
was completed when the
king died, but a
majority of writers and
historians refer to the
monument as ‘Satkhanda’
only.
Some say that the king
had the building
constructed so that he
could sight the moon
that signals the
celebration of eid.
Mohammad Ali Shah,
immediately after his
ascendance to the throne
of Oudh, focused his
attention on the
beautification of the
city. He gave funds for
the construction of the
Lucknow-Kanpur road over
the canal and appointed
a British engineer to
oversee its
construction.
The king also
constructed the ‘chota
imambara’ (an imposing
monument built to serve
as his own mausoleum).
The chandeliers to
decorate the interior
part of the building was
brought from Belgium,
reflecting the king’s
love for European
designs.
Only four storeys could
be completed before the
construction had to be
stopped following
Mohammad Ali Shah’s
death in 1842. According
to the local belief, the
king, an infirm, loved
his daughter very much
and had constructed the
building for her. The
daughter, however, died
at a tender age. The
king could not bear the
loss of his dear
daughter and he also
breathed his last a
little later. His
untimely death brought
the construction of the
beautiful building to a
halt.
A blend of French and
Italian architecture,
the circular structure
has arches that are
examples of Islamic
architecture. The Greek
influence could be seen
in alternate succession
in the façade and in the
four tiers of the
structure that is still
in existence today. The
67-metre tower, that
could very well have
been the pride of Awadh
and a major tourist
attraction, is in ruins
like many other heritage
sites in Lucknow today
and may well come down
in the near future,
unless conservationists
and authorities turn
their immediate
attention towards its
restoration.
“The ‘Satkhanda’ is an
important symbol of
Awadh’s past glory and
it must be restored to
its original form.
Unfortunately, officials
are not sensitive
towards such heritage
monuments resulting in
their decay,’’ said
Yorgen Provence,
well-known Awadh
historian, who has
written several books on
Awadh culture and
history.
The monument has been
subject to vandalism and
a large portion of the
building has already
been damaged, owing
largely to official
apathy and ignorance
among the common public.
The Hussainabad and
Allied Trust (HAT), that
looks after many
heritage buildings in
Lucknow, has however
started a project to
protect the monument
from further damage and
restore it to its old
glory. The Trust is also
contemplating on posting
security guards outside
the structure to prevent
further vandalism. The
Trust officials feel
that the co-operation of
the locals is a must in
this regard.
The renovation work,
however, has been moving
at a snail’s pace and
even as it continues,
the defacement of the
imposing structure also
goes on simultaneously.
The Indian Institute of
Technology at Roorkee in
Uttarakhand has been
entrusted with the job
of restoring the
structure to its
original glory. The
authorities say that
they will complete the
work of renovation soon.
The grand structure may
be a symbol of an
unfulfilled dream, but
it certainly reflects a
glorious past and needs
to be preserved.
Deccan Herald, 29thMay 2011
Dara Shikoh is one of the most tragic figures in Indian history. A philosopher and a liberal who favoured cultural interaction between people of different faiths, the 17th century Mughal prince was executed after losing the war of succession among emperor Shah Jahan's sons.
Over the centuries, Dara has been reduced to a mere footnote in the history of India. But Ajoka, a theatre group from Pakistan, believes there's plenty to be learnt from the socio-cultural and political thought of the Mughal prince. "Dara", a play to be staged at the Kamani Auditorium on May 30, will provide an insight into the man who understood the need for harmonious co-existence between different religious communities.
"I researched on Dara for many years. I visited Agra and Old Delhi. And I found books on Dara at Urdu Bazaar and Ghalib library. He was not only a Sufi, but also a poet, calligrapher and a scholar who did comparative studies on religions. In Los Angeles, I found an English translation of Sarmad's poetry, published by Satsang Beas in Punjab," says playwright Shahid Nadeem (62). "Visits to Agra Fort and Hazrat Nizam-ud-din's dargah were important not only for research but also for inspiration," he adds. Sarmad was a mystic of Armenian origin from Persia, who came to the Mughal Empire in the 17th century. Dara was influenced by him.
Another play, "Bullha", will be performed the following day at the same venue. It is based on the life and works of the great Punjabi Sufi poet, Bulleh Shah. "His poetry is a powerful voice for universal love and a strong indictment of religious exploitation. The play also includes qawwalis. It has been very well-received in Punjab, Kerala and Delhi in recent years," says Nadeem, who has penned this play, too.
Both the plays have been directed by Madeeha Gauhar, another eminent theatre personality from Pakistan. "Bullha" imbibes indigenous humanistic and secular forms such as the Sufi traditions. "We counter intolerance and bigotry with the humanism of Bulleh Shah, Shah Hussain, Amir Khusro, Khwaja Fareed, Guru Nanak, Baba Farid and Kabir," says Gauhar. She further says that both plays are attracting huge audiences in an increasingly Talibanized Pakistan. Some prominent Pakistani artistes such as Kamran Mujahid, Sarfraz Ansari, Tahira Imam, Imran-ul-Haq, Usman Zia and Eva Majid have acted in the two plays.
The plays have been
brought to Delhi by
Routes 2 Roots, an NGO
that seeks to enhance
cultural ties across
SAARC countries,
especially India and
Pakistan through theatre
and music concerts.
Times of India, 29th May2011
HISTORY-The Shia
cemetery in Jorbagh
contains the tombs of
some illustrious
personages, including
Jorbagh is known for its
Karbala, where Tazias
are interred at
Moharrum, but few know
that the Shia cemetery
there contains the tombs
of some illustrious
personages. Among these
is the mausoleum of Mah
Khanum. What her real
identity is a mystery
and even Maulvi Zafar
Hasan's survey of the
monuments of Delhi does
not throw much light on
it. Mah Khanum was born
during the reign of
Aurangzeb and died in
1726 at the time of
Mohammad Shah, before
the Qadim Sharif or the
stone impressions of
Hazrat Ali's foot was
installed there by
Qudsia Begum, the
emperor's wife.
Khanum is the feminine of Khan and Mah Khanum would mean that she was the most exalted lady of her time. Her title was the equivalent of Khan-e-Khanan, bestowed on great generals and statesmen by Moghul rulers. There were few who enjoyed this honour, besides Abdul Rahim Khan-e-khanan, one of Akbar's Nau Ratan or Nine Jewels of the court.
Mah Khanum's tomb stands in the centre of the Karbala which has been described by Zafar Hasan thus: “In the centre of the Karbala is a masonry apartment covered by a vaulted roof, and over that apartment is a platform a few feet high. Under that platform is an underground chamber which has a vaulted ceiling and a marble floor, and is approached from the apartment by descending 15 steps. It is in this chamber that the grave of Mah Khanum, which is a marble monument, is to be found. The grave measures 6-ft 4-inches by 1-ft 4-inches…. On the grave are inscribed these words in Persian: Mah Khanum, the sun of the zodiac of chastity, by Heaven's decree hid her face under the cloud of compassion and turned her face towards God. “The pen of providence wrote the date of this (event) on the tablet of the grave (when) the Mary of the age joined God”.
Pious lady
The chronogram gives the
date 1139 Hijri
(1726-27AD). From this
it can be deduced that
Mah Khanum was a very
pious lady and a virgin
because of her
comparison with Mary,
the mother of Christ,
who was held in high
esteem for her piety and
saintly life. The
Karbala is known for the
dargah of Shahi Mardan
(Ali) which was built by
Nawab Qudsia Begum. The
wall enclosing the
Karbala is said to have
been erected by Kaptan
Sahib Ashraf Beg,
captain of Scindia's
forces in the reign of
Shah Alam. Not far away
in Aliganj is the mosque
of Zeenat Begum (not
Aurangzeb's daughter)
along with a baoli or
step-well. Nearby are
also a Naqqar Khana, a
lal masjid and an
imambara. Other noted
women buried in the
cemetery are Sharfun
Nisa Begum alias Haji
Begum, daughter of Mirza
Sayyid Muhammad
Gulistana alias Mirza
Jani who died in August
1801, Biba Jan who died
in 1851 and believed to
have been a dancing
girl. Then there the
graves of Wilayati
Kanaum Sahiba who died
in 1852, Sadrunissa
(died 1808), Jahanara
(died 1843), Mahaldar
Begum (died 1804), and
Mihirunnisa Begum (died
1813).
However the most
notable tomb is that of
Mahabat Khan, General of
Jahangir, who took the
emperor prisoner for
some time to express his
resentment against the
domination of the empire
by Nur Jahan. His real
name was Zamana Beg and
he was appointed
governor of Delhi by
Shah Jahan. Mahabat
Khan, who became a Shia
in later life, died in
1634, his daughter who
pre-deceased him is
buried in an exquisite
monument in Agra.
Dominating all the
graves in the area is
the tomb of Nawab
Safdarjang, built in
1753 from material taken
from Khan-e-Khanan's
tomb in Nizamuddin. The
focus is naturally on
this last lamp of the
architectural
magnificence of the
Moghul era. Hence the
neglect of the other
monuments of Jorbagh,
where the riddle,
“wrapped in an enigma”
of Mah Khanum stares one
in the face like a
medieval sphinx.
The Hindu, 30th May 2011
Nikitin's travelogue comes across as a thoroughly unprejudiced account of Indian reality
The well-known Russian Indologist, Ivan Minayev's work on Voyage Beyond the Three Seas, a 15th century travelogue by Afanasy Nikitin (a Russian merchant and adventurer), developed the original so beautifully as to reflect contemporary India in all its diverse, but integrated, economic, social and cultural facets.
The book starts with two notes: one by Irina Chelysheva on Minayev's contributions to Indian studies, and the other by Minayev himself, briefly introducing Nikitin's manuscript. Chelysheva's note sharply brings out Minayev's heritage that continues as leavening influence on the Russian Indologists, even after 120 years.
The first of the seven chapters in the book is on Nikitin's voyage from Hormuz, a tiny island of Persia, 20-30 miles in perimeter with barren land and inhospitable climate, but with one of the most strategic ports. It is followed by a narration of his trading experience in Cambay, a port from which ships sailed all over the Indian seas. Nikitin had a sojourn in Chaul, a commercial town in the Bhamini kingdom, situated 23 miles to the south-east of Bombay.
Bidar, where Nikitin arrived from Junnar via Kulungir and Gulbarga, is discussed extensively. The prominent role Bidar played as a medieval point of exchange and a transactional centre of contemporary politico-cultural life; the Shah and his court; and his campaigns and excursions — all these are dealt with in detail. The contextualised note of the editor, given towards the end, helps the reader a great deal in comparing Nikitin's travelogue with contemporary sources.
The manuscript
The English translation
of Nikitin's manuscript,
given as an annexure,
provides the reader a
feel of his long,
arduous, and eventful
journey from the Volga.
The other annexure
presents Chelysheva's
study of the manuscript
and its elucidation
undertaken in India in
the 19th century on the
basis of archival
material in Maharashtra.
Nikitin's travelogue comes across as a thoroughly unprejudiced account of Indian reality. It is argued that Nikitin's account, though naïve and inadequate sometimes, has immense historical value for the Russian and Indian researchers.
If the original is remarkably objective, the fact that it has been contextualised and supplemented by Minayev's historical scholarship makes the book an important source of information on medieval India. It transports the reader from the harbour of Hormuz to the shores of Gujarat and enables him to experience the life and culture of the ruling aristocracy, the splendid courts, the militia and the rank and file, the market place, holy places, food habits, fairs, festivals, rituals, local traditions, and superstitions that prevailed during that period in the kingdom of Bidar.
Minayev's
commentary
By way of commenting on
Nikitin's observations,
Minayev has traced the
genesis and development
of the socio-economic,
political, and cultural
history of India up to
the 19th century,
comparing the picture
emerging from the
travelogue with the one
that prevailed in
British India. In the
hands of Minayev,
Nikitin's manuscript has
acquired an intellectual
depth.
Minayev differed from his European colleagues on two points. First, he did not share their preferential focus on the ‘classical ancient', which they considered glorious, or their prejudiced neglect of the ‘post-classical' as degenerative, and hence disgraceful. He found it important to study the Indian historical process as a whole. Secondly, unlike theirs, his approach to contemporary Indian civilisation was open and without any reservation.
Russia is perhaps the
only country to express
sympathy for India's
struggle for
Independence and cast
doubts on the
“progressive mission” of
British colonialism in
India.This perception,
left as Minayev's
legacy, deserves to be
shared with the people
of the country he
studied insightfully and
affectionately. This
book does serve that
purpose.
The Hindu, 31st May 2011
“My Country's
World Heritage” photo
contest is an
opportunity to learn
more about the World
Heritage Sites in our
country.
Marking the World
Heritage Day, NGO's
Nivesh, and The
Himalayan Hub for Art,
Culture and Heritage
(HHACH) started the
Photo Contest “My
Country's World
Heritage.” The contest,
held in partnership with
UNESCO and Cannon, saw
the first workshop held
for children in Delhi,
encouraging them to
photograph the UNESCO
world heritage sites of
India, beginning with an
early morning trip to
one of Delhi's favourite
monuments, the Qutub
Minar.
On the occasion of the inauguration of the workshop, Cannon's CEO and president, Fujio Mitarai addressed the children and teachers gathered in Ambience Mall's Cannon studio lounge. “Our philosophy at Cannon is very similar to this project's philosophy and motto. We want the young generation to value and preserve the rich cultural heritage of their country and the world. You see a beautiful thing, you feel impressed, and you want to share the experience with your friends and family. Taking beautiful pictures makes this possible,” Fujio said.
“The primary goal of these workshops and contest is to preserve and capture the beauty and importance of the world heritage sights in the country. This raises awareness in not only the present generation, but the future ones also,” said Shaguna Gahilote, Project Officer for Culture, UNESCO New Delhi.
Learn photography
The first workshop saw
children participating
from the NGO Sakshi
Samajik Suvidha. “It was
a great experience. We
learnt a lot about the
monument and about how
to photograph them,”
says Mina, a
bright-eyed, 14-year-old
from the NGO. The
children were taught the
basics of photography by
Shailesh Sharma, a
professional
photographer whose work
was also displayed in
the Cannon Studio Lounge
for the children to see
and learn from. He
explained to the little
photographers important
concepts like ISO,
shutter speed and taught
them how to use a
tripod. Students from
Apeejay School
Pritampura and Salwan
Public School were also
present.
The project is a
pan-Indian one, and will
involve and encourage
children to visit and
photograph the heritage
sites in their city and
send it to the NGO. The
entries will be judged
in October 2011 by a
panel of professional
photographers. The best
entries will be given a
certificate and prize.
Canon India will be
funding the project to
conduct the workshops.
Regular workshops will
be held once a month in
each of the
participating cities.
Schools all over Delhi
and five other cities —
Hyderabad, Leh,
Bangalore, Mumbai and
Kolkata —have been
invited to register and
participate in the
contest. The workshops
will be held with a
select group of school
children divided into
two categories, for 15
to17 years and 12 to 14
years. The final
workshops will we held
in the month of
September, when the
contest closes. Students
from schools registered
for the programme can
take part in the
competition. The best
pictures taken by
students will be
selected and displayed
in November.
The Hindu, 31st May 2011
The fate of the
multi-crore Dr Shyama
Prasad Mukherjee Civic
Centre hangs in balance
after trifurcation of
the Municipal
Corporation of Delhi.
Elected members of the
ruling BJP and
Opposition Congress
believed unbundling of
the civic body will
create a peculiar
situation, which may
result in depreciation
of the 28-storey
structure and huge
revenue loss to the
Government.
Who will have ownership
rights of the property
and whose liability it
will be after the
splitting of the MCD
into smaller units? Who
will be responsible for
its maintenance and who
will be legal heir to
revenue from the
property?
All these questions may
be precursors to a huge
property dispute and
clashes between
Government
organisations.
Sources in the MCD said
all three future
municipalities may be
allotted equal space at
the civic centre and if
infrastructure for
separate bodies is
created, it will require
more funds and loss to
public exchequer.
“All three corporations
may continue functioning
from the same building.
Equal space —equal
number of floors — may
be given to three
bodies. It will be also
be in favour of the
common man. Otherwise,
creation of such
infrastructure will
require huge money,”
said a source.
A senior Delhi
Government official also
said there was ample
space at the civic
centre and even if some
issues were to come up,
zonal Deputy
Commissioner offices may
be re-developed.
The MCD sources further
said that since the Town
Hall is a heritage
building, it cannot be
sold or altered and may
thus be taken over by
the Government. Soon,
the Town Hall — a
145-year-old building
from where the MCD had
been running its
headquarters — may be
converted into a
heritage hotel.
Delhi Mayor Rajni Abbi
is uncertain whether the
three bodies will get
space on a sharing basis
and said the ownership
rights would result in a
tussle among the three
proposed municipalities.
“I also raised the issue
of the civic centre
before Union Home
Minister P Chidambaram
at a recent meeting,
asking who (civic
bodies) would have
privilege for its
headquarters in the
building. I told him
Delhi Chief Minister
Sheila Dikshit had been
insisting to divide the
MCD like a cake into
five or three pieces and
the civic centre is like
cherry on it, so who
would have the cherry?”
she quipped.
On the contrary,
Standing Committee
chairman Yogender
Chandolia alleged that
with the trifurcation of
the MCD, the Delhi
Government is also
eyeing numerous MCD
properties worth crores.
Former Delhi Mayor and
Congress councillor from
Nizamuddin ward Farhad
Suri said there may,
now, be several issues
which need to be
addressed carefully.
However, Leader of
Opposition Jai Kishan
Sharma had a different
take and said there
would not be any problem
and that each unit
(after dissolving the
MCD into small blocks)
would get its adequate
share within the
premises.
The Pioneer, 31st May 2011
The 13th Finance
Commission made a
historic budget
allocation to state
governments for the
restoration of their
heritage. With an
allocation of ` 100
crore, can Punjab
restore the glory of
Quila Mubarak, with its
notorious history of
bureaucratic solutions
for matters related to
culture and
conservation?
IT’S only in the last
few years the Government
of India has finally
woken up to the
realisation that post
independence the
heritage of India has
been gravely neglected.
While the Archaeological
Survey of India had its
budget substantially
increased in 2002, thus
ensuring that the
national heritage would
never lack funds; state
government budgets for
culture remain pitiful,
its limited resources
largely allocated to
paying salaries of
administration and
staff. Last year the
13th Finance Commission
made a historic budget
allocation to state
governments for the
restoration of their
heritage. Ranging from
Rs 175 crore to Madhya
Pradesh, 10 crore to
Tripura, and Rs 100
crore assigned to
Punjab; these
allocations were made
against rapidly cobbled
together ill conceived
estimates. One only has
to consider that the
entire State of Jammu
and Kashmir has an
allocation of Rs 50
crore for just one site,
Mubarak Mandi in Jammu.
DECAYING FRESCOS
Inside Quila
Andaroon
Built in 1763,
Quila Mubarak,
the rare and
outstanding
example of Sikh
palace
architecture is
in a dilapidated
state. World
Monument Fund
listed the Quila
in the “ list of
100 most
endangered
monuments” in
2004. Since then
INTACH( Indian
National Trust
for Arts and
Cultural
Heritage) and
ASI (
Archaeological
Survey of India)
with the help of
Punjab State
Government and
the Central
Government, have
taken up several
restoration
projects with
funding from
World Heritage
Watch and other
agencies, but
the Quila
continues to
lose its
heritage value
due to decay and
bureaucratic
delays.
Missing: Money, manpower
Missing: Money,
manpower
While this significant
injection of funds for
heritage must be
welcomed and it’s not a
minute too soon; the
tragedy facing cultural
institutions in India is
that apart from meagre
budget allocations,
there has been
absolutely no human
resource development in
the last decades.
Systems established in
the colonial era still
prevail and recruitment
policies are fossilised
in the 19th century.
Institutions, monuments
and sites are in danger,
not just for want of
money but simply because
there has been no
investment in developing
manpower to protect
them. With no emphasis
on skills upgrading or
professionalisation, our
culture and heritage
remain at risk.
The heritage sites at the state level are most critically endangered as they face a total vacuum in professional manpower. The lack of emphasis in the development of expertise, the predominance of bureaucrats in making technical decisions and the absence of commitment to build a cadre of professional and technical skills in culture and heritage management is a crisis we face across the country. Funds are languishing, or worse, misused in the absence of suitable skills. The conservation and preservation of our heritage is a highly professional task and we need to recognise this gap. Visiting protected sites in various states one cannot help but be profoundly disturbed by the awareness of local people about not only the misuse of funds, but more critically, the damage caused by unimaginative use of funds for the monuments. Ironically, departments of culture remain unable or unwilling to grasp the gravity of the damage being inflicted as vast swathes of original fabric are replaced.
Quick fix
conservation
So, back to the 13th
Finance Commission; what
will become of these
resources? Will local
caretakers turn into
conservationists so that
heritage sites not
merely languish, but get
further damaged as ad-
hoc repairs, shortcuts
and kickbacks vitiate
the windfall of funding?
In the rush to spend the
money before it
“lapses”, will cement
replace lime mortar as a
quick and easy option,
and will the finely
crafted pillars be
substituted with crass
machine cut stones? Are
we always going to get
it wrong?
While privatisation is the mantra of the time and public- private partnership the call to arms, there is one thing we need to be clear on: the cultural heritage of the nation or the state is the custodial responsibility of the government. Their mandate is to safeguard the heritage for future generations. And, in today’s climate of public information, governments can and must be called to account on its ability to safeguard our heritage for future generations.
Even the Archaeological Survey of India with its hugely increased budget has been unable or unwilling to restructure and upgrade its systems, update professional skills and invest in management. In this scenario can the states transform their approach? In the crossed wires which define Indian administration, and as fiats against recruitment prevail, the culture sector epitomises diminishing standards and failure to deliver; an area where the responsibility of the government is non negotiable. It is essential that structural reform in the culture sector must be undertaken at every level.
The
precarious Quila
The problems are
manifold. Quila Mubarak
or the Sheesh Mahal in
Patiala are alarming
examples of the failure
of government to
recognise the magnitude
of damage done through
neglect and paucity of
competent decision
making. Over the last 20
years I have watched
many initiatives to
preserve Quila Mubarak
flounder. This iconic
heritage of Punjab was
acquired by the state as
“our” heritage and
efforts to preserve it
have continuously been
vitiated by political
compulsions or a
bureaucracy mired in
mediocrity. In the years
that I have followed its
fate, many reports have
been generated, the only
difference being that
each condition
assessment has further
highlighted the gravity
facing the building;
funds have been
allocated and lapsed,
more than once. About
ten years ago under
immense pressure from
conservationists,
government offices were
removed from the
complex. Lying vacant
and uncared for ever
since, the building
today is in a desperate
state of decay.
Now under the 13th Finance Commission perhaps it will receive some funding, probably wholly inadequate to its needs. But what is far worse and must give us cause for concern, is, that Punjab’s finest heritage will be restored at the lowest tender bidding..
Today with this huge amount of money being injected we need to stop and consider very carefully how best to minimise waste, or indeed optimise the opportunity. Given the manpower void, professional consultants must step up and fill the gap until state departments get their act together and divert a significant amount of money towards developing technical training institutions and augment their capacities. The need of the hour clearly is setting up institutes for cultural resource training and management which will serve existing institutions, transforming not just how we preserve, but also nurture and manage our cultural resources. Perhaps, states should join forces and collaborate on technical training and thus manage their heritage in a more collaborative way. Until then government must have the humility to acknowledge that professional skills in India require to be engaged and that they are the most competent in the present scenario to undertake this task.
A live-in with
heritage
States such as Punjab
which are being guided
by agencies like
Infrastructure Leasing
Finance& Services, the
Asian Development Bank
and a battery of
consultants are
attempting to moderate a
paradigm shift to manage
the often competing
objectives of
development and
preservation. Here
preservation is finally
on the table with
infrastructure and
development and this is
a huge transformation in
perception. In planning
documents and as a one-
off for execution, this
would appear to be a
perfect model for others
to emulate. A
simultaneous thrust in
education, training and
building skills is
critical, without which
it cannot work. In
realistic terms serious
reform will mean
restructuring state
archaeology departments;
changing recruitment
rules and battling the
many vested interests
and turf wars to
establish more result
oriented organisations.
Equally, in the long
term, the preservation
of sites like Quila
Mubarak will best be
realised if we can give
it a role and relevance
in society. Will Quila
Mubarak house a Cultural
Resource Training
Institute - an
opportunity to study and
work in a historic site?
With this tranche of
funding can we imbue
these sites with energy
and capture the
imagination of
generation next? Clearly
the opportunity given to
the states is rich with
challenge to evaluate
and restructure how we
mediate the future of
our heritage. We must
have the courage to step
out of the box and
debate new solutions.
While the Punjab
Government has seen the
merit of investing in a
cultural policy document
which should in due
course address these
lacunae and provide a
balanced and
professional foundation
for the future of
Punjab’s heritage, what
will happen in the
interim? It must have
the vision and the
integrity to shift the
decision making process
to professional advisors
who will assess the
work, guide decisions,
monitor implementation
and ensure that funds
are optimally utilised
not just for the finance
commission, but for the
future of our heritage.
The Tribune, 31st May 2011
Five years after India, Pakistan and Bangladesh banned the veterinary use of diclofenac, scientists have now unearthed the first evidence of the efficacy of the ban, writes Kalyan Ray
The ban seems to have
worked. Five years ago,
India, Pakistan and
Bangladesh banned
veterinary use of
diclofenac as it was
found to be the main
causative factor behind
a virtual wipe-out of
the subcontinent’s
vultures that gorged on
diclofenac-laden
carcasses. Scientists
have now unearthed the
first evidence of the
efficacy of the ban.
The ban did not have an
immediate impact, but
started to show results
after almost three
years. Analysis of
samples collected around
December 2008 showed a
reverse trend in the
decline of vulture
population. Even though
veterinary diclofenac is
still believed to be in
the system illegally,
the results so far are
encouraging.
Researchers at Bombay
Natural History Society
reported decline of
vulture population first
in the 1990s in Keoladeo
National Park at
Bharatpur in Rajasthan.
Subsequently, the crash
in population was
reported from across the
country.
A large number of
studies in the last
decade have clearly
established that the
population of three
species of vultures
decreased at an alarming
rate, thanks to the
drug. A meeting of the
Indian National Board
for Wildlife in 2005,
chaired by the Prime
Minister of India,
finally prompted the
withdrawal of licences
for the manufacture of
veterinary diclofenac.
The numbers of oriental
white-rumped vultures
(gyps bengalensis)
declined by 99.9 per
cent between 1997 and
2007. The population of
oriental white-billed
vultures has an average
annual rate of decline
of 43.9 per cent between
2000 and 2007. Their
numbers are on a decline
since 1992, as a result
of which India now has
only about 11,000 birds
from tens of millions.
Populations of
long-billed and
slender-billed vultures
have fallen. The
combined population of
long-billed vultures
(gyps indicus) and
slender-billed vultures
(gyps tenuirostris) too
dropped by 96.8 per
cent. With a combined
annual average decline
rate of 16 per cent,
India currently has
about 45,000 long-billed
vultures and just about
1,000 slender-billed
vultures.
Just short of
extinct
All three species fall
in the International
Union for the
Conservation of Nature
(IUCN) category of
‘critically endangered’,
the highest risk
category is just short
of extinct. Researchers
from BNHS and Indian
Veterinary Research
Institute, Izzatnagar
with colleagues from UK
and Spain measured the
prevalence and
concentration of
diclofenac in carcasses
of domesticated cattle
in India, before and
after the implementation
of the ban. Samples were
collected in three
phases – between May,
2006 and July, 2005;
April and December of
2006 and between
January, 2007 and
December, 2008. The
study shows that the
proportion of cattle
carcasses in India
contaminated with the
drug declined by over 40
per cent between 2006
and 2008.
The concentration of the
drug in contaminated
animals also fell.
Combining the effects of these two changes, the expected rate of annual population decline of the vultures is expected to slow by approximately 60 per cent, the team reported in the journal PLOS One on May 11.
Need for greater
efforts
The resulting decline
rate is still expected
to be around 18 per cent
per year for the most
susceptible species, the
oriental white-backed
vulture. Even though the
results show early signs
of success compared to
the pre-ban era when the
decline was about 40 per
cent per year, the study
suggests that vultures
will not recover unless
more efforts are made to
eradicate the drug from
the system. Although
legal action has started
to show encouraging
results, much remains to
be done.
“Because of the
difficulty in ensuring
that human diclofenac is
not being used illegally
and in secret, testing
the vulture food (cattle
carcasses) directly is
the only way to find out
how safe the vultures
really are,” said
Devendra Swarup, former
research director at
IVRI and one of the
authors of the paper.
Three captive breeding
centres have been built
so far in India, where
250 vultures are housed
at the moment and
successfully breeding of
all three species is
continuing. The centres
are in Haryana, West
Bengal and in Assam. Two
additional centres are
operational in Nepal and
Pakistan, and five
Indian zoos are also
developing captive
breeding facilities with
the support of the
Central Zoo Authority.
“We will start releasing
the vultures by 2014-15
when we have sufficient
birds (in groups of 25
birds) and most
importantly by that
time, the government
should see that
diclofenac is totally
removed from the
veterinary sector;
otherwise these released
birds will also die one
day due to diclofenac
poisoning,” BNHS
director Asad Rahmani
told Deccan Herald.
Pharmacies in India
often dispense both
human and veterinary
medicines because of
which they can legally
hold diclofenac stocks.
Safe alternatives
are key
They dispense human
formulations of
diclofenac for use on
livestock. Together with
informal and illegal
dispensing of human
diclofenac for
veterinary purposes by
unregistered people
probably accounts for
the continued
contamination of
ungulate carcasses, the
researchers said, adding
that a similar situation
might exist in the
Punjab province of
Pakistan too.
Complete removal of
diclofenac from vulture
food was the single most
important action needed
to save vultures,
Rahmani said.
“This shows how much
progress has been made,
but there is still a job
to do; to make sure that
safe alternative drugs
are used. Unfortunately
some of the alternatives
have not been tested for
their safety to vultures
and one drug in
increasing use,
ketoprofen, is already
known to be toxic to
vultures,” said the
study’s lead author
Richard Cutbert from
Royal Society for the
Protection of Birds.
The only safe
alternative used in
India known so far is
meloxicam, which is
becoming more widely
used now that its cost
is falling and
approaching that of
diclofenac, Rahmani
added.
Deccan Herald, 31st May 2011
Begur, a small
village that lies on
Bangalore’s periphery,
struggles to retain its
old-world charm,
crumbling mud fort,
broken sculptures, hero
stones and more
importantly, the
inscription that
mentions Bangalore for
the first time in
recorded history.
Lakshmi Sharath visits
the village that is
slowly being eaten up by
multicoloured apartment
complexes
It was that house in
Begur that first caught
my attention. There was
an open space with dry
grass and a narrow path
that led to a small
village street. A huge
compound met my gaze,
with a small door that
was left ajar to reveal
a courtyard and a house
with pink walls. The
rangoli in front of the
door looked fresh, but I
couldn’t see a soul. A
small stone bench was
placed near the
entrance.
But what really caught
my attention was not the
house itself. It was a
small sculpture placed
at the very end of the
compound. It seemed to
sit there placidly,
without anyone really
disturbing it. I bent
down to take a closer
look, all the time
wondering if I should
ask someone for
permission to take a
photograph. But there
was no one around. It
was a Jaina sculpture
and I stumbled on it
when I was looking for
the remains of an old
Jaina basti in Begur.
Begur is a small
village, located in the
outskirts of Bangalore.
While most villages
outside the City have
lost their identities,
merging somewhere with
the IT corridor, Begur
struggles to retain its
old-world charm, even as
real estate and rampant
construction projects
knock at its very door.
The banks of the lake
have been taken over by
multicoloured apartment
complexes, while the
roads are dug up all
along the village. The
crumbled mud fort that
speaks of a rich past
shares its compound with
chaotic modern-day
constructions. There are
buildings and cranes
touching the sky, and
the old temples inside
the fort are dwarfed
somewhere in between.
My quest, however, was
to understand the
heritage of the town and
its connect with
Bangalore. The
settlement itself dates
back to the sixth
century and its story
can be pieced together
through the old temples,
the crumbling mud fort,
the remains of a Jain
basti, lost
inscriptions, broken
veeragallus (hero
stones) and scattered
sculptures in front of
houses.
Stories people
tell...
But the best
story-tellers are people
who have lived in the
village and have passed
on their tales to
generations. The stories
may lack the clinical
precision of history
books, but they are
laced with a passion and
zest that come from a
sense of belonging. As
Girish, the head priest
of the 1000-year-old
Panchalinga temple said,
“For us, Begur is mula
(origin), only after
that comes Bangalore.”
The locals were indeed
my guides in the village
and I saw the village
through their eyes. One
of the first locals I
met was young Vidya and
her 98-year-old
grandfather Subbarama
Sastry.
I was standing in front of their house wondering whether to take a photograph of the Jaina sculpture when Vidya asked me if I was a researcher, in her crisp English. She had just finished her studies in Bangalore and was spending her holidays with her grandfather. She invited me inside to meet him.
It was an old house,
simple and comfortable,
and we listened to Vidya
and her grandfather talk
in a mix of Kannada and
Telugu. Vidya’s great
grandfather Rama Sastry
whose photographs dot
the walls of their
house, had moved in here
from Andhra Pradesh more
than 100 years ago and
their family had been
the officiating priests
for more than 30
villages including
Begur. “We conducted so
many weddings and
ceremonies too, apart
from being temple
priests,” they told us.
The Begur of their days
was a quiet village,
filled with local
festivities. They told
me about the ancient
Gopalaswamy temple in
the fort compound, a
temple that seemed even
smaller than some of the
roadside temples in
Bangalore, but I learnt
that the original idol
of Venugopala is today
placed in a museum in
Bangalore. The
grandfather’s memory was
hazy, but when we spoke
about the Jaina
sculpture, he squinted
hard at me and called it
the “Buddha” which had
been around for more
than 100 years.
They directed us to
the fort.
A stone entrance with a
few pillars and
inscriptions was the
adda (haunt) where men
gathered to gossip,
while the children
played cricket in front
of the temples inside
the ground. As we roamed
around aimlessly, a
young man wearing a
white T - shirt and
shorts walked curiously
towards us and proceeded
to show us an old well.
He then took us to a
clearing near the
temples and said that in
his childhood, there was
a tunnel in there, which
had now been buried
under the sand.
Ramachandra was a local
auto driver who was
brought up in the very
village, playing cricket
like the children today.
It was Sunday and his
day off as he catered
largely to the IT crowd
in the vicinity. He was
happy that the IT boom
had given him some work,
but unhappy that land
here was being sold at
crazy prices. We chatted
a bit about the fort as
we walked towards the
pillars at the entrance.
He mentioned that some
historians had copied
the inscriptions here,
using a piece of paper
by rubbing ink on to it.
I later learnt that it
was a technique called
enstampage and the
inscription related to
the death of a chieftain
Nagattara’s daughter who
fasted to death through
a Jain ritual called
sallekhana.
In search of the
teerthankara
Ramachandra looked at
the photograph of the
headless teerthankara
that I had taken along
with me (which had
already appeared in
these pages before) and
suggested that we go
back to Girish, the head
priest at the
Panchalinga temple for
details. Girish’s family
had been officiating in
this 1,000-year-old
temple for generations.
There were five shrines
that dated back to the
Ganga and Chola period,
the oldest of them being
the Nageswara temple and
the remaining four,
Nagareshvara,
Karneshvara, Choleshvara
and Kalikamateshvara
were added later.
The connection with Bangalore, however, was inscribed in a stone that basked in the sun along with broken hero stones. It spoke of a Battle of Bengaluru fought around 900 AD which resulted in the deaths of chieftain Nagattara’s son Buttana-setti. It was apparently the very first time that the City was mentioned in recorded history. Girish added that one of the hero stones which documented chieftain Nagattara’s death were now in a museum in Bangalore.
I showed him the
photograph of the
teerthankara and he gave
us directions mentioning
that the sculptures were
out in the open, seated
amidst thorny bushes.
After losing our way, we
finally reached a small
patch of land where a
residential colony had
sprouted out of nowhere.
There was the headless
teerthankara along with
another idol of
Parshwanatha lying in
the undergrowth.
Nobody could tell us if
it had been a basti, but
the sculptures had been
there long enough to
watch the land around
them shrink, as houses
and colonies were built
here, shoving them into
a corner plot of land.
Watching them
languishing in the
wilderness, I realised
that Begur itself is
getting lost, hemmed in
by these construction
projects. The town may
house the identity of
Bangalore, but the very
identity of Begur lies
in that and is being
threatened today.
Deccan Herald, 31st May 2011
Bangalore has many majestic trees, including ‘ficus’, neem, mango and ‘araucaria cooki’ (the latter found in Lalbagh). A heritage tree register needs to be opened with details like their serial numbers, location, size, species, age and historical background, observes S G Neginhal
The culture of greenery
in Bangalore traces its
roots to the Dewans of
Mysore, British regents
and kings like Hyder Ali
and Tipu Sultan, who
were true blue tree
lovers. Bangalore has
many important lung
spaces such as Lalbagh,
Cubbon Park and several
smaller gardens. Added
to the parks and
gardens, the streets and
roads of Bangalore are
shaded by beautiful
flowering trees. The
earlier Palegars and
rulers of Bangalore had
also planted several
trees in the City, in
addition to several
temple trees already
existing.
Scientists visiting the
Tata and Raman
Institutes added to this
greenery by planting
several exotic
ornamental trees. From
1982, the Forest
Department further
greened the city by
planting lakhs of trees
in the avenues and open
areas of the City in
addition to the earlier
efforts of the erstwhile
BDA. Among these, there
are several majestic,
large-sized trees
standing loftily in the
parks and along our old
City roads. Some are
rare, environmentally
useful, mammoth in size,
and of historical
background. All these
trees make up the
natural heritage of
Bangalore and serve as
important green
landmarks of the City.
Today, though, as the
City grows, there is the
danger of losing these
lofty trees. We have
already lost many of
them. In view of this
concern, these heritage
trees need to be
identified and preserved
for all times to come.
At present, the Dodda
Aalada Mara on Mysore
road is the only giant
heritage tree that is
getting all the required
care and attention.
Heritage trees are
selected on
consideration of their
rarity, age, size,
species, historical
background,
environmental value,
etc. Such trees that dot
the City are the ficus
species, for instance
aswatha (ficus
religiosa), aala (ficus
benghalensis), atthi
(ficus racemosa, syn. F.
glomerata), goni mara
(ficus drupacea syn. F.
mysorensis), Krishna’s
Butter Cup (ficus
krishnae), the
long-leaved mohwa
(madhuca longifolia),
bakul (mimusops elengi),
the yellow-flowering
muttuga (butea
monosperma variety
lutea), neem
(azadirachta indica),
mango and tamarind among
Indian trees.
To this list of species
can be added some exotic
trees on consideration
of their rarity and
uniqueness, like the
Splendid Amherstia, Rose
of Venezuela, Christmas
trees etc. Bangalore has
the uniqueness of having
old, ancient, and
giant-sized ficus and
the long-leaved ippe
(madhuca longifolia)
trees, which are not
found in such large
numbers in any of the
Indian cities.
Keystone species
Ficus trees are
‘keystone species’ that
have large ramifying
effects on the ecosystem
through direct and
indirect pathways, which
are crucial to the
overall health or
function of the
ecosystem. Ficus trees
bear fruits all year
round, and support a
broad spectrum of
frugivorous birds.
During an observation,
about 20 different
species of birds were
seen on the goni mara
(ficus racemosa) when in
fruit. Extinction of
keystone species is
likely to cause major
changes in the urban
ecosystem.
Ancient trees also
support birds of prey.
In a personal
observation, a pair of
spotted owlets were seen
breeding in a natural
hole of a ficus tree on
a busy street of
Vijayanagar. Owls keep
the population of rats
under control, that are
causes for many
diseases.
Ancient long-leaved ippe
trees are another
landmark tree species of
Bangalore, which are
also found in some
specific places like at
Melkote, Mandya etc.
Its seeds yield a
valuable oil used in
medicines, (recently in
soap-making), burning
lamps in temples etc.
These grow into large,
lofty sizes and look
beautiful when in new
flush of leaves. They
were planted by our
ancients in front of
temples and along older
roads. There is an
ancient bakul tree
(mimusops elengi) in the
sprawling Palace of Tipu
Sultan at Bangalore
which I discovered last
year.
It is a huge and healthy
tree, about 300-250
years in age and has a
lot of history attached
to it. The tree is
supposed to have been
planted by either Hyder
Ali or his son Tipu
Sultan. A mango tree
planted by Tipu Sultan
still stands in Lalbagh.
There are three to four
Christmas trees
(Araucaria columnaries
syn. and A. cooki) at
Lalbagh, which not only
flower but bear fruits
every year, rare
floristic occurrence in
the whole of India.
Arboriculturists across
the country annually
flock here to collect
the rare seeds of
Christmas trees.
Several countries in the
world have already
awakened to the
importance of the
heritage trees in their
regions. At Singapore, a
Heritage Tree Scheme was
announced as early as in
August 2001.
To support this
initiative, a Heritage
Tree Fund was
established with the
help of well-known banks
with substantial initial
donations. The fund was
used to kickstart a
conservation programme
to safeguard heritage
trees in that country
and to promote
appreciation of their
natural heritage. Steps
were taken to protect
heritage trees in other
countries like the UK,
Ireland, Canada, USA
etc.
A decade ago, noted
ornithologist Zafar
Futehally and I went
round the City
documenting ancient
ficus trees. We had also
contacted the
authorities to preserve
these trees, as a result
of which an order was
issued not to cut ficus
trees in the city as
they were
environmentally friendly
and supported a number
of colourful birds. But,
one wonders if such
conservation efforts
have been followed up.
A heritage tree
committee should be
formed under the
chairmanship of the
Forest Minister, with
associate members like
the BBMP, Departments of
Forests and
Horticulture, nature
conservationists and
noted landscapers.
Immediate steps should
be taken to prepare a
list of heritage trees
available in the City.
A heritage tree register
needs to be opened with
details like their
serial numbers,
location, size, species,
age, historical back
ground etc.
Orders should be issued
not to damage or remove
these trees. Plaques
should be provided for
these trees giving
essential details like
their serial numbers,
the species, age, size
etc. Private enterprises
need to be approached to
adopt these trees and to
provide funds for their
overall preservation
etc.
Deccan Herald, 31st May 2011
He is remembered
as ‘Abhinava Kalidasa’
of the Kannada literary
world. He enjoyed royal
patronage for many
decades and enriched
Kannada literature
We are talking about
Basavappa Shastry
(1848-91).
A memorial built near the LIC building in the Millennium Circle area on the Mysore-Bangalore Highway, is in a shambles. The whole area is littered with waste and pieces of glass. Weeds proliferate the area around the memorial. This should have been one of the important landmarks of Mysore. The State government that spends crores on the promotion of Kannada language and culture, has, it seems, turned a blind eye to the memorial of Basavappa Shastry.
The writer served as the court poet of Mummadi Krishnaraja Wodeyar and was honoured with the title of ‘Abhinava Kalidasa’. Basavappa Shastry, who had mastered Halagannada and Sanskrit literature, especially Sanskrit plays, had a respectable position in the courts of Mysore kings. Basavappa Shastry was just 18 years old when he became part of the Mysore Palace court and served as rajaguru, asthana vidwamsa and rajapurohit (important royal decorations). He published a compilation on Mummadi Krishnaraja Wodeyar titled ‘Krishnarajabhyudaya’. Though he lived only for 43 years, his contribution to Kannada literature was outstanding.
He wrote as many as
28 books including 11
translations, 12 works
in Sanskrit and five
works in Kannada. The
Kannada literary world
lost a valuable gem when
he passed away in
February 1891.
The then Maharaja,
recognising his service
to Kannada literature,
built a samadhi in
memory of the great
scholar. Several
programmes like
Deepotsava were held at
the samadhi premises
regularly. Subsequently,
the then Mysore Town
Municipal had allocated
some funds towards the
maintenance of the
memorial.
Over a period of time,
the significance of the
place was lost, and the
samadhi was neglected.
The surroundings of the
samadhi became a place
for dumping garbage and
a haunt for mischief
mongers and anti-social
elements.
Seeing the pathetic
condition of the samadhi
of Basavappa Shastry, a
team of five members
have formed a committee
called ‘Abhinava
Kalidasa Sri
Basavashastry Smaraka
Abhivruddhi Samiti’, to
restore the place to its
former glory. The team
comprises K M
Shivashankar, retd
principal Prof N
Girigowda, Prof S
Ramprasad, litterateur
Kempachar and veteran
photographer H N
Venkateshmurthy.
Speaking to Deccan
Herald, one of the
committee members said
several activities are
being chalked out to
give the memorial a
face-lift.
The committee, he said,
is following up with the
Mysore City Corporation,
the Mysore Urban
Development Authority
and Zilla Panchayat to
extend their helping
hand to spruce up the
memorial
Deccan Herald, 31st May 2011